In a reference order, the Rajasthan High Court found that a co-ordinate Bench, when it dismissed a finance company's connected appeal against the same motor accident award in 2012, had not been shown Sections 146 and 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 or the Supreme Court's ruling in Godavari Finance Company (paras 10-11). Instead of taking a contrary view itself, it referred two questions to a Special/Larger Bench and sent the matter to the Chief Justice (paras 19-21).
A Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court dismissed Jaipur National University's challenge to the second proviso to Regulation 3(A) of the UGC (Open and Distance Learning Programmes and Online Programmes) Regulations, 2020, which let only institutions that had applied to NAAC by 29.02.2020 continue distance-learning programmes for 2020-21 (paras 19, 48-49). It held that compliant and non-compliant institutions formed distinct classes, the cut-off date had a rational basis, and the proviso caused no prohibited retrospective prejudice (paras 40-41, 44-45).
The Rajasthan High Court set aside the confiscation of a truck seized with Khair wood under the Rajasthan Forest Act, 1953. Confiscation proceedings run parallel to the trial and need not await a conviction, it held, but Section 52(5) bars confiscating a vehicle used without the owner's knowledge or connivance. The Authorised Officer had recorded exactly that finding and still confiscated the truck because forest offences were rising, an order the Court called void (paras 22, 24, 28-30).
A Constitution Bench held that there was no real conflict between the Kothari Products and Agra Belting Works lines of cases on taxing goods such as pan masala with tobacco, so the reference was incompetent and the appeals go back to a regular Bench. On the second question, it held that a majority decision of a larger Bench prevails over a smaller Bench, whatever the number of judges in the majority (paras 17, 19-20).
The Rajasthan High Court quashed a second Anti Corruption Bureau FIR against a Biofuel Authority CEO, registered six days after a trap case against him, alleging another bribe. Because Section 219 CrPC allowed the two like offences, committed within twelve months, to be tried together, and both FIRs alleged the same conspiracy, the second FIR was an abuse of process (paras 15-16). Without Section 17A approval it could not be investigated either (para 18).
The Rajasthan High Court quashed the Regional Passport Officer's rejection of a woman's passport application. An email gave her 21 days to respond while a show-cause notice of the same date allowed only 7; the Court held this self-contradictory and a sign of predetermination (paras 37-39). Her case fell within none of the grounds in Section 6(2) of the Passports Act, 1967, and the passport authority could not treat as fraudulent a birth certificate issued by the competent authority once the earlier one had been cancelled (paras 43-48).
On a newspaper report that the State planned to shrink the Eco-Sensitive Zone of Tal Chhapar Wildlife Sanctuary to 3 km, the Rajasthan High Court registered a suo moto PIL and barred any attempt to reduce the sanctuary's area (paras 2-3, 23). Finding a dire need to enlarge the 7.19 sq. km. home of about 4000 blackbucks, it struck down the renotification of a road through it and ordered land merged into forest (paras 17, 23). Compliance monitoring continues.
The Rajasthan High Court allowed an accused husband, on trial under Sections 304-B and 498-A IPC, to undergo a voluntary narco-analysis test at the defence stage. Section 233 CrPC gives an accused who is not acquitted under Section 232 an indefeasible right to lead defence evidence, and refusing a scientific technique that Selvi permits on a voluntary basis would deprive him of his right to defend himself (paras 14-16). The trial court's refusal was set aside (para 17).
The Supreme Court held that a PGIMER nursing officer was entitled to maternity leave under Rule 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules for her first biological child, even though her husband had two children from his earlier marriage for whom she had taken child care leave. Reading the rule purposively, it said that maternity leave and child care leave are distinct, and that the law must account for families that change or do not fit the usual mould (paras 23-28).
The Rajasthan High Court dismissed two writ petitions by 16 students admitted to the 2017 MDS course at a private dental college outside NEET counselling, most without the qualifying score, and upheld the Dental Council of India's 2018 decision to discharge them (paras 71, 88-91, 135). Such per se illegal admissions cannot be regularised, and students who gave false NEET information could not claim a hearing (paras 91, 119-121, 134). The College must pay each student Rs.10 lakh as compensation (para 135).
A three-Judge Bench rejected the constitutional challenges to the Prevention of Money-Laundering Act, 2002, including Sections 5, 8(4), 17, 18, 19, 24, 45, 50 and 63 (para 187). The amended twin bail conditions in Section 45 are valid and apply even to anticipatory bail, but Section 436A CrPC remains available (paras 141, 149, 187). Enforcement Directorate officers are not police officers, Section 50 statements are not hit by Article 20(3), and an ECIR is not an FIR (paras 172, 179).
In an interim order, the Supreme Court allowed an unmarried woman whose pregnancy had passed twenty weeks to seek its termination before an AIIMS Medical Board. It found prima facie that the 2021 amendment, which replaced 'husband' with 'partner', shows that Parliament did not intend to confine the law to married women, and that the High Court read Rule 3B too narrowly (paras 14-16, 21-22).




