Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Samman Nidhi Is a Debt of Gratitude, Not a Dole: Supreme Court Grants Freedom Fighter's Widow Her Pension
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court restored a Single Judge's order granting Samman Nidhi to the widow of a Maihar Praja Mandal activist jailed in 1946, holding that the freedom fighter's pension is a constitutional debt of gratitude, not a bounty. Such claims cannot be defeated merely by delay, are judged on probabilities, and, given her age, the State must comply within four weeks (paras 10-19).

Excise-Duty Restrictions Do Not Bar CENVAT Credit of CVD on Imported Coal: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court dismissed five appeals by the Revenue against Hindustan Zinc Ltd., holding that the company was entitled to CENVAT credit of the 1%/2% additional duty of customs (CVD) paid on imported steam coal under Customs Notification No. 12/2012-Cus (para 16). It upheld the Tribunal's finding that the conditions attached to excise-duty credit under Rule 3(1)(i) had wrongly been read into the credit of CVD (paras 12-13).

Vague Eligibility Criterion Benefits the Candidate: Supreme Court Restores Librarian's Selection, Faults High Court for Doing Employer's Job
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that ambiguity or vagueness in an eligibility criterion in a recruitment advertisement must be construed in favour of a candidate who prima facie holds the qualifications, and that the High Court wrongly decided for itself whether experience gained while studying counted. The Tribunal's direction to offer the appellant the post of Librarian was restored, but without back seniority and pay fixation (paras 3, 8-9).

Preventive Policing Must Work on the Ground, Not on Paper: Supreme Court Issues Fresh Delhi Safety Directions
Supreme Court of India

In its suo motu case on recent rape incidents in Delhi NCR, the Supreme Court issued further interim directions on preventive policing: enhanced beat patrolling near educational institutions, verified and visibly identified drivers of buses, cabs and auto-rickshaws, SOS awareness, removal of habitually parked heavy vehicles and action against unlicensed liquor outlets. The Chief Secretary and the Police Commissioner will be personally answerable; the matter returns on 16.11.2026 (paras 16, 24, 30).

No Trial Decades After 1999 Discharge: Supreme Court Restores Prison Guard's Discharge Set Aside by Gujarat High Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside a 2025 Gujarat High Court judgment that had revived the prosecution of a prison sipahi discharged in 1999 in a 1998 arms and explosives case. The High Court faulted the trial court for ignoring a precedent that did not exist in 1999, and in any event a trial at this distance of time would not serve the interest of justice (paras 2, 6-9).

Tax Follows the Form at Sale, Not End Use: Supreme Court Rules Drink-Mix Powder Is Not a Beverage
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that ‘GRD Powder’ and ‘GRD Mix’, sold as powder and biscuit, are not ‘non-alcoholic drinks and beverages’ under Entry 20(ii) of the Madhya Pradesh Commercial Tax Act, 1994 and fall in the residuary entry. The taxable event is the sale, so classification turns on the form of the goods when sold, not the consumer's later use (paras 16-19, 29). Read ejusdem generis, ‘beverages’ covers liquids (paras 20, 23). The State's appeals were dismissed (para 31).

Civil Dispute Cannot Wear Criminal Colour: Supreme Court Quashes Cheating FIR Against Power-of-Attorney Holder
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed a cheating FIR against the power-of-attorney holder of landowners, after the High Court had quashed the same FIR for the landowners but refused the holder relief. The buyers had not acted on their 2012 sale agreement for years; the land was sold to another in 2016, and only then did they sue and complain (paras 3-4). The holder's culpability could not exceed the landowners', and it was "a classic case of casting the shadow of criminality on a pure civil dispute" (paras 17-18).

In-Laws Cannot Be Dragged Into Dowry Case on Omnibus Allegations: Supreme Court Quashes FIR
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed a Section 498A IPC and Dowry Prohibition Act case against a woman's parents-in-law, holding that the allegations against them were vague and omnibus, attributed no specific overt act, and had no support beyond her own complaint and her parents' statements (paras 25-26). Applying Bhajan Lal, Arti Mehta and Geddam Jhansi, it said criminal law must not reach every family member without a clear factual foundation (paras 16-17, 26). The case against the husband was untouched (para 27).

Mere Recovery of Tainted Money Cannot Prove Bribery Without Demand and Acceptance: Supreme Court Acquits Public Servant
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside the Prevention of Corruption Act conviction of an Assistant in the District Education Office, Saraikella, holding that the prosecution failed to prove demand and acceptance of the bribe. No trap witness saw the demand or the handing over of ₹5,000; the case rested only on the complainant's uncorroborated word (para 18), and recovery of the notes could not make up for it (paras 19-23). He had already served his sentence but pursued the appeal to clear his name (para 3).

Co-operative Society's Losses No Ground to Deny Employees Revised Pay Scales: Rajasthan High Court Quashes Registrar's Order
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that employees of a co-operative federation cannot be denied revised pay scales on the ground that the society runs at a loss, and that the denial violated Articles 14 and 21 (para 26). Quashing the Registrar's order of 30.12.2015, it held the members of the employees' union entitled to the benefits of the Rules of 2008, later pay revisions and selection scales after 9, 18 and 27 years of service (para 31).

Voluntary Retirement Can Be Withdrawn Before Its Date, but Writ Court Cannot Order Unsought Reinstatement: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

A Rajasthan High Court Division Bench held that a government servant who asked, before the date fixed for his voluntary retirement, to defer it had in effect withdrawn the notice, so the State could not retire him on that date (paras 15-18). But the Single Judge should not have ordered reinstatement, which the writ petition never sought (paras 20-22). The order was modified and both appeals disposed of (paras 23-24).

Name Error in Service Record Left Uncorrected: Rajasthan High Court Imposes Rs 10,000 Costs on State
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court imposed costs of Rs 10,000 on the State for forcing a Prabodhak to litigate for the correction of her name in her service record, a clerical mistake the department had made and fixed only after the Court issued notice (paras 9-10, 15). Calling it culpable inaction, the Court allowed the State to recover the costs from the official responsible after a show cause notice (paras 11, 15).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt