Judgment Intelligence
Petition Dismissed- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of Decision
- 1 March 1966
- Bench
- Chief Justice P.B. Gajendragadkar and Justices K.N. Wanchoo, M. Hidayatullah, J.C. Shah and S.M. Sikri
- Relevant Acts & Sections
- Indian Evidence Act, 1872 — Sections 24, 25; Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 — Sections 9, 13, 14, 18, 19, 21; Sea Customs Act, 1878 — Section 167(81); Land Customs Act, 1924 — Section 9; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 — Sections 173, 190, 202
Appeal dismissed. The appellant's statement to the Deputy Superintendent of Customs and Excise was held admissible, Section 25 of the Evidence Act not applying and section 24 having no application, so the conviction under section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act restored by the Mysore High Court stood (paras 3, 12).
Source Supreme Court of India, judgment dated 1 March 1966 · Court's copy
Key holdings
- Section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act takes in persons not concerned with the actual import of prohibited goods (para 4).
- The Court left open the broad and narrow views of police officer and proceeded on the broad view (para 7).
- A Central Excise Officer's powers of arrest and search support the main function of levying and collecting duty (para 8).
- Section 21(2) powers serve only the inquiry under section 21(1) and do not include submitting a charge-sheet under section 173 (para 10).
- Mere conferment of powers of investigation does not make an officer a police officer (para 11).
- Raja Ram Jaiswal was distinguished: the Bihar Act deemed the excise officer an officer in charge of a police station; the 1944 Act does not (paras 10, 12).
- With section 24 inapplicable, the statement was admissible and the conviction correct (para 12).
Case explainer by NyayVidhan: an account of this judgment and the law it laid down, not the court's text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.
Brief Facts
Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)
- Does section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act reach a person not concerned with the actual import of prohibited goods?
- Is a Central Excise Officer, given the powers of an officer in charge of a police station by section 21(2), a police officer under Section 25?
- If not, was the statement otherwise excluded, and did the conviction stand?
Submissions
For the appellant. It was admitted that, after Sachidananda Bannerjee, he would be guilty under section 167(81) (para 4), and not disputed that the conviction was correct if his statement was admissible (para 12). A Central Excise Officer is a police officer under Section 25, so the statement, in the nature of a confession, was inadmissible; Raja Ram Jaiswal had held an excise officer under the Bihar and Orissa Excise Act a police officer (para 5). The broad view of the Bombay High Court in Nanoo Sheikh Ahmed was correct (para 7), and section 21(2) gave the officer all the powers of an officer in charge of a police station under Chapter XIV of the Code (para 10). In the High Court the statement was also said to have been obtained by threats (para 12).
For the State. The narrow view of the Patna High Court in Radha Kishun Marwari, confining Section 25 to police officers properly so-called, was correct (para 7). The Court also recorded, without saying who urged it, an argument that the inquiry under section 21(1), read with section 14, differs in substance from an investigation under the Code (para 11).
Court's Findings
Section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act
The point was settled by Sachidananda Bannerjee, which held the Calcutta High Court's reading wrong: the section can take in persons not concerned with the actual import of prohibited goods. The Mysore High Court's view accorded with it (para 4).
Is a Central Excise Officer a police officer?
High Courts were divided between a broad view, treating as police officers all officers with the powers of a police officer for investigating their offences, and a narrow view confined to police officers properly so-called (para 6). Finding prima facie much to be said for the narrow view, the Court assumed the broad one, because even on it the officer failed (para 7). The Act's main purpose is to levy and collect excise duties, and its powers of arrest and search support that function (para 8). Section 21(2) confers the powers of an officer in charge of a police station only for the inquiry under section 21(1). The officer cannot submit a charge-sheet under section 173; a police officer under section 190(b) of the Code is one properly so-called, so he must complain under section 190(a) (para 10). Mere conferment of powers of investigation does not make him a police officer, or anyone investigating under section 202 would be one (para 11). Unlike section 78(3) of the Bihar and Orissa Excise Act, 1915, considered in Raja Ram Jaiswal, section 21 does not deem him an officer in charge of a police station or his area a police station. The scheme being different, Raja Ram Jaiswal did not help the appellant, and the case was more in accord with Barkat Ram (paras 10, 12).
Admissibility and the conviction
The statement was not hit by Section 25. The High Court had not accepted that it was obtained by threats, so section 24 had no application, and it was not disputed that the conviction was correct if the statement was admissible (para 12).
What Changes
Legal Principle
NyayVidhan's view · Practice note
Why It Matters
Badku turned the question on an officer's statutory position. Powers lent to him for his own inquiry were not enough; what mattered was whether the law deemed him an officer in charge of a police station, able to submit a charge-sheet under section 173 (paras 10, 12). The Court proceeded on the broad view of a police officer while finding much to be said for the narrow one (para 7), and it distinguished Raja Ram Jaiswal on the wording of the Bihar Act without deciding which view was right (paras 10, 12). Later rulings on this site carried the distinction to officers under the NDPS Act. In Raj Kumar Karwal v. Union of India (1990) the Court followed Badku in holding such officers not to be police officers. In Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu (2020), which overruled Karwal, the majority explained Badku as a case of limited powers under a revenue statute and held officers empowered to investigate under the NDPS Act to be police officers for Section 25.
Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.
Precedents Relied Upon
- Sitaram Agarwala v. State [1962] Cr. L.J. 43
The Calcutta High Court decision on which the Sessions Judge acquitted the appellant; the Mysore High Court disagreed with it, and this Court noted that its reading of section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act had been held not correct in Sachidananda Bannerjee (paras 3, 4).
- Sachidananda Bannerjee, Assistant Collector of Customs v. Sitaram Agarwal and another [1966] 2 S.C.R. 1
Settled the first question: section 167(81) of the Sea Customs Act can take in persons not concerned with the actual import of prohibited goods; the Mysore High Court's view accorded with it (para 4).
- State of Punjab v. Barkat Ram [1962] 3 S.C.R. 338
Relied on by the High Court for the majority holding that a Customs Officer under the Sea Customs Act is not a police officer under Section 25; the Court held the present case more in accord with it (paras 5, 12).
View all precedents (6)
- Raja Ram Jaiswal v. State of Bihar [1964] 2 S.C.R. 752
Relied on by the appellant (an excise officer under the Bihar and Orissa Excise Act held by majority a police officer). Distinguished: section 78(3) of that Act deemed the excise officer an officer in charge of a police station, while section 21 of the 1944 Act does not, so even on the broader view the appellant could not take advantage of it (paras 5, 10, 12).
- Nanoo Sheikh Ahmed v. Emperor [1927] I.L.R. 51 Bom. 78
The leading case for the broad view of police officer, which the appellant urged; the Court did not decide between the views but proceeded on the assumption that the broad view may be accepted (paras 6, 7).
- Radha Kishun Marwari v. King-Emperor [1933] I.L.R. 12 Patna 46
The leading case for the narrow view (a police officer properly so-called), urged by the State; prima facie much to be said for it, but no final opinion was expressed (paras 6, 7).
