The Rajasthan High Court dismissed, with costs, an election petition challenging the election of the returned candidate from the Barmer Parliamentary Constituency in 2019. The petitioner, dismissed from the Indian Police Service on 19.02.2019, had filed his nomination without the Election Commission's certificate under Section 33(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The Returning Officer had no option but to reject it, and a certificate issued after scrutiny could not change that (paras 39, 41, 45, 47).
The Supreme Court acquitted three men convicted under Section 15 of the NDPS Act after 75 kg of poppy straw was found in a private jeep on a public road. A private vehicle is not a public place under the Explanation to Section 43, so Section 42 applied; the officer admittedly never recorded the secret information in writing, and total non-compliance with Section 42 is impermissible (paras 12-15).
The Supreme Court upheld a 15-year sentence for possession of 1 kg of heroin, four times the minimum commercial quantity, though the NDPS Act's minimum is ten years. Section 32B lets courts weigh such factors as they deem fit beyond clauses (a) to (f), and the quantity of drugs is one; being poor, a carrier or the sole breadwinner is no ground for leniency in NDPS sentencing (paras 6, 7).
The Supreme Court cancelled bail granted by the Allahabad High Court to a company director accused of diverting acetic anhydride, a controlled substance, as part of an alleged international drug syndicate. The High Court merely recorded the submissions, never applied Section 37 of the NDPS Act, and relied on the extraneous ground that the accused was educated and so "may not commit any offence" (paras 11-13).
Answering a reference, a Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court held that, unless the statute provides otherwise, an offence under a law other than the IPC punishable with imprisonment which may extend to three years falls in the second category of Part II of the First Schedule to the Cr.P.C. and is cognizable and non-bailable (para 25). The maximum punishment that may be awarded decides the category, not the minimum (para 21), and Pintu Dey does not lay down the correct law (para 24).
The Supreme Court dismissed the NIA's appeal against bail granted to a UAPA accused who had spent over five years in custody with 276 witnesses still to be examined (paras 6, 15, 21). Section 43-D(5) of the UAPA "per-se does not oust the ability of Constitutional Courts to grant bail on grounds of violation of Part III of the Constitution", and its rigours "will melt down" where a timely trial is unlikely and much of the sentence has already been undergone (para 18).
The Supreme Court granted bail to actress Ragini Dwivedi, jailed since September 2020 in Bengaluru's alleged drug-party case. No drugs were found at her home and the case rested on another person's statement; at most an offence of consuming drugs under Section 27 was made out, so the courts below wrongly applied the Section 37 bar on bail (paras 6-8).
The Rajasthan High Court held that the Finance Department memorandum of 01.06.2017, which defers the next Assured Career Progression (ACP) by three years for an employee with more than two children on or after 01.06.2002, cannot be applied by a blanket order to a third child born after a failed ligation operation (paras 10-12). The operation showed that the couple did not intend a third child, and such exceptions are inherent in the rule (para 11). The State must grant the petitioner ACP with arrears (para 13).
The Rajasthan High Court held that a woman government employee cannot be refused maternity leave under Rule 103 of the Rajasthan Service Rules, 1951 only because her child was born before she joined service. The Rule turns on her being a female Government servant with less than two surviving children, not on the date of birth (para 24). The Court quashed the orders treating her 142 days' absence as unpaid leave and deferring her confirmation (paras 47-50).
The Rajasthan High Court held that a complainant-victim who alleges that the police recorded his Section 161 CrPC statement wrongly cannot go straight to a Magistrate to have his statement recorded under Section 164 CrPC. Following Jogendra Nahak v. State of Orissa, it held that a Magistrate has no power to record the statement of a person not sponsored by the investigating agency, and that this applies to complainants and victims too (para 16). The petition was dismissed (para 17).
In Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu, decided on 29 October 2020, a three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court answered a reference on how far an accused's own words to NDPS officers can be used against him. By a 2:1 majority, Justices R.F. Nariman and Navin Sinha held that officers invested with powers under Section 53 of the NDPS Act are police officers under Section 25 of the Evidence Act, so a confession made to them cannot ground a conviction, and that a statement recorded under Section 67 cannot be used as a confession at trial. Raj Kumar Karwal and Kanhaiyalal were overruled (paras 153, 155). Justice Indira Banerjee dissented.
The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of Rajesh Dhiman and Gulshan Rana for possessing 3.1 kg of charas found in a backpack, dismissing their appeals against the High Court's reversal of their acquittal. Following the Constitution Bench in Mukesh Singh, it held that a complainant who also investigates does not by that fact alone taint the case, called the claim that the bag belonged to a vanished stranger fanciful, and sent both back to custody (paras 10, 16, 22).









