Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Prayer to Declare Later Sale Deed Void Is Ancillary; Court Fee Only on Specific Performance: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

Answering a reference prompted by conflicting Single Bench rulings, a Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court held that in a suit for specific performance a prayer to declare the subsequent sale deed null and void is only an ancillary relief. Under the proviso to Section 6(1) of the Rajasthan Court Fee and Suits Valuation Act, 1961, court fee is payable only on the main relief; Section 38, governing cancellation suits, does not apply (paras 1, 17-19).

Calling Article 370 Abrogation a 'Black Day' Is Protected Dissent, Not Promoting Enmity: Supreme Court Quashes FIR
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed an FIR under Section 153-A IPC against a college professor whose WhatsApp status called 5 August a 'Black Day' for Jammu and Kashmir, said he was not happy with the abrogation of Article 370 and wished Pakistan a happy Independence Day. Criticism of a State decision is protected by Article 19(1)(a), and the effect of words is judged by reasonable people, not weak minds (paras 10-12, 15).

Five-Year, Magistrate-Triable GST Offence Is No Automatic Ground for Bail: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused bail to a man accused of running 294 fake firms to pass about Rs.1,032 crores of inadmissible input tax credit (paras 4, 14). That an offence under Section 132 of the CGST Act carries five years and is triable by a Magistrate is no automatic ground for bail; each application turns on its own facts and evidence (para 12). Economic offences call for a different approach, and a similarly placed co-accused had been refused bail (paras 7-9, 13).

Legislators Taking Bribes Get No Immunity Under Articles 105 and 194; PV Narasimha Rao Overruled: Seven-Judge Bench
Supreme Court of India

A seven-Judge Bench unanimously held that a Member of Parliament or of a State Legislature who accepts a bribe to vote or speak in a particular way cannot claim immunity from prosecution under Articles 105(2) and 194(2) of the Constitution. Bribery is not 'in respect of' anything said or any vote given, and the offence is complete when the bribe is accepted. The majority view in PV Narasimha Rao was overruled (paras 113, 188).

Accused Can Seek Police Officers’ Call Records Before Defence Stage to Save Them From Deletion: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court allowed two NDPS accused to have the call data records and tower locations of the police officers named in the seizure memo summoned and preserved before the defence stage. Saving such data from deletion is not taking defence evidence prematurely, it held. The trial court must have the records procured and kept on file with a Section 65-B certificate, and the accused may confront the officers with them (paras 12-13, 15, 21-22).

Recruiter May Revise Exam Result Flawed by Software Error; Wrongly Selected Candidates Have No Right: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

A Rajasthan High Court Division Bench dismissed twelve writ petitions by Stenographer Grade-III candidates who lost their places when the High Court revised the 2021 shorthand-test results. A software error had awarded marks on the words typed instead of applying the prescribed formula, and correcting it was justified (paras 10-11, 13, 17). The first result created no right (para 15), and the formula, part of the method of evaluation, did not change the rules of the game (para 19).

Unexplained Third Sample and No Section 52A Inventory: Supreme Court Acquits Three in 80 kg Ganja Case
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court acquitted three men convicted of carrying about 80 kg of ganja in Hyderabad. The weight included unseparated green chillies, three samples reached the laboratory although one of three had been given to the accused, the ganja was repacked into unsealed bags, and no Section 52A sampling was done, so the FSL report was worthless. Two appellants were convicted only on co-accused's interrogation notes (paras 19-25).

State Cannot Demand Own 100-Bed Hospital for Nursing College NOC Beyond INC Regulations: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court dismissed the State's special appeals and upheld the quashing of a condition in its policy of 07.06.2022 that a nursing college must have its own 100-bed hospital to obtain a no-objection certificate for opening or adding seats. The Indian Nursing Council's Regulations of 2020 already require a 100-bed parent hospital, and the State's stricter administrative condition contravened them (paras 8, 12-14.1, 20).

No Automatic Vacation of High Court Stay Orders After Six Months: Constitution Bench Revisits Asian Resurfacing
Supreme Court of India

A five-Judge Constitution Bench held that interim orders of stay granted by High Courts cannot lapse automatically on the expiry of six months, and declined to concur with the contrary directions issued in Asian Resurfacing (Oka J., para 36). Blanket directions of that kind, and directions to decide every stayed case day-to-day within a fixed time, cannot be issued under Article 142 (Oka J., para 36). Both referred questions were answered in the negative (Oka J., para 36).

Clubbing Left to Trial, Bail Granted: Delhi High Court Cites Section 52A Doubts and Three Years' Custody
Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court granted bail to two men from whom 12 kg of ganja each was allegedly recovered (paras 13, 28, 52). Applying Awadhesh Yadav, it held that invoking Section 29 on call-record material could not be faulted at the bail stage (paras 31-32). But unexplained Section 52A sampling gaps cast serious doubt on the prosecution case, and custody since 03.12.2020 with the trial at a nascent stage meant the Section 37 embargo did not bar bail (paras 38-42, 49-50).

State Employee's Emergency Treatment at Private Hospital Without Prior Sanction Must Be Reimbursed: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that a State employee facing a threat to life may seek emergency treatment at a private hospital without awaiting prior sanction or a turn at a government or authorised hospital (para 10). Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Surjit Singh, it said the right to health and self-preservation by medical treatment in an emergency is akin to the right to life under Article 21 (para 10). It ordered a ward boy's cardiac treatment bills verified and reimbursed with interest (para 11).

Repeated Drug Cases and Failure to Surrender After Bail Cancellation Justify Refusing Bail: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused bail under Section 439 CrPC to a petitioner accused of supplying opium in an NCB case in which 33 kg was recovered (paras 8, 12-13). It found him involved in at least three more narcotics cases, held that he had grossly misused the liberty of earlier bail, and noted that he did not surrender on time after his bail was cancelled (paras 8, 10). A person repeatedly involved in drug trafficking can be called a habitual offender (para 11).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt