Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Nineteen Cases, None Since 2013: Rajasthan High Court Sends History-Sheet Reopening Back for Reasoned Review
Rajasthan High Court

In Kishan Khatik v. State of Rajasthan (2026:RJ-JD:54063), the Rajasthan High Court sent back to the Superintendent of Police, Udaipur the question whether a history-sheet re-opened in 2014 should continue: nineteen cases are recorded, but none since 2013 (paras 8-9). Conviction is not essential under Rule 4.4(3)(b) of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965, but the belief must rest on reasonable grounds (para 8.1).

After Supreme Court Remand, Rajasthan High Court Upholds Conviction for 1996 Barmer Murder on Footprint and Forensic Evidence
Rajasthan High Court

In Jagia @ Jagdish v. State of Rajasthan (2026:RJ-JD:53593-DB), the Rajasthan High Court, hearing the appeal afresh after the Supreme Court set aside its 2004 acquittal, upheld a 1997 Barmer murder conviction. A matching crime-scene footprint, blood of the same group on the deceased's articles and on the knife and clothes recovered from the first appellant, and her identified gold ring formed a complete chain. An identified pendant sustained the second appellant's theft conviction (paras 2, 20-28).

Status Quo Binds Until Vacated: Rajasthan High Court Holds Respondents Guilty of Contempt Over Construction on Disputed Plot
Rajasthan High Court

In Devendra & Ors. v. Lrs Of Magni & Ors. (S.B. Civil Contempt Petition No. 16/2021), the Rajasthan High Court held the respondents guilty of contempt for construction and renovation on a disputed plot while a status-quo order of 29 November 1999, passed in a second appeal that is still pending, remained in force (paras 1, 5-7). Repairing a dilapidated room did not excuse acting without permission. Punishment will be decided after hearing them on 25 November 2026 (paras 7-8).

Recoveries Alone Cannot Convict: Rajasthan High Court Acquits Three of Bundi Murder, Flags Excess Sentence Under Section 201
Rajasthan High Court

A Rajasthan High Court Division Bench acquitted three men serving life sentences for a 2017 murder near Bundi. With no eyewitness and no evidence of last seen, the prosecution relied only on recoveries made on their disclosures: currency notes, a shirt and knife, a mobile phone and a motorcycle. None was proved to link them to the crime, so the chain of circumstances was incomplete (pp. 9-21). The Bench also noted that the trial court exceeded the seven-year maximum under Section 201 IPC (pp. 21-22).

Healthcare PIL Closed on State's Affidavit: Rajasthan High Court Expects Real Improvement, Not 'Administrative Assurances'
Rajasthan High Court

A Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court headed by the Chief Justice closed a public interest litigation on gaps in the State's public healthcare after the State filed an affidavit listing the measures taken, including fire-safety work at SMS Hospital after a fire at its Trauma Centre. Finding no further directions warranted at this stage, the Court said timely medical care is linked to Article 21 and expected tangible improvement, not mere assurances (paras 5-14).

No Ground Beyond 24 Weeks: Rajasthan High Court Declines Termination of 28-Week Pregnancy, Orders Free Care and Compensation
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court declined to permit termination of a 28-week pregnancy of a petitioner described as a rape survivor. Beyond 24 weeks, the MTP Act allows termination only for substantial foetal abnormalities diagnosed by a Medical Board or to save the woman's life, and the Board found neither. The petition was disposed of with directions for free care, privacy and victim compensation (paras 6.4-8).

Poppy Straw in Panchayat Cow Shed: Rajasthan High Court Grants NDPS Bail, Finds Section 37 Satisfied
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court granted NDPS bail to a man after police recovered 1 quintal 56 kg 960 grams of poppy straw from a room on Gochar land while he sat outside it (pp. 1-3). Records showed the Gram Panchayat had built the tin-shed room for cows and fodder, so the Court found his ownership or possession of it prima facie doubtful and held the Section 37 conditions satisfied for the bail application (pp. 3-4).

Hostile Complainant No Shield: Rajasthan High Court Upholds ASI's Bribery Conviction on Recorded Demand and Trap Evidence
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court upheld an Assistant Sub-Inspector's conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act for taking Rs 700 in a 2007 trap. Although the complainant turned hostile, his admitted complaint, the recorded conversation, the trap witnesses and the recovery proved demand and acceptance. A Section 65-B certificate produced during the trial was enough to admit the recordings (paras 7-11).

Reservation of Assembly Seats Essentially for the Legislature: Supreme Court Leaves Rotation Plea to Elected Representatives
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court found no ground to differ from the Allahabad High Court, which had turned down Jagdish Singh's challenge to the vires of Section 9(1)(c) of the Delimitation Act, 2002 in his plea for rotation of Assembly seats reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Calling reservation of seats in the State Legislative Assemblies and Parliament essentially a matter for the Legislature, it disposed of his special leave petition with liberty to approach elected representatives (paras 2, 4-5).

Supreme Court Leaves Cricket Association Election Dispute to Rajasthan High Court, Fixes Four Weeks for Appeal
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court granted permission to file the special leave petitions of Rajendra Singh and another against the State of Rajasthan and others, condoned the delay and disposed of the petitions. As the High Court is already seized of the matter concerning the election of the State Cricket Association, the Court left all contentions open for consideration there (paras 1-3, 5). It directed the appellate authority to decide the petitioners' appeal against the order dated 03.07.2026 within four weeks (para 4).

Broker Defence No Bar to Investigation: Rajasthan High Court Refuses to Quash Cheating FIR Over Lentil Import Deal
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused to quash an FIR alleging cheating, criminal breach of trust and conspiracy against two representatives of a commodities firm over a 250-tonne Australian red lentil import. The allegations went beyond non-payment of a commercial debt, so the dispute was not purely civil and the FIR disclosed cognizable offences. Whether the petitioners were mere brokers was a disputed question for the investigation, not for a Section 528 BNSS petition (paras 9-13).

'Tax on Tax' Reference Rendered Academic: Seven-Judge Bench Says S. Kodar Governs Surcharge on Sales Tax
Supreme Court of India

A seven-Judge Supreme Court Bench has answered a reference pending since 1998 as rendered infructuous, directing that the States' competence to levy the impugned surcharges, computed on the sales tax payable, is governed by the Constitution Bench ruling in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala. India Cement's premise that royalty is a tax was overruled by nine Judges in Mineral Area Development Authority, so no conflicting decision survives (paras 102-103). In a separate judgment, Justice K.V. Viswanathan held that S. Kodar was correctly decided (Viswanathan J., para 65). The appeals go to regular Benches.

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt