Answering a Presidential Reference under Article 143, a five-Judge Constitution Bench held that a Governor has three options on a Bill: assent, reserve it for the President, or withhold assent and return it to the Legislature. He chooses among them in his discretion, and the choice is not justiciable. Courts cannot prescribe timelines or deem assent under Article 142, but may issue a limited mandamus where inaction is prolonged, unexplained and indefinite. Questions 12 and 14 were returned unanswered (para 165).
In a dispute over 363 posts of Principal in Delhi government schools, the Supreme Court held that candidates who completed ten years' teaching experience by 29.07.2021, the closing date of UPSC's re-notified detailed advertisement, were eligible, though the first, deferred advertisement had closed on 13.05.2021. Clause 9(b) fixed eligibility in every respect on the closing date, and UPSC gave no reason for keeping the old date (paras 8-13).
The Supreme Court upheld the unseating of a municipal councillor in Madhya Pradesh who did not disclose, in her nomination affidavit, a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act with one year's imprisonment. Rule 24-A requires disclosure of any conviction, the offence need not be serious, and once suppression is found the voters' informed choice is impeded, so the result need not be shown to be materially affected (paras 15, 19, 21).
The Supreme Court held that a person arrested for any offence under any statute, including the IPC (now BNS), must be told the grounds of arrest in writing, in a language they understand (paras 46, 56). Where written grounds are impractical at the moment of arrest, they may first be conveyed orally, but must be supplied in writing "at least two hours prior to production of the arrestee for remand proceedings before the magistrate" (para 56). Non-compliance renders the arrest and remand illegal (para 56).
The Rajasthan High Court quashed a 2017 cognizance order for adultery under Section 497 IPC and the revisional order that upheld it (para 22). It held that the Supreme Court's declaration in Joseph Shine v. Union of India striking down Section 497 operates retrospectively and nullifies all pending prosecutions based solely on that provision, though trials concluded before that judgment cannot be reopened (para 20). Continuing this prosecution, after a negative final report, would be an abuse of process (para 21).
The Supreme Court held that an investigating officer cannot summon an Advocate representing an accused to learn the details of the case unless a Section 132 BSA exception applies. Such a summons must state the facts relied on, carry the written approval of an officer not below Superintendent of Police and is open to challenge under Section 528 BNSS. The Court declined to frame wider guidelines (paras 49-50, 67).
The Rajasthan High Court held that compassionate appointment is conferred on one member as a representative of the whole family and carries a fiduciary obligation towards the deceased employee’s other dependents (paras 13, 19). A widow appointed on an affidavit promising to maintain her parents-in-law could not enjoy the job while neglecting them. It directed the employer to deduct ₹20,000 a month from her salary from 01.11.2025 and credit it to her aged father-in-law (para 22).
The Rajasthan High Court refused to quash the prosecution of a Jaipur doctor under Sections 304-A and 420 IPC over the death of a newborn in 2007. After a negative police final report, CID(CB) investigated further and a charge-sheet followed. The Court held that this further investigation under Section 173(8) CrPC was lawful (paras 18-20), and that the Jacob Mathew guidelines were met because expert reports of the Rajasthan Medical Council and SMS Medical College had been considered (paras 22-24).
The Rajasthan High Court refused bail to an engineering student from whose hostel room 0.31 gram of LSD on blotter papers and 6.1 gram of ganja were allegedly recovered. Taking into account that the quantity as alleged was commercial, the Section 37 NDPS bar, and a Bombay High Court Full Bench ruling that the blotter paper is part of the LSD and counts towards its weight, the Court dismissed the application without commenting on the merits (paras 3, 5-6).
The Rajasthan High Court granted bail to a man held since March 2024 on charges under the Official Secrets Act, 1923, because the prosecution had examined only 4 of its 18 witnesses in pre-charge evidence and had still not filed the forensic report on his mobile phone (paras 6, 11). An undertrial cannot be confined indefinitely when the prosecution is not diligent, and the gravity of the charge alone cannot justify prolonged incarceration, the Court held (para 11).
The Supreme Court held that the NDPS Seizure, Storage, Sampling and Disposal Rules, 2022 do not take away the Special Court's power to release a seized vehicle on interim custody under Sections 451 and 457 CrPC (Sections 497 and 503 BNSS). A lorry owner whose crew carried 6 kg of ganja, and who was never charged, got his vehicle back on supurdagi (paras 13-36).
The Rajasthan High Court allowed a private pharmacy college's writ petition against the State's order of 26.04.2025 banning NOCs for new B.Pharmacy courses and colleges. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Pharmacy Council of India v. Rajeev College of Pharmacy, Justice Sunil Beniwal held that the State, without legislative competence, could not impose such a ban, and that confining it to private colleges was arbitrary and violative of Article 14 (paras 8.8, 9.1, 11).




