The Supreme Court has upheld a man's conviction for possessing opium under the NDPS Act, rejecting the High Court's finding that he had conspired with a co-accused to jointly possess a larger quantity. It held there was no evidence of conspiracy, but independently found the 920 grams recovered from him alone already exceeded the commercial-quantity threshold for an opium derivative.
A three-Judge Bench held that a doctor can be prosecuted under Section 304A IPC only for negligence that is gross or of a very high degree; the Bolam test governs medical negligence in India, and res ipsa loquitur has at most a limited role in a criminal trial (para 45). It laid down guidelines requiring a credible medical opinion before a private complaint or investigation proceeds against a doctor, and quashed the prosecution over an empty oxygen cylinder (paras 49-51).
In State (N.C.T. of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu @ Afsan Guru (Criminal Appeal Nos. 373-375 of 2004), the Supreme Court held that a confession recorded by a police officer under Section 32(1) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 is admissible against its maker only, and cannot be used against a co-accused, even through Sections 30 or 10 of the Evidence Act (paras 78-79, 97). Holding the safeguards in Sections 32(2) to (5) integral (para 199), it refused to act on Mohd. Afzal’s confession in the Parliament attack case (para 227) but confirmed his death sentence (para 395).
The Supreme Court set aside the conviction of an electricity board engineer for accepting a Rs 150 bribe in a 1985 trap, restating when it will disturb concurrent findings under Article 136. The courts below wrongly discarded proof that he was on leave on the date of an earlier alleged payment, and his defence that the notes were planted in a shirt hanging in the room was probable, especially as the notes were not treated with phenolphthalein (paras 11, 19-22, 26).
Resolving a split between two judges, a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court held that Section 50 of the NDPS Act applies only to a search of the person, meaning the human body with its clothing and footwear. A bag, briefcase or other container carried by the accused is not part of his person, so Section 50 does not apply to its search. Both State appeals were allowed and remitted to the High Courts (paras 9-10, 23-24).
In Ranjitsing Brahmajeetsing Sharma v. State of Maharashtra (2005 INSC 190), the Supreme Court held that Section 21(4) of the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999 does not require a court to record a positive finding that a bail applicant has not committed the offence; it is enough that the court, on the record, is satisfied that he may in all probability not be convicted, and the feared future offence must be one under the Act (paras 45, 51). Holding, prima facie, that neither Section 3(2) nor Section 24 was made out against a former police commissioner (paras 38, 40), it continued his interim bail (para 93).
In Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community v. State of Maharashtra (I.A. No. 4 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 740 of 1986), the Supreme Court held that the law laid down by a Bench of larger strength binds every later Bench of lesser or co-equal strength. A Bench of lesser quorum cannot doubt such a ruling; it can only ask the Chief Justice to place the matter before a larger Bench, and only a co-equal Bench may express doubt (para 12). The five-Judge Bench directed that a petition seeking reconsideration of a five-Judge ruling of 1962 be heard by five Judges, not seven (para 14).
The Supreme Court set aside the Punjab and Haryana High Court's acquittal of three men caught with 18 bags of poppy husk on a bullock cart. Section 50 applies only to a personal search, not to a vehicle, container, bag or premises, so the search of the bags on the cart did not attract it. The respondents were directed to surrender to serve the rest of their sentences (paras 3, 10, 12).
The Supreme Court acquitted a man sentenced to death for abducting and killing two boys, holding that his retracted judicial confession was uncorroborated and contradicted the medical evidence, so "it is not safe to convict the appellant solely on the basis of the alleged confession which has been retracted" (para 28). General corroboration of a retracted confession suffices (para 23).
The Supreme Court set aside the High Court's acquittal of two Visakhapatnam Port Trust officers caught accepting Rs. 5,000 each, restoring their conviction under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120B IPC with one year's imprisonment (paras 1, 3, 28). Once acceptance of gratification is proved, the presumption under Section 20(1) is compulsory, and acceptance need not be shown by direct evidence (paras 13-14).
The Supreme Court set aside a Madras High Court order quashing a corruption prosecution because the Inspector who registered the FIR had also investigated it. Nothing in the Code bars this; such an investigation can be assailed only for "bias or real likelihood of bias", which depends on the facts of each case (paras 3, 5). Bhagwan Singh and Megha Singh lay down no broad contrary rule (paras 7, 11).
The Supreme Court upheld the acquittal of two men found sitting on 100 bags of poppy husk in a field. The police had not investigated how the bags reached the field or who owned them, and treated mere presence as possession. The prosecution failed to prove conscious possession, so the Punjab and Haryana High Court's acquittal of both stood (paras 1-2).








