The Supreme Court upheld the proviso to Section 41(1) of the NDPS (Amendment) Act, 2001, which denies the amendment's lighter, quantity-based sentences to cases pending in appeal on 2 October 2001. Separating concluded trials from pending trials and investigations is a reasonable classification: applying the new Act to concluded trials could reopen them and defeat the aim of avoiding delay (paras 21-23). High Court rulings striking down the proviso were overruled (para 24).
The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of a woman found with 600 grams of heroin in a 1994 roadside search, and the acquittal of two men alleged to have supplied it (paras 6, 27-30). Section 50 prescribes no specific form: the suspect need only be made aware of the right to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or Magistrate (paras 21, 23). Section 42 covers a building, conveyance or enclosed place, while Section 43 covers public places (para 15).
The Supreme Court acquitted a farmer convicted under the NDPS Act after 17 ganja plants were found in a field. To prove cultivation there must be supporting evidence that the accused grew the plants; a few plants on the land are not enough, since plants may sprout naturally. Nothing showed the field was his alone or that he cultivated them (paras 4, 6-7).
The Supreme Court held that a man who enters into a marital relationship and, under the colour of that status, subjects the woman to cruelty is a ‘husband’ for Sections 498A and 304B IPC, whatever the legitimacy of the marriage (para 18). It set aside the High Court's summary refusal of leave to appeal against an acquittal resting on the husband's undissolved first marriage, and remitted the matter for a hearing on merits (para 27).
The Supreme Court upheld the NDPS convictions of two men found with 200 grams of opium each, holding that Section 50 prescribes no particular form for telling a suspect of his right (paras 2, 7, 15). A notice asking whether they would give the officer the search or be searched by a gazetted officer or magistrate was enough, as in Joseph Fernandez (paras 9-10, 13). "No specific words are necessary to be used to convey existence of the right" (para 9).
The Supreme Court upheld CBDT Circular No. 789 of 13 April 2000, under which a Mauritian certificate of residence is sufficient evidence of residence and beneficial ownership under the Indo-Mauritius tax treaty, and set aside the Delhi High Court's judgment quashing it (para 140). A treaty notified under Section 90 overrides the Income-tax Act where inconsistent, ‘liable to taxation’ does not mean actual payment of tax, and treaty shopping is not illegal (paras 27, 75, 102, 113).
In M. Prabhulal v. Assistant Director, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (2003 Supp(3) SCR 958), the Supreme Court held that Section 42(2) of the NDPS Act is not applicable when an empowered Gazetted Officer himself searches, arrests and seizes, because he acts under Section 41 (paras 14-15). It upheld four convictions in a case of 66.1 kg of heroin, treating the Section 67 statements to Revenue Intelligence officers as voluntary and rejecting objections over independent witnesses and the seizure at the Customs office (paras 2, 5-7, 16).
The Supreme Court acquitted a man and his mother convicted of possessing charas and ganja because the seized drugs were never produced at trial, the panch witnesses turned hostile and the Investigating Officer was not examined (paras 5-6, 9). "The best evidence would have been the seized materials which ought to have been produced during the trial and marked as material objects" (para 6). A final report saying the laboratory report was awaited, filed after that report's date, added to the doubt (para 8).
The Supreme Court upheld the NDPS convictions of the occupants of a private car from which 820 grams of charas was recovered (paras 7, 30). Section 50 applies only to the personal search of a person, not to a vehicle, container, bag or premises (para 17). Once possession is established, the person claiming that it was not conscious must prove it, as Sections 35 and 54 recognise; the driver stood on no different footing (paras 27-29).
The Supreme Court upheld a Delhi Police driver's conviction under the Explosive Substances Act and TADA for keeping explosives, detonators and timers in a locked box in his quarter (paras 1-2, 11). Police witnesses are treated like any other witnesses, and "The presumption that a person acts honestly applies as much in favour of police personnel as of other persons" (para 8). The absence of public witnesses was explained by fear of terrorists (para 8).
A Constitution Bench held that "lawyers have no right to go on strike or give a call for boycott, not even on a token strike" (para 35). Advocates holding vakalats cannot stay away from court on a strike call, courts need not adjourn cases because lawyers are on strike, and an advocate who abstains is personally liable for costs; protest must take peaceful forms that do not stop court work (paras 31, 35).
In Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms (2002 INSC 253), the Supreme Court held that a voter’s right to know the antecedents of candidates for Parliament and the State Legislatures, including their criminal past, is part of Article 19(1)(a) (paras 48, 55). As the Act and the Rules were silent, the Election Commission could use its plenary power under Article 324 to fill the gap (paras 21, 31). Every candidate was to disclose criminal cases, assets, liabilities and educational qualifications on affidavit with the nomination paper (para 57).










