Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Accused Entitled to Cloned Copy of CCTV Footage Filed With Charge-Sheet, Rajasthan High Court Holds
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that a DVD and pen drive of CCTV footage filed with the charge-sheet are documents that must be supplied to the accused under Section 207 CrPC. It quashed a Hindaun City trial court order of 31 July 2023 rejecting the accused's application for them (paras 3, 19). The trial court must supply a cloned copy forthwith; where the privacy of a victim or witness is involved, inspection alone may be allowed (paras 18, 20).

Newspaper Publication Without Judicial Satisfaction Is Not Valid Service: Rajasthan High Court Sets Aside Ex Parte Decree
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court set aside an ex parte decree for specific performance of an agreement to sell farmland, holding that the trial court ordered newspaper publication without the satisfaction Order V Rule 20 of the CPC requires, though the process server had reported that the defendant lived in a named Jaipur colony. Publication alone is not effective service (paras 4.7-5.5, 6.4-7).

No Pension for Widows of Railway Casual Labourers With Temporary Status: Rajasthan High Court Larger Bench
Rajasthan High Court

A three-judge Larger Bench of the Rajasthan High Court, answering a reference made in 2003, held that widows of railway casual labourers with temporary status who died before appointment to a temporary post are not entitled to pension. Following the Supreme Court's decision in Chanda Devi and Rule 1501 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual, it upheld the earlier Somati Dai view and dismissed the writ petitions (paras 1, 6-8).

Supreme Court Upholds Acquittal In Double Murder Case Over Incomplete Chain Of Circumstances
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court has upheld the acquittal of two men convicted of a double murder, dismissing the State's appeal against the High Court's benefit-of-doubt finding. It held the circumstantial evidence chain was incomplete: no eyewitness, a key witness's delayed disclosure, and recoveries made days after the arrest that appeared stage-managed and artificial.

No Chemical Report on THC: Madras High Court Grants Bail in Hydroponic Weed Airport Seizure
Madras High Court

The Madras High Court at Madurai granted bail to an air passenger after eight vacuum-sealed packets of suspected hydroponic weed were allegedly found under false bottoms in his trolley bags at Trichy airport (paras 2, 6). It extracted its own order of 02.09.2026, which had refused to treat hydroponic weed as commercial quantity on an untested THC claim, and weighed the quantity, the pending chemical analysis report, his custody and the absence of previous cases (paras 5-6).

No Mini-Trial at Charge Stage: Rajasthan High Court Upholds Corruption Charges Against Former Panchayat Samiti Members
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court dismissed revisions by two former Panchayat Samiti members against charges under the Prevention of Corruption Act and for forgery and conspiracy over alleged embezzlement in rural poverty schemes. At the charge stage the court takes the prosecution material at face value; a mini-trial or an assessment of its truth is not permitted (paras 1, 10-12, 17-20).

Wife's Murder: Acquittal Upheld as No Circumstance Proved; Appellate Court Must Prefer View Favouring Accused: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed Himachal Pradesh's appeal against a 2014 High Court judgment acquitting a labourer of murdering his wife in 2006. None of the five circumstances relied on (last seen together, suspicious conduct, soil-stained clothes, an extra-judicial confession and recovery of a knife) was proved, and together they formed no complete chain; where two views are possible, the view favouring the accused prevails (paras 7-16).

Supreme Court Acquits Two In NDPS Charas Case Over Broken Chain Of Custody Of Samples
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court has acquitted two men convicted under the NDPS Act, holding that the prosecution failed to prove the seized substance was charas. The forensic report was discarded because the chain of custody of the samples was broken, including an unexplained five-day gap, and no other admissible evidence identified the substance.

Supreme Court Restores Rs 6.11 Lakh Accident Award, Sets Aside Rajasthan High Court's Cut to Rs 3.36 Lakh
Supreme Court of India

In a claim against the Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation over the death of a 25-year-old labourer in an accident on 20.11.1997, the Supreme Court held that the Rajasthan High Court ought not to have reduced the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal's award of Rs 6,11,600 to Rs 3,36,112. It set aside the High Court's order and restored the Tribunal's award (paras 2, 5-8).

Unsigned GST Notice and Order Are Non Est: Rajasthan High Court Quashes Demand and Bank Attachment
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that a GST show cause notice and an adjudication order bearing neither a digital nor a physical signature are non est under Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules, rejecting the department's plea that an officer's digitally authenticated portal login is enough. It quashed the notice and order behind a demand of Rs 11,76,97,600, the Section 79 recovery notice and the bank attachment (paras 6, 16-17.1, 23-24).

Delhi Office No Ground to Challenge Mumbai FDA Notice: Delhi High Court Dismisses Vimal Elaichi Maker's Petition
Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court dismissed a petition by P B Agro LLP, master licensee of the "VIMAL" brand, against a show cause notice issued by the Food and Drug Administration, Mumbai, to its brand ambassadors, holding that no substantial part of the cause of action arose in Delhi (paras 1, 42-44). Maharashtra's courts were also the more convenient forum; the merits were left open (paras 43-44).

Idol-Immersion Guidelines Plea Withdrawn: Madras High Court Grants Liberty to Pursue Appropriate Remedy
Madras High Court

A Division Bench of the Madras High Court headed by the Chief Justice dismissed as withdrawn a writ petition that sought statewide enforcement of the rules on installing and immersing Vinayagar idols, after the petitioner asked to withdraw it (paras 1-2). The petitioner was given liberty to pursue an appropriate remedy in accordance with law, with no order as to costs (para 2). The written order gives no other reasons.

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt