An eleven-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court held that compelling an accused to give specimen handwriting, signatures or finger, palm or foot impressions does not make him a witness against himself under Article 20(3) (paras 18, 36). Mere police custody or questioning is not compulsion (paras 16-17). Section 27 of the Evidence Act is valid unless the information was compelled (paras 10, 37). Article 20(3) needs the person to be an accused when he made the statement (para 20).
A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court upheld the dismissal of assault complaints against income-tax investigation officials for want of sanction under Section 197 CrPC, holding that "There must be a reasonable connection between the act and the discharge of official duty" (para 19). The need for sanction may be decided at any stage (para 20), and Section 197 does not violate Article 14 (para 14).
In M.P. Sharma v. Satish Chandra, District Magistrate, Delhi (1954 INSC 24), the Supreme Court held that a search and seizure of documents under a magistrate's warrant does not compel the accused to be a witness against himself under Article 20(3). A Bench of eight Judges, speaking through Jagannadhadas J., read the guarantee widely: to be a witness is to furnish evidence, by documents as well as by words, and the protection is available to a person against whom a formal accusation, there a First Information Report, has been made (paras 11-12). But a search warrant is addressed to an officer, and the search is not the occupier's testimonial act (para 24). The petitions were dismissed (paras 26, 28).
In Kashmira Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1952 AIR 159), the Supreme Court held that the confession of an accused is not evidence against a co-accused in the ordinary sense and cannot be the foundation of a conviction: a court must first weigh the other evidence without it and may then use the confession only to lend assurance to that evidence (paras 8-11). Applying that test, it set aside the appellant’s conviction for the murder of a five-year-old boy and convicted him only under Section 201 IPC (paras 43, 45).
In N.P. Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency (1952 AIR 64), the Supreme Court held that a candidate whose nomination paper was rejected could not seek a writ from the High Court under Article 226 while the election was in progress. A Bench of six Judges, speaking through Fazl Ali J., read election in Part XV of the Constitution in its wide sense: the entire process culminating in a candidate being declared elected (para 10). Questioning the rejection of a nomination was therefore calling the election in question, which Article 329(b) and section 80 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 allow only by an election petition after the election (paras 13, 17-18). The appeal was dismissed (para 38).
In State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar (1952 INSC 1), the Supreme Court held that section 5(1) of the West Bengal Special Courts Act, 1950, violated Article 14 so far as it let the State Government send particular cases to a Special Court with a shortened procedure. Six of the seven Judges found that the Act laid down no basis for the choice, so one accused could lose the Code's safeguards while another, similarly placed, kept them (Mahajan J., para 39; Mukherjea J., para 53; Das J., para 68). Bose J. held the whole Act bad (Bose J., para 103); Patanjali Sastri C.J. dissented. The State's appeals were dismissed.





