The Supreme Court expunged strictures that a Rajasthan High Court Single Judge had passed against Kaushal Singh, a District Judge cadre officer, while rejecting an accused's bail on 3 May 2024. Relying on In Re: ‘K’ and Sonu Agnihotri, it reiterated that High Courts should ordinarily refrain from such strictures on the judicial side. The officer had no chance to explain, and the High Court's foundation, Jugal, had since been reversed (paras 18-21).
The Supreme Court dismissed a special leave petition by a man convicted under Section 21(c) of the NDPS Act for 236 vials of codeine cough syrup, but corrected the Chhattisgarh High Court's view that a sentence above the minimum needs a Section 32-B factor. Section 32-B lets courts weigh other relevant factors, such as quantity, so the minimum is not the maximum; the reduced sentence was left undisturbed (paras 9-21).
The Rajasthan High Court held that a plaintiff whose dispute is settled through a mode recognised by Section 89 CPC is entitled to a refund of the full court fee paid on the plaint under Section 65-B of the Rajasthan Court Fees and Suit Valuation Act, even where the settlement comes after the decree, during execution (paras 5-6, second paras 6-7). It set aside a Bikaner trial court order refusing the refund (para 8).
The Rajasthan High Court dismissed a writ petition by a candidate with low vision who sought appointment as Stenographer Grade-III (Hindi) in the physically handicapped category. Rule 10 of the Rajasthan District Courts Ministerial Establishment Rules, 1986 requires passing a Hindi shorthand speed test at 70 words per minute, and his speed was assessed at 50.167 WPM (paras 9, 13). Aggregate marks of 121.142 and unfilled reserved posts gave him no vested right to appointment (para 16).
The Rajasthan High Court granted anticipatory bail to a woman accused of illicit opium poppy cultivation, holding that Section 37 of the NDPS Act does not apply because cultivation under Section 18(c) has no quantity threshold. The case rested only on her minor son's uncorroborated statement in custody, the land stood in another person's name, and she was covered by the first proviso to Section 437(1) CrPC (paras 6, 9-13, 22).
The Rajasthan High Court declined a mother's plea to have her minor daughter's pregnancy terminated because the daughter, described as a rape survivor, did not want a termination (paras 1, 6.12-6.13). Holding that a pregnant woman has autonomy over her body and that a sufficiently mature minor's choice prevails over her guardian's consent, the Court upheld her right to continue the pregnancy and directed State-funded medical care and victim compensation (paras 6.2, 6.12, 7).
Acting on a letter from the children of a Balika Grah (girls' home) in Alwar about non-receipt of grant-in-aid, the Rajasthan High Court registered a suo motu PIL on their grievances and the hardship of ‘care leavers’, who must leave care at 18 (paras 12, 27, 32). It listed steps in eight areas that the Centre and State are required to take by law or policy (first para 34). A Division Bench later vacated the directions in paras 34 and 35.
The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal by the Rajasthan power distribution companies against Adani Power Rajasthan, leaving undisturbed APTEL's ruling that Coal India's Evacuation Facility Charges notification of 19 December 2017 was a change in law compensable from its date. A mere difference in one party's understanding of a change in law does not move the start date to an order's date under Article 10.5.1(ii) of the PPA, and a supplementary bill follows adjudication (paras 24-26, 28-29).
The Supreme Court held that a Tamil Nadu government teacher who had two children from her first marriage, born before she entered service, must be granted maternity leave under FR 101(a) for her first child from her second marriage. Reading the rule purposively, it held that the two-child norm and maternity benefit must be harmonised, set aside the Madras High Court Division Bench and ordered the benefits released within two months (paras 34-37).
The Supreme Court set aside the discharge of a probationer Civil Judge in Rajasthan who had not mentioned her earlier job as a government teacher, a job she had resigned before her interview. The omission was not a serious misconduct, her performance on probation was never faulted, and she was not heard in the inquiry. She was reinstated and treated as confirmed, with seniority and notional pay but no back wages (paras 18, 21, 27, 32).
The Supreme Court restored the requirement that candidates for Civil Judge (Junior Division) must have practised at the Bar for at least three years, counted from provisional enrolment and including work as a law clerk. It also raised the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination quota for promotion to District Judge from 10% to 25%, and directed High Courts to frame suitability tests for promotion (paras 84, 89).
The Supreme Court upheld a clause in a Vijaya Bank appointment letter requiring an officer to serve three years or pay Rs. 2 lakh as liquidated damages. A restrictive covenant operating during employment is not a restraint of trade under Section 27 of the Contract Act, and a minimum term adopted by a public sector bank to curb attrition is not opposed to public policy (paras 15-16, 27, 35).





