A Constitution Bench held that Article 19(2) lists the only grounds on which free speech may be restricted, and that rights under Articles 19 and 21 can be enforced against persons other than the State (Ramasubramanian J., paras 45, 78). A Minister's statement cannot be attributed vicariously to the Government through collective responsibility (Ramasubramanian J., para 137). Nagarathna J. agreed on Article 19(2) but differed on horizontal enforcement, the State's duty, vicarious attribution and constitutional tort (Nagarathna J., para 6).
By a 4:1 majority the Supreme Court upheld the 8 November 2016 notification demonetising Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 notes. The majority held that Section 26(2) of the RBI Act permits demonetising all series, is not excessive delegation, and that the decision-making, proportionality and 52-day exchange window were lawful. Justice Nagarathna held the notification unlawful because the proposal came from the Centre, but only prospectively (majority, para 304; Nagarathna J., para 21).
The Rajasthan High Court set aside the refusal of compassionate appointment to a widow whose mother-in-law, a ‘Coolie’ in the respondent department, died in harness in 2007 (paras 1-2, 12). Applying Smt. Pinki, it held that the 1996 Compassionate Appointment Rules are a beneficial piece of legislation to be interpreted harmoniously, so a widowed daughter-in-law is part of ‘widowed daughter’ in Rule 2(c) (paras 9-11). The respondents were directed to consider her case within 30 days (para 13).
A five-judge Constitution Bench held that if the complainant dies, turns hostile or is otherwise unavailable, the demand and acceptance of a bribe can still be proved through other witnesses, documents or circumstantial evidence, and the trial does not end in acquittal for that reason alone (paras 68, 70). Proof of demand and acceptance remains a sine qua non, and there was no conflict between B. Jayaraj, P. Satyanarayana Murthy and M. Narsinga Rao (paras 68-69).
The Rajasthan High Court dismissed a writ petition by four general-category candidates who wanted reserved-category candidates who had qualified NET/SLET/SET with relaxed marks kept out of unreserved Assistant Professor posts in the RPSC recruitment of 2020. NET/SLET/SET is only a condition of eligibility; merit rests on the written examination and interview, so a relaxation at that stage does not tie a candidate to the reserved category (paras 31, 35, 44). The petition was also premature (paras 41, 45).
A Constitution Bench held that a trial court may summon an additional accused under Section 319 CrPC only before it pronounces the sentence after a conviction, or before it acquits. A summoning order passed after the trial ends is not sustainable, and evidence from a concluded main trial cannot be used in a split-up trial. It laid down step-by-step guidelines for pausing the trial and deciding on a joint or separate trial (para 33).
The Rajasthan High Court quashed a 1990 conviction for 8.5 kg of opium, holding that police who set out to search a shop and house needed a warrant or recorded grounds under Section 42 of the NDPS Act, even though the accused was caught on the road outside. The Court found the recovery proved and Section 50 complied with, but the Section 42 breach made the search void (paras 32, 48, 53-61).
The Rajasthan High Court dismissed an Environment Engineer's writ petition against the sanction to prosecute him under the Prevention of Corruption Act. The Anti Corruption Bureau had sent a draft sanction order, but the sanctioning authority had weighed the witnesses' evidence and the documents, and its order was not a verbatim copy of the draft (paras 6, 15). Trivial errors in dates and names caused no failure of justice, so the cognizance order stood (paras 12, 16-17).
A Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court at Jodhpur held that a woman claiming a post reserved for divorcees must hold a divorce decree from a competent court on the cut-off date. A customary divorce, even in Scheduled Tribe/Tribal Sub Plan communities, cannot replace the decree, because a custom cannot supersede the terms of a recruitment process (paras 14-15). The appeals of the Public Service Commission and the State were allowed and the Single Bench judgments set aside (para 17).
By 3:2 the Supreme Court upheld the 103rd Amendment, which lets the State reserve up to ten per cent in education and public jobs for economically weaker sections other than SCs, STs and non-creamy-layer OBCs. The majority held that economic criteria, the exclusion and exceeding fifty per cent do not breach the basic structure. Justice Bhat, with Chief Justice Lalit, accepted economic criteria but held the exclusion unconstitutional (Maheshwari J., para 104; Bhat J., para 195).
The Rajasthan High Court allowed 56 State appeals against Indus Tower Ltd. and held that the stamp duty concession notification of 05.03.2003 covers only leases where the rent is fixed and no premium is paid or delivered, the class in clause (a) of Article 33 of the Schedule to the Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1998. A lease that stipulates a security deposit falls under clause (c) and outside the notification; holding otherwise would add words to it (paras 28, 30, 32).
Answering questions framed by a coordinate Bench, the Supreme Court held that once a Chemical Examiner finds morphine and meconic acid in seized poppy straw, it is covered by Section 2(xvii)(a) of the NDPS Act and no further test is needed to show that it came from papaver somniferum L. It set aside the Himachal Pradesh High Court's acquittal of a woman found with bags of poppy husk and remanded the appeal (paras 1, 89-95).





