Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Supreme Court Dismisses Sumit Roy's Plea Against Calcutta High Court Order, Vacates His Interim Protection
Supreme Court of India

A three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court headed by the Chief Justice dismissed Sumit Roy's special leave petition against the Calcutta High Court's order of 03.08.2026 in CRM (A) No. 1748/2026, declining to interfere having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances, and vacated the interim protection earlier granted to him (paras 2-3). The order records no further reasons.

Rajasthan High Court Lets Assistant Professor (English) Recruitment Proceed but Bars Final Result Over Answer-Key Objections
Rajasthan High Court

In an interim order, the Rajasthan High Court at Jaipur issued notice on a candidate's challenge to the recruitment for Assistant Professor (English) and allowed the selection process to continue, but directed that the final result of the selected candidates shall not be declared (paras 2-3). The petition is pending; the order records the petitioner's case and decides nothing on merits (para 1).

Marital Rape Exception: Supreme Court Posts Challenges Under IPC and BNS for Final Hearing on 18 November
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court posted the batch of cases on Exception 2 to Section 375 of the IPC and Exception 2 to Section 63 of the BNS, the marital rape exception, for final hearing on 18.11.2026. The Solicitor General stated that the Union's counter affidavit in the lead case may serve as its reply in the connected matters, and nodal counsel were asked to compile the pleadings and judgments (paras 1-4). Nothing was decided on the merits.

Promoted Officer Cannot Be Branded Deadwood Months Later: Supreme Court Quashes Compulsory Retirement, Awards ₹15 Lakh
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside the compulsory retirement under FR 56(j) of an Indian Trade Service officer, ordered on 10.05.2018 within months of his promotion to the Senior Administrative Grade, holding it vitiated by malice in law (paras 24, 49, 65). It awarded ₹9 lakh for loss of reputation and ₹6 lakh costs, full service benefits including notional promotion, and directed that he be given a farewell with full honour (paras 67-69).

Supreme Court Allows Himachal to Withdraw Remaining Covid-Era Prosecutions of Sitting and Former Legislators
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court allowed an appeal by the State of Himachal Pradesh and permitted it to withdraw prosecution in all the remaining cases against sitting and former MPs and MLAs arising from the Covid-19 period. The High Court had allowed withdrawal in only 15 of 60 cases. The Bench found no grave offence alleged and held that continuing such prosecutions would serve neither criminal justice nor the public interest (paras 4, 6-9).

Paying Probationers 70-80-90% of Pay Is Discriminatory: MP High Court Strikes Down Rules, Orders Full Salary
Madhya Pradesh High Court

A Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court headed by the Acting Chief Justice struck down the rules and circulars under which directly recruited Class III and IV employees were paid 70%, 80% and 90% of the minimum pay scale in their three years of probation (paras 7-8). Holding that full work must bring full pay and that the scheme discriminated against them, it ordered full salary for the probation period (paras 5, 8).

Rising Drug Dependence in Punjab Jails Prima Facie a ‘Serious Malaise’: Punjab & Haryana High Court Seeks Affidavits
Punjab and Haryana High Court

In a suo motu public interest case on drug-dependent jail inmates, the Punjab and Haryana High Court said Punjab's figures prima facie indicated "a serious malaise" (paras 1-3). By an interim order it asked Punjab to explain its action under Rule 29.22 of the Punjab Prison Rules, Haryana to file a further affidavit on counsellors and its SOP, the Union of India to place on record its methodology, and PGIMER to outline a medical protocol (paras 6, 9-10, 12-13). The matter is pending.

Long Custody, Parity and a Slow Trial: Punjab & Haryana High Court Grants Bail, Suggests Antecedents Database
Punjab and Haryana High Court

The Punjab and Haryana High Court granted regular bail to a petitioner accused of conniving with a co-accused to get multiple cases registered in Punjab and Delhi on false allegations of rape to extort money (para 2). It relied on about two years and five months in custody, bail to both co-accused, offences triable by a Magistrate and only 2 of 30 witnesses examined (para 8). Before parting, it said a national-level portal of antecedents in repeated-complaint cases needed consideration (para 9).

Honey Trap No Excuse for Sharing Air Force Station Photos With Pakistan-Based Contact: P&H High Court Denies Bail
Punjab and Haryana High Court

The Punjab and Haryana High Court refused regular bail to a man accused under the Official Secrets Act and Section 152 BNS of sharing photographs of the Air Force Station, Ambala Cantt, including Rafale jets, with a woman whose numbers operated from Pakistan (paras 1-2, 9). Even if it was a honey trap, the Court said, there was no occasion to share such photographs with an unknown person (para 6).

Delhi High Court Bars GST Registration Without Biometric Aadhaar Authentication for the Time Being Over PAN Misuse
Delhi High Court

In an interim order, the Delhi High Court directed authorities across the country, for the time being, not to allow any GST registration without biometric-based Aadhaar authentication. The petitions allege fraudulent GST registrations made in innocent persons' names using their PAN and Aadhaar details. The Bench gave the authorities liberty to object on practical difficulties and listed the matter again (paras 1, 8-10). The petition remains pending.

Aerial Distance Counts for Highway Liquor Rule: Madras High Court Orders TASMAC Shop Closed, Bars Club Licence
Madras High Court

A Division Bench of the Madras High Court at Madurai ordered closure of a TASMAC liquor shop at Vellithirumutham, Trichy, and barred an FL-2 licence for a recreation club nearby, holding that the distance from a National Highway is the aerial distance, not the road distance a vehicle must travel (paras 13, 15). At 55.7 and 71 metres, both fell within the Supreme Court's 220-metre limit in K. Balu (paras 12-13).

Food Licence Suspension Cannot Continue After ‘Exemplar’ Re-Inspection: Bombay High Court Restores Hotel's Licence
Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court at Kolhapur restored a hotel's food licence, holding that a suspension imposed forthwith to protect public health cannot continue once a re-inspection scores the establishment 97%, ‘exemplar’ on the authorities' own grading (paras 17, 30). The appellate authority had not considered the re-inspection report, and other breaches attract penalties under Sections 55 and 63, not continued suspension (paras 21, 29).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt