Friday, 20 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Mundra Heroin Case: Supreme Court Denies Bail Under Section 43D(5) UAPA, Allows Renewal After Six Months
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court refused regular bail to Harpreet Singh Talwar, accused of facilitating heroin imports concealed as Afghan talc through Mundra Port, holding that the material met the prima facie threshold under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA though nothing was recovered from his consignment. Dead and untraceable witnesses, antecedents and flight risk weighed against bail, but he may renew his plea after six months or on substantial progress of the trial (paras 23-35).

Courts Have Limited Power to Modify Arbitral Awards: Constitution Bench in Gayatri Balasamy, 4:1
Supreme Court of India

By 4:1, a Constitution Bench held that courts hearing challenges under Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration Act have a limited power to modify arbitral awards: severing invalid parts, correcting clerical, computational or typographical errors, and modifying post-award interest, with the Supreme Court able to use Article 142 with great caution. Justice K.V. Viswanathan dissented: courts cannot modify awards, though they may sever invalid parts and correct such errors (para 85; Viswanathan J., para 157).

Cross-Subsidy Surcharge Need Not Be Fixed With Tariff: Supreme Court Restores Rajasthan Commission's 2016 Order
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that the cross-subsidy surcharge payable by open access consumers need not be determined together with the tariff. Under Regulation 90 of the Rajasthan Tariff Regulations, 2014 it may be fixed separately, on the prevailing tariff. The Court set aside the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity's judgment and restored the Rajasthan Electricity Regulatory Commission's order of 1 December 2016, which remained in force only until 2 November 2017 (paras 19-21).

Consideration Paid, Not Compensation Claimed, Can Decide Consumer Commission Jurisdiction: Supreme Court Upholds 2019 Act
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court upheld Sections 34, 47 and 58 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which fix the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District, State and National Commissions by the value of goods or services paid as consideration instead of the compensation claimed. The classification is neither discriminatory nor manifestly arbitrary, and the Court directed the Central Consumer Protection Council and Authority to review the working of the statute (para 13).

Bald Allegations of Undisclosed Criminal Cases Cannot Sustain Election Petition: Rajasthan High Court Rejects Hanumangarh Poll Challenge
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court rejected, under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, an election petition against the returned candidate for the Hanumangarh Assembly constituency. The petition alleged that 17 criminal cases were not disclosed but gave no FIR numbers, police stations or courts; the Court held that such bald pleadings disclosed no cause of action (paras 31-32, 37, 42, 47-48). A typing error citing non-existent 1967 Rules could be corrected (paras 28-30).

Candidate Fit for Accounts Service Cannot Be Declared Unfit for RAS for Sub-40% Disability: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

A candidate with congenital nystagmus and less than 20% visual disability ranked 21st in the RAS Examination, 2003 but was declared medically unfit for the RAS and placed in the Rajasthan Accounts Service. The Rajasthan High Court held that, since the 1975 medical guidelines treat both services as non-technical, the State could not find him fit for one and unfit for the other, and that a disability below the 40% benchmark cannot justify exclusion (paras 36, 42, 49). He was ordered appointed to the RAS from 21.04.2006 (para 53).

Mere Allegations of WhatsApp Harassment Cannot Sustain an Abetment of Suicide Charge: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court discharged a cricket coach charged with abetting the suicide of a fellow coach who, the complaint alleged, had been harassed and threatened in a WhatsApp group. Abetment under Section 306 IPC needs intentional instigation or aid with a clear mens rea, and mere allegations of harassment do not suffice for framing a charge (paras 10-11, 14). The defamation and insult charges also fell because the evidence did not show he sent any derogatory messages (para 25).

Sanjeev Deshpande Applies Retrospectively: Supreme Court Restores NDPS Trials Over Buprenorphine, Bars Discharge Under Section 216
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that dealing in a psychotropic substance listed in the Schedule to the NDPS Act is an offence under Section 8(c) even if it is not in Schedule I of the NDPS Rules, and that Sanjeev V. Deshpande, which settled this in 2014, applies retrospectively to pending cases. Once a charge is framed, Section 216 CrPC cannot be used to delete it or discharge the accused. Two buprenorphine prosecutions go back for trial (paras 156-163).

Heatwave Preparedness and the Right to Life: Rajasthan High Court Orders Cooling Spaces, Division Bench Closes Case
Rajasthan High Court

Taking suo motu cognizance of rising heatwaves, a single judge of the Rajasthan High Court found that, almost ten months after the Court's 2024 heatwave directions, the State had prepared no action plan and had not implemented its Heat Action Plan (paras 10-11, 15). He ordered a coordination committee, reiterated interim directions on cooling spaces, health-centre facilities, rest hours for outdoor workers and alerts, and issued show-cause notice on five further directions (paras 19, 22, 25). A Division Bench closed the petition on 05.05.2025.

Suits Over Jaipur Ruler's 1949 Covenant Properties Barred by Article 363: Rajasthan High Court Rejects Four Plaints
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that Article 363 of the Constitution bars courts from deciding disputes arising out of the 1949 covenant between Jaipur's erstwhile ruler and the Union of India. Allowing four revisions by the State, it rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC the suits of a museum trust and Sawai Bhawani Singh's heirs claiming possession of, and mesne profits for, buildings occupied by the State (paras 41, 48-50).

Urdu Alongside Marathi on a Municipal Council Signboard Is Lawful; Language Is Not Religion: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court upheld the use of Urdu below Marathi on the signboard of the Patur Municipal Council in Maharashtra. Neither the Maharashtra Local Authorities (Official Languages) Act, 2022 nor any other law prohibits an additional language, and the appellant's case rested on a misconception of law. Language belongs to a community and a region, not to a religion, and Urdu is an Indo-Aryan language born in India (paras 15, 17, 27, 49).

Two-Step Test Decides Copyright or Design Protection for Industrial Drawings; Plaint Cannot Be Rejected at Threshold
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that whether engineering drawings are an 'artistic work' protected by copyright or a 'design' caught by Section 15(2) of the Copyright Act is a mixed question of law and fact, not one to be settled on an Order VII Rule 11 application. It laid down a two-step test: is the work purely artistic or an industrially applied design derived from it, and if not copyrightable, is its dominant purpose functional (paras 60, 67)?

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt