The Supreme Court set aside orders compelling the CBI to produce documents it had not relied on, at the stage of framing of charges. Without deciding the conflict between Debendra Nath Padhi and Sarla Gupta, it held that an accused may access documents held by the prosecution to shape the defence, but the stage depends on the document: voluminous unrelied material is inspected, and specific documents are produced at trial.
The Supreme Court set aside the appellant’s rape conviction, finding that the prosecutrix’s evidence did not inspire confidence. It reiterated that sole testimony can sustain conviction when credible, while moral disapproval cannot substitute for proof. (Paras 28–31)
The Supreme Court upheld the withdrawal of Academic Grade Pay benefits paid by mistake to teachers of a National Institute of Technology, because they had given undertakings to refund any excess. The Rafiq Masih (White Washer) exceptions did not help them, hardship was not pleaded, and the Court observed that the law on recovery of excess payments has perhaps not developed on correct lines (paras 16-26).
The Supreme Court quashed a 2012 cheating case against two directors of a steel trading company who withheld Rs 1.19 crore for TMT bars to set off a Rs 2 crore deposit they said the supplier owed them. The grievance was essentially civil, no civil suit had been filed, and using criminal proceedings to recover money was an abuse of process (paras 22, 27-30).
The Rajasthan High Court set aside a Magistrate's order, passed on a protest petition, taking cognizance only for culpable homicide in an assault death case, and the revisional order upholding it, because the Magistrate had weighed the medical evidence to rule out an intention to kill. Whether the case is murder or culpable homicide is for trial, not the cognizance stage (paras 14, 17-20).
The Supreme Court held that a victim's appeal against an acquittal recorded by a Magistrate lies to the Sessions Court, not the High Court. Under the proviso to Section 413 of the BNSS, a victim's appeal lies to the court that ordinarily hears appeals against convictions by the trial court, and Section 415(3) sends appeals from a Magistrate's conviction to the Court of Session. The Court upheld the High Court's order and allowed the petitioner to appeal to the Sessions Court within one month (paras 10-13).
The Supreme Court set aside a High Court order that had remanded a cheque-dishonour case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for fresh trial from the defence-evidence stage. The remand relied on Mandvi Cooperative Bank v. Nimesh B. Thakore, under which an accused cannot be examined on affidavit. The Court held that the ruling must be applied with reference to prejudice, which the accused had never pleaded, and restored the revision for a decision on its merits (paras 6-9).
The Supreme Court has set aside a Patwari's conviction under the Prevention of Corruption Act, holding that recovery of tainted currency alone cannot establish bribery without proof of an actual demand. Two prosecution witnesses admitted they saw neither the demand nor the money being handed over, applying the settled rule that demand is the sine qua non of the offence.
The Supreme Court held that when an accused is released because the police breached Article 22(1), by not giving written grounds of arrest, or Article 22(2), by not producing him before a Magistrate within 24 hours, the same police cannot re-arrest him on their own. Re-arrest needs the Magistrate's permission on an application made after furnishing the grounds, explaining the lapse and endorsed by a superior officer. The Court set aside the High Court's contrary order (paras 24-25, 36, 38).
The Rajasthan High Court dismissed a second bail application in a murder case filed soon after the first was rejected on merits, noting that the earlier dismissal was not disclosed. A successive application must show a substantial change in circumstances or new material; it cannot be used to re-argue the same case (paras 2-8).
The Supreme Court held that a court is not bound to send a disputed signature to a handwriting expert: under Section 72 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 it may compare signatures itself, and an expert's opinion does not bind it. Setting aside a Madhya Pradesh High Court order that called expert opinion on a Will 'essential', it restored the trial court's refusal in an eviction suit (paras 10-14).
The Rajasthan High Court upheld a Pali magistrate's order allowing the complainant in a cheque dishonour case to exhibit a bank return memo bearing the bank's seal and signature as Exhibit-9, although an unsigned computer-generated memo had already been marked Exhibit-2. This corrected an inadvertent error and did not fill a lacuna (para 8.4). Marking a document as an exhibit is not proof of it, and the accused can still cross-examine and object to its admissibility (paras 9.3, 12).





