Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Procedural Lapse in Government-Formed Selection Committee Cannot Oust Live Stock Inspectors After 18 Years: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court allowed three appeals and held that Live Stock Inspectors selected in 2006 and appointed in 2008 may continue in service, setting aside the Orissa Administrative Tribunal and High Court decisions that upheld their 2012 termination over the make-up of the Selection Committee; the State now supports them. A natural-justice defect may make a decision void ab initio or only voidable, it said, and the appointees were not at fault because the Government itself had constituted the committee (paras 3-5, 9-12).

SARFAESI Auction Held in Breach of Restraint, 30-Day Rule and Bid Terms Set Aside: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside IFCI's 2011 SARFAESI auction of the Fernhill resort at Ooty and the sale certificate issued to M/s P.M. Associates. The bid was received while a DRAT restraint was in force, the sale was concluded before the 30-day notice period ran out, the borrower was not told of the bid opening, and the certificate went to a firm that neither bid nor existed on the auction date (paras 31-32, 36).

NCLT Can Recall Insolvency Admitted on Collusive Debt Claim, but May Continue CIRP for Creditors: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that the NCLT can recall the admission of an insolvency application when the debt behind it is shown to be fraudulent and collusive, since a debt is a jurisdictional fact. Because an admitted CIRP becomes a proceeding in rem for all creditors, the NCLT may still continue it without the collusive applicant. The Greenopolis housing project's CIRP was restored to the NCLT to decide that question (paras 28-30, 45, 49-50).

Disputed Overpayment Cannot Be Recovered From Bills Under Other Contracts Without Hearing: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed a Chhattisgarh rural roads agency order that withheld Rs 84.17 lakh from a contractor's bills under three ongoing PMGSY contracts to recover an alleged overpayment on earlier, separate works. None of the contract clauses relied on authorised it, the audit clause required a hearing and the CEO's orders, and an unadjudicated claim is not a debt presently due.

Cheque Bounce Notice Received by Family Member at Correct Address Is Valid; M.D. Thomas Per Incuriam: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court restored a cheque-dishonour conviction that the Kerala High Court had set aside because the statutory demand notice was received by the accused's mother, not by him. Once the notice is sent by registered post to the drawer's correct address, service is presumed and the drawer must rebut it (paras 24, 32, 35). The Court declared M.D. Thomas v. P.S. Jaleel, which had held service on the drawer's wife insufficient, per incuriam (para 30).

Delay Alone Cannot Defeat Substantive Right: Supreme Court Allows Condonation in Second Appeal Against Ex Parte Reversal
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside a Himachal Pradesh High Court order of 10.04.2025 that refused to condone the delay in a plaintiff's second appeal, after finding that the first appellate court had reversed the plaintiff's partial decree ex parte. The length of the delay alone cannot defeat a substantive right, especially where a Trial Court decision is reversed, and courts should not be pedantic under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, it held (paras 2, 8-10).

MD on Election Duty Was 'Sufficient Cause': Supreme Court Condones 130-Day Delay by UP Co-operative Federation, With Costs
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that the Allahabad High Court should have condoned a 130-day delay by the UP Co-operative Federation in filing intra-court appeals, as its Managing Director, whose approval was needed, was away as an election observer during the 2024 Lok Sabha elections. The cause, not the length, of delay matters. The appeals will be heard on merits once the Federation pays ₹2,000 costs to each writ applicant (paras 6, 9-10).

Contract Dispute Not Cheating: Supreme Court Quashes Case Against Tea Company CEO Over ₹40 Lakh MoU
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed a cheating complaint under Sections 417 and 420 IPC against the CEO of a tea company who signed an MoU for a tea estate on the company's behalf. The ₹40 lakh was paid to the company, the complainant already knew of the bank mortgage, and a bare assertion that he knew the representation was false did not show dishonest intention at the inception; the dispute was predominantly contractual (paras 7-11).

Second Suit for Specific Performance After Injunction Suit Barred by Order II Rule 2 CPC: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed a suit for specific performance of an alleged oral agreement to sell land, reversing concurrent decrees. The plaintiff had earlier sued only for an injunction when specific performance was already available and took no leave, so Order II Rule 2 CPC barred the second suit; liberty granted on withdrawal could not cure that. In any case, no concluded oral contract was proved (paras 24-27, 39-40).

Uniform Rs 5 Lakh an Acre Restored for Lands Acquired for Drain; Severance on Unacquired Land: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

In 47 appeals by landowners whose land in six Fazilka villages was acquired in 2000-01 for the Aspal Extension Drain, the Supreme Court restored the Reference Court's uniform Rs 5 lakh an acre and 50% severance charges on the unacquired land, rejecting the High Court's distance-based rates. It upheld the High Court on fruit trees (280 pleaded trees only), tubewells (Rs 50,000 each) and the bar on solatium and additional amount on such items (paras 5.4.6, 7.9, 11).

No Cattle-Transport Conviction Without Proof of Slaughter Purpose; Reverse Burden Needs Ingredients Proved: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside a conviction under the Chhattisgarh Agricultural Cattle Preservation Act, 2004 for transporting 32 bullocks towards Odisha. Section 6 requires transport for slaughter, and apart from the Head Constable's presumption nothing showed that purpose; a veterinary doctor found the animals fit for ploughing. The reverse burden in Section 11 arises only after the essential ingredients are proved, and the lack of transport documents does not prove slaughter (paras 8-10).

Juvenile Convicted of Murder: Children's Court Must Give Reasons for Fixed-Term Sentence, Rajasthan High Court Holds
Rajasthan High Court

On a State appeal against sentence, the Rajasthan High Court held that Section 21 of the Juvenile Justice Act bars only death and life imprisonment without the possibility of release for a child in conflict with law, so life imprisonment with the possibility of release remains available. The Children's Court had imposed ten years' rigorous imprisonment for murder without giving any reason, so the sentence was set aside and the matter remanded for fresh sentencing (paras 6-7).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt