Friday, 20 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Section 65B Certificate Produced Six Years Late Cannot Rescue Trap Recordings; Bribery Conviction Set Aside: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court acquitted a Patwari convicted of taking a ₹3,500 bribe, holding that a Section 65B certificate produced more than six years after the recordings were prepared, on the day an ACB officer deposed, could not make the electronic evidence admissible (paras 10.2, 10.12). With the complainant hostile, no work pending with the appellant and the money recovered from the ground, demand and acceptance were not proved (paras 7-9, 12). The Court suggested that the ACB require same-day certificates (para 14).

Unmarried Sisters-in-Law Declared Honourably Acquitted as "In Absence of Evidence" Is Expunged: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court struck out the words "in absence of evidence" from the acquittal of two unmarried sisters-in-law in a matrimonial cruelty case and declared them honourably acquitted (para 16). Where the prosecution has miserably failed after full consideration of its evidence, the accused can be said to be "honourably acquitted", and labels such as "benefit of doubt" or "in absence of evidence" would affect their careers (paras 13-15).

Stale 2004 Theft FIR Quashed: Endless Investigation Against Unnamed Person Violates Article 21, Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court quashed, qua the petitioner, all proceedings arising from a 2004 theft FIR in which he was never named. The seven persons charge-sheeted had been acquitted in 2012, no fresh material had surfaced, and nothing was done even after he obtained anticipatory bail in 2020 (paras 4, 4.12). Keeping coercive action alive indefinitely, without progress or material, is manifestly arbitrary and violates the right to speedy justice under Article 21 (para 4.11).

Rajasthan High Court Refuses DRI Plea to Cancel Bail in Hydroponic Weed Case Below Commercial Quantity
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court at Jaipur dismissed an application by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence to cancel the bail granted to two accused in a case involving 3.727 kg of hydroponic weed (paras 1-2, 9). Following the Supreme Court's order in Puranmal Jat, which holds that the Section 37 NDPS restriction on bail does not apply below commercial quantity, it found no merit in the complaint that the trial court had ignored that restriction (paras 6-8).

Pending Criminal Cases Without Conviction No Ground to Block Passport Renewal: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court set aside a Kota Chief Judicial Magistrate's refusal to issue a no-objection certificate for passport renewal to an accused facing 23 criminal cases, none ending in conviction. Stopping renewal, and so travel abroad, merely because criminal cases are pending violates Article 21, it held, and the passport authority must decide a fresh renewal application under Section 5 of the Passports Act within 30 days (paras 10-11).

Accused Who Denies Signature on Bounced Cheque Is Entitled to Handwriting Expert Opinion: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court allowed a cheque-bounce accused, who had denied signing the cheque ever since the legal notice, to have the signature examined by a handwriting expert at the Forensic Science Laboratory. Because Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act shifts the burden to the accused, his right to a fair trial and to lead defence evidence deserves stronger protection (paras 13-14). Following Kalyani Baskar, the Magistrate's refusal was quashed (para 17).

Trial Court's Plausible View Stands: Rajasthan High Court Upholds 1996 NDPS Acquittal in Opium Case
Rajasthan High Court

Dismissing a State appeal pending since 1996, the Rajasthan High Court upheld the acquittal of two men charged with possessing and supplying opium. The trial court's findings rested on material contradictions, procedural lapses and evidentiary deficiencies, and its view was plausible; given the stringent NDPS Act and its mandatory safeguards, the prosecution had not proved its case with the required certainty (paras 6-7).

Separate Sentences Under NDPS Sections 25 and 29 Valid, but No Double Fine When Sentences Run Concurrently
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that allowing a vehicle or premises to be used for an NDPS offence (Section 25) and abetment or criminal conspiracy (Section 29) are independent offences that attract separate punishment, even though they borrow the main offence's punishment by reference. But where the sentences run concurrently, the fine is part of the sentence and cannot be exacted twice; the appellant, in custody for 11 years, was released (paras 5-10).

Rajasthan High Court Upholds Cancellation of 2021 Sub-Inspector Exam Over Systemic Paper Leak
Rajasthan High Court

A Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court upheld a Single Judge's cancellation of the Rajasthan Police Sub-Inspector/Platoon Commander Examination, 2021, dismissing 17 appeals, including the State's (para 117). Paper leaks through organised gangs and RPSC members, dummy candidates and missing safeguards showed a systemic breach, and two years of investigation had not separated tainted from untainted candidates (paras 95-108). Clearing the physical test and interview did not save selected candidates (paras 109-110).

Dying Declaration Backed by Doctor's Certificate Sustains Conviction for Setting Wife on Fire: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court upheld a man's concurrent conviction for murdering his wife by pouring kerosene on her and setting her on fire in 2012, resting on her dying declaration recorded by a magistrate. The duty doctor had certified her condition after examining her, the statement on the reverse of that paper kept its sanctity, the tutoring plea was a bald assertion, and the medical evidence matched (paras 10-13). A postscript reflected on persisting violence against women (paras 14-18).

Compromise No Ground for Anticipatory Bail in 'Digital Arrest' Fraud on 83-Year-Old: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused anticipatory bail to a Dubai-based man whom the State accuses of running a 'digital arrest' fraud that took Rs 80 lakh from an 83-year-old woman (paras 7-8, 16). A compromise signed by his father, not by him, could not help, because organised cyber fraud affects society at large (para 15). Using its inherent powers, the Court told the trial court to consider releasing the Rs 13.40 lakh recovered to the complainant within seven days of her application (para 18).

Oral Grounds in Template Arrest Memo Not Enough: Supreme Court Grants Bail to Amritsar Doctors in NDPS Case
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court ordered the release on bail of two Amritsar doctors arrested by the NCB over 2000 Tramadol tablets. Their arrest memo, in a template format, recorded only that the grounds of arrest had been explained orally. Under Mihir Rajesh Shah, written grounds then had to be supplied two hours before production before the Magistrate, and that was not done (paras 20-22). Applying that ratio, the appellants were entitled to release (para 23).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt