The Supreme Court upheld the acquittal of two men from whom 9.6 kg of opium was recovered, holding that Section 50 of the NDPS Act was breached. A joint written notice, signed by one accused for both, is not a valid communication of the right; each person must be told individually. Offering a third option of search before a superintendent of the raiding party was also improper. Because both the bag and the persons were searched, Section 50 applied (paras 12, 14-15).
A Constitution Bench held that registration of an FIR under Section 154 CrPC is mandatory when the information discloses a cognizable offence, and no preliminary inquiry is then permissible (para 111). A limited preliminary inquiry, completed within seven days, may be held only to ascertain whether a cognizable offence is disclosed, in categories such as matrimonial, commercial, medical negligence and corruption cases or after abnormal delay (para 111). Registration of an FIR and arrest are "two entirely different concepts" (para 98).
Doubting Kanhaiyalal and Raj Kumar Karwal, a two-judge Bench referred to a larger Bench whether an NDPS investigating officer is a police officer and whether a Section 67 statement can be treated as a confession (paras 28-29, 38-40). The NDPS Act "is purely penal in nature" (para 32). The appellant's further sentence was suspended and bail granted pending the reference (para 43).
In Vijay Jain v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2013 INSC 370), the Supreme Court held that where the seized narcotic is not produced before the trial court, its non-production is not explained and the seizure witnesses do not establish the seizure, a conviction under the NDPS Act cannot be sustained. Relying on Jitendra and Ashok, and holding that Noor Aga’s rule on producing samples does not address the consequence of non-production, it set aside the brown sugar convictions of both appellants (paras 9-13).
In this 2013 ruling the Supreme Court set aside a rape conviction founded on an alleged false promise of marriage. It held that consent is vitiated only if the accused never intended to marry from the very beginning, and that a mere breach of promise differs from a false promise (paras 18, 21). The 19-year-old prosecutrix had gone with the appellant willingly to marry him, and they were caught on their way to marry at Ambala, so the false-promise allegation could not stand (paras 23-24).
In Sukhdev Singh v. State of Haryana (Criminal Appeal No. 2118 of 2008), the Supreme Court held that an officer who neither wrote down secret information nor informed his superior before a raid had totally failed to comply with Section 42 of the NDPS Act; a ruqa sent after the recovery was not substantial compliance (paras 8, 12, 21-22). Applying Karnail Singh, it set aside the conviction, acquitted the appellant and had the judgment sent to the Directors General of Police of all States (paras 19, 24-26).
The Supreme Court refused bail to men caught transporting 449 cartons of Phensedyl and Recodex cough syrup, concealed with household goods and carried without documents. The exemption for codeine preparations measured per dose applies only to therapeutic use; with nothing to show where the bulk consignment was going, the whole codeine content of each bottle counted, attracting the NDPS Act (paras 10-13).
The Supreme Court reduced the 15-year sentences of two first offenders convicted of carrying 500 g of brown sugar to the 10-year statutory minimum, and cut the imprisonment in default of the Rs 1.5 lakh fine from three years to six months. Default imprisonment is a penalty, not a sentence, and courts must weigh the offender's means before ordering it; having served nearly 12 years, the appellants were to be released (paras 9, 12, 14-15).
The Rajasthan High Court granted bail under Section 167(2) CrPC to a man from whose possession 1.500 kg of opium was recovered when two persons were apprehended on a motorcycle (paras 4, 6). The trial court had treated the recovery as commercial quantity, with 180 days to file the charge-sheet (para 2). Relying on Akhlak @ Vilasan and Smt. Anita Devi, the Court held that recovery from another person cannot be clubbed and that the limit was 60 days (paras 4-6).
In Gyan Chand v. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Criminal Appeal No. 77/2008), the Rajasthan High Court held that 2.5 kg of opium, the very quantity notified for opium, is not commercial quantity, because Section 2(viia) of the NDPS Act covers only a quantity greater than the notified figure (paras 12-15). Upholding the conviction under Section 8/18, it replaced the trial court's 10-year minimum sentence with eight years' rigorous imprisonment and a Rs 50,000 fine (paras 10, 17-18).
The Supreme Court acquitted a man convicted of carrying two kilograms of heroin because a consent memo that only asked him to choose between a Gazetted Officer and a Magistrate did not inform him of his right under Section 50 of the NDPS Act (paras 9-10, 12). On confessions to Customs officers, the Bench chose to follow Noor Aga rather than Kanhaiyalal (para 11).
The Supreme Court upheld the acquittal of a man found with 16 grams of smack in 1998, because the written Section 50 notice only told him that a Gazetted Officer or Magistrate ‘could be arranged’, not that he had a right to be searched before one (paras 20-22). It rejected the State's argument that a recovery made in breach of Section 50 can still be proved through police or independent witnesses (paras 23-25, 28).









