Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Bail Granted on Suppressed Facts Recalled: Calcutta High Court Applies Zeba Khan to NDPS Bail
Calcutta High Court

The Calcutta High Court, in a revision registered on its own motion, recalled and cancelled the bail it had granted on 24.08.2026 in an NDPS brown-sugar case (paras 2, 6, 9). Both sides had told the Court that only Rs. 4 lakh, and no contraband, was recovered from the accused, but the case diary showed 446 grams of brown sugar seized from him as well (paras 2-3). Applying Zeba Khan, the Court held that material facts had been suppressed (paras 4-5).

Bigamy Complaint Against Constable Husband and 498A Case Ending in Acquittal Are Cruelty: Rajasthan High Court Dissolves Marriage
Rajasthan High Court

A Rajasthan High Court Division Bench allowed a husband's appeal against the Family Court's refusal of divorce and dissolved the marriage (paras 1, 20). It held that the wife's bigamy complaint against him, a police constable, closed by an accepted negative final report, and her Section 498A case ending in his acquittal amounted to cruelty, as did more than 15 years of separation; it also found that she had deserted him without justified reason (paras 14-17).

Consenting Adults in Live-in Relationship Entitled to Police Protection: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court at Jaipur held that consenting adults in a live-in relationship are entitled to police protection, because choosing a partner is a personal freedom protected by the Constitution (para 5). Family disapproval cannot by itself justify interference with their life and liberty (para 6). The couple's writ petition was disposed of with a direction to the police to enquire into the alleged threat (para 7).

SC Woman in 2020, OBC Woman in 2026: Rajasthan High Court Upholds Sarpanch Reservation Rotation
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court upheld the reservation of the office of Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat Manchi for an OBC woman in the 2026 Panchayati Raj elections, although the same office had been reserved for an SC woman in 2020 (paras 1-2, 21). Reservation for women is horizontal and runs across the vertical SC, ST and Backward Class categories, so an earlier reservation for women does not by itself bar a later one (paras 14, 19). The writ petition was dismissed (para 22).

GST Reimbursement Claim Not Covered by Arbitration Clause: Supreme Court Restores Contractor’s Writ Petition
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that a contractor's claim for refund of GST, based on a contract clause promising reimbursement of service tax if it became applicable, does not fall within the contract's arbitration clause. The Chhattisgarh High Court was therefore wrong to dismiss the contractor's writ petition on that ground; the petition was restored for a fresh hearing on merits (paras 7-10).

No Specific Role, No Defamation Case: Rajasthan High Court Quashes 2003 Complaint Against Rajasthan Patrika and Its Editor
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court quashed criminal defamation proceedings pending since 2003 against Rajasthan Patrika and its Editor-in-Chief over a local news report, holding that neither the complaint nor the evidence attributed any specific role or intention to them, and that a newspaper company is not liable without proof of its management's knowledge. Cognizance without the ingredients of defamation undermines press freedom (paras 35-42, 49-50).

Inadmissible Section 67 Confession Is No Ground to Quash a Pending NDPS Case: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside a Karnataka High Court order quashing an NDPS case against an accused who fled the spot where 32.615 kg of ganja was seized. The rulings it relied on, starting with Tofan Singh, concerned convictions or bail cancellation, not a pending trial (para 11). A Section 67 confession or Section 53A disclosure has no evidentiary value at trial, but it is material the investigator may use to gather further evidence (para 13). The case was restored (para 15).

Complaint Filed to Coerce Marriage Is Abuse of Process: Supreme Court Quashes Rape FIR After Soured Relationship
Supreme Court of India

Applying the four-step test in Pradeep Kumar Kesarwani, the Supreme Court quashed a rape FIR and chargesheet after what it found was a consensual relationship that "went sour" (paras 4, 13). The complainant did not allege a promise of marriage used to entice her into a sexual relationship; the rape allegation came more than one and a half years later, and the complaint was filed specifically to coerce the appellant into marrying her (paras 8-9).

A Criminal Prosecution Cannot Be a Strong-Arm Tactic: Supreme Court Quashes False Promise of Marriage Case
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed a chargesheet accusing a man of sexually exploiting a woman on the pretext of marriage after their consensual relationship of about three years ended. Applying Deepak Gulati v. State of Haryana, it held that consent under fear or misconception cannot be loosely inferred where both parties admittedly chose the relationship. The complaint showed no clear promise of marriage, the allegation was "clearly an afterthought", and a criminal prosecution "cannot be reduced to a strong-arm tactic" (para 7).

Supreme Court Grants Bail in 27 kg Ganja Case, Citing Custody Period, Slow Trial and Article 21
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court granted bail to a man held for about one year and four months in an NDPS case involving an alleged 27 kg of ganja-patti, after the Punjab and Haryana High Court had refused it. Weighing the period in custody and the time the trial will take, the Court kept in mind Article 21 and the principle of Section 37 of the NDPS Act and enlarged him on bail on conditions to be set by the trial court (paras 3, 5-6).

Supreme Court Acquits Man in Child Rape-Murder Case: Recovered Bones Were Male, Last-Seen Evidence Unproved
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside the life sentence of a man convicted of raping and murdering his young niece in Sikkim in 2013, holding that the chain of circumstances was broken at several points. No witness saw him take the child, the recovery spot was open to passers-by, the bones recovered were of male origin, the forensic tests were inconclusive, and his Section 313 answers could not fill the gaps.

Unexplained Recording of Convenient Witnesses Dents Credibility: Supreme Court Upholds Acquittal in Double Murder
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed Himachal Pradesh's appeal against the acquittal of a woman accused of strangling her step-mother and minor step-brother. The last-seen witness had improved on his police statement, the investigating officer never explained why or when he recorded the taxi driver and hotel worker, tower locations were never collected, and a DNA match on a trunk showed only that the accused, a regular visitor, had been there at some point.

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt