Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Open Air Camp for POCSO and Rape Convicts: Rajasthan High Court Refers Conflicting Rulings to Larger Bench
Rajasthan High Court

Faced with conflicting Division Bench rulings, the Rajasthan High Court referred to a Special/Larger Bench whether a prisoner convicted under Section 376 IPC or the POCSO Act can be shifted from jail to an Open Air Camp in view of Rule 3 of the Rajasthan Prisoners Open Air Camp Rules, 1972 (paras 19-20). The Supreme Court had dismissed the State's special leave petition in Asharam @ Ashu on its peculiar facts but kept the question of law open (paras 12-13).

Daughter Widowed After Government Servant’s Death Not Entitled to Family Pension: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court has held that a daughter who becomes a widow or divorcee only after a government servant’s death is not entitled to family pension under Rules 66 and 67 of the Rajasthan Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1996. Under Rule 4, the right is fixed on the date of retirement or death (para 23), and a 2013 circular extending the benefit could not override the Rules (paras 29, 31). Four writ petitions by widowed daughters were dismissed (para 32).

State's Choice of Law Officers Not Open to Challenge Unless Arbitrary: Rajasthan High Court Dismisses PIL
Rajasthan High Court

A Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court at Jodhpur dismissed a writ petition, treated as a public interest litigation, against the appointment of Additional Advocate Generals and Law Officers through the State's circulars of 12 February and 12 March 2024 (paras 2, 23). The Bench held that the State's choice of its lawyers can be challenged only if shown arbitrary, and found no public interest and no pleaded facts against any appointee (paras 13, 16, 20).

Women Have a Right to Safe, Clean Toilets: Rajasthan High Court Takes Suo Motu Cognizance
Rajasthan High Court

Acting on a Rajasthan Patrika report that working women were drinking less water for fear of having to use a toilet, a Rajasthan High Court judge took suo motu cognizance and held that women have the right to safe and clean toilets at all convenient places, a right that impacts their right to live with human dignity (paras 11, 13-14). The Court issued show-cause notice on 31 proposed directions for women's public toilets (para 15).

Parliament's Power to Amend Extends to the Preamble; 'Socialist' and 'Secular' Challenge Dismissed: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed writ petitions challenging the insertion of 'socialist' and 'secular' into the Preamble by the Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976. It held that the amending power under Article 368 extends to the Preamble and is not curtailed by the date of adoption, that both words carry settled Indian meanings, and that a challenge brought 44 years later did not warrant even issuing notice (paras 2-7).

Missing Class XI Biology Marksheet Cannot Defeat Merit in NEET Seat Allotment: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that higher-ranked NEET-UG 2024 candidates could not be ousted from the Stray Vacancy Round merely because their Class XI marksheets did not show Biology, when their Class XII marksheets did (paras 13.6, 14.2). Document verification was held during the Deepawali holidays in a three-hour window, and the school certificates produced on 31.10.2024 were held to be in time (paras 13.3-13.4, 15). Treating merit as the exclusive criterion, the Court cancelled two lower-ranked candidates' allotments (paras 15-17).

Right to Health and Hospital Negligence: Rajasthan High Court Takes Suo Motu Cognizance, Division Bench Closes PIL
Rajasthan High Court

Acting on two Rajasthan Patrika reports of November 2024, a single judge of the Rajasthan High Court took suo motu cognizance of what he called gross negligence by hospital administrations, holding that the right to health is an integral part of the right to life under Article 21 (paras 7, 10, 13). He summoned reports from the Union and the State on steps to improve health care (para 15). A Division Bench closed the PIL on 11.12.2024, finding the reports vague.

Statutory Incorporation Does Not Erase a University's Minority Character: Seven-Judge Bench Overrules Azeez Basha by Majority
Supreme Court of India

A seven-Judge Bench held, in the majority opinion of Chief Justice Chandrachud for four Judges, that an educational institution is not denied minority status under Article 30(1) merely because a statute incorporated it, overruling the contrary view in Azeez Basha (Chandrachud CJI, para 161). The majority set out indicia of ideation, purpose and implementation for 'establishment' (Chandrachud CJI, para 160). Surya Kant, Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma JJ. disagreed in separate opinions. AMU's own status was left to a regular Bench.

Unilateral Appointment of Sole Arbitrator Raises Justifiable Doubts; Mandatory Curated Panels Breach Equal Treatment: Constitution Bench Majority
Supreme Court of India

A Constitution Bench, by majority, held that equal treatment of parties under Section 18 of the Arbitration Act applies when arbitrators are appointed. A clause letting one party unilaterally appoint a sole arbitrator raises justifiable doubts about impartiality, and a party cannot be made to choose its arbitrator from a panel curated by a PSU. Unilateral clauses in public-private contracts violate Article 14 (Chandrachud CJI, para 169). In separate opinions, Roy J. and Narasimha J. declined to declare unilateral appointment clauses void as a class.

Rules of the Game Cannot Be Changed Midway: Constitution Bench Upholds K. Manjusree in Tej Prakash Pathak
Supreme Court of India

A five-Judge Constitution Bench held that eligibility criteria for placement in a select list cannot be changed midway through recruitment unless the rules or the advertisement permit it, and even then only non-arbitrarily. It affirmed K. Manjusree as good law, found no conflict with Subash Chander Marwaha, and held that statutory rules bind recruiters, while a place in the select list gives no indefeasible right to appointment (para 42).

LMV Licence Holders Can Drive Transport Vehicles Up to 7,500 kg Without Separate Endorsement: Constitution Bench
Supreme Court of India

A five-Judge Bench held that a driver with a Light Motor Vehicle licence under Section 10(2)(d) of the Motor Vehicles Act may drive a transport vehicle with a gross vehicle weight under 7,500 kg without a separate endorsement. The added eligibility rules for transport vehicles apply only to medium and heavy vehicles above that weight, and the special rules for e-carts, e-rickshaws and hazardous goods stay. Mukund Dewangan (2017) was upheld and held not per incuriam (para 131).

U.P. Madarsa Act Upheld Except Fazil and Kamil Provisions; Secularism Breach Must Be Traced to Express Provisions
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside the Allahabad High Court's judgment striking down the Uttar Pradesh Board of Madarsa Education Act, 2004. A statute cannot be invalidated merely for violating the basic structure; a breach of secularism must be traced to express constitutional provisions. The Act is a regulatory law within Entry 25, List III, but its provisions on the higher-education degrees of Fazil and Kamil conflict with the UGC Act and are invalid (paras 73, 104).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt