Friday, 20 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court set aside a Central Administrative Tribunal order directing release of a retired Tax Assistant's gratuity. Rule 69(1)(c) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 bars gratuity until departmental or judicial proceedings conclude, and his criminal appeal against conviction is still pending. Following the Supreme Court in Bikram Chand Rana, the Bench held that the bar lasts until the appeal is decided, when his claim revives (paras 16-21).

Raising Pro-Palestine Slogans Without Criminal Force Is Not Unlawful Assembly: Madras High Court Quashes Case
Madras High Court

The Madras High Court quashed the case against fourteen men accused of gathering at Gudalur and raising slogans in support of the Palestinian people, holding that an assembly is unlawful only when its common object falls within the statutory categories, such as using criminal force or committing an offence (paras 7-8). The charge sheet showed no criminal force and no ingredients of wrongful restraint under Section 126(2) BNS (para 8).

Four-Attempt Cap Counts First-Year MBBS Attempts, Not Subjects: Bombay High Court Dismisses Student's Plea
Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court dismissed an MBBS student's plea for another attempt at the First Year Anatomy examination, holding that the proviso to Regulation 21 of the Graduate Medical Education Regulations, 2023 allows four attempts at the first year as a whole, irrespective of the subjects taken in each attempt (paras 24-26). Her first examination, in which she could not take Anatomy, counted as an attempt, and the Rajkumarsingh ruling was distinguished (paras 26, 29).

Sanitary Workers' 18-Year Wait for Housing: Bombay High Court Finds BMC Affidavit Non-Compliant, Seeks Fresh One
Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court found that an affidavit of the Municipal Commissioner of Greater Mumbai did not comply with its order of 10 August 2026, which sought details of municipal lands that could be used to house the Corporation's sanitary workers under a 2008 State policy (paras 2, 5-7). Noting that the policy had not been implemented for about 18 years, it adjourned the matters to 9 September 2026 for a fresh affidavit (paras 5, 9).

Loud Shouting Alone Is Not Disorderly Behaviour Under Section 85: Bombay High Court Quashes FIR, Imposes Costs
Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court quashed an FIR under Section 85(1) of the Maharashtra Prohibition Act against two men accused of shouting loudly at each other on a public street under the influence of alcohol, finding no allegation of any element of obscenity, depravity or moral offensiveness and no cognizable offence (paras 3-6). For the nuisance their shouting caused, it ordered them to pay Rs. 10,000 costs to a charity (para 9).

Welfare, Not Biological Parenthood, Governs Interim Custody: Bombay High Court Declines to Move Child Raised by Neighbour
Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court refused to disturb the custody of a girl who has lived with a neighbour and his wife since she was about two months old, holding that her welfare, not her biological parents' legal right, is decisive (paras 34, 62). It upheld the District Judge's refusal of interim custody, asked for the main custody case to be decided preferably within six months and gave the parents access twice a week (para 67).

Economic Offences Involving Abuse of Fiduciary Structures Call for Greater Circumspection: P&H High Court Denies PMLA Bail
Punjab and Haryana High Court

The Punjab and Haryana High Court refused regular bail to Sandeep Gupta, accused by the Enforcement Directorate of laundering about ₹236 crore diverted from Richa Industries Limited through shell entities (paras 1-2, 8). It held that where material prima facie shows a specific, active role, especially through misuse of corporate or fiduciary structures, bail must be approached with greater circumspection (paras 6.1-7).

OBC Enumeration in Census Is a Policy Decision for Government: Madras High Court Declines to Intervene
Madras High Court

A Division Bench of the Madras High Court at Madurai declined to direct that Other Backward Classes be counted in the Census, holding that whether to include the OBC category or any other caste is a policy decision, and also a matter for individuals, who may choose not to state their caste (para 3). It disposed of two writ petitions without setting aside the 2020 notification limiting caste enumeration to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (para 4).

Wife's Unexplained Stays at Maternal Home, Pressure on Only Son to Live Separately Are Cruelty: Madras High Court
Madras High Court

A Division Bench of the Madras High Court upheld a divorce granted to a husband on the ground of cruelty, holding that a wife's frequent stays at her maternal home without valid reason, and her pressure on her husband, an only son, to set up a separate residence away from his parents, amounted to cruelty (paras 9-10). It dismissed her appeal against the Cuddalore Family Court's decree of 08.07.2026 (para 11).

No Extended Limitation on a Bare Allegation of Suppression: Supreme Court Quashes GST Notice Against Tata Steel
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside a CGST show cause notice and the resulting demand against Tata Steel for 2018-19 to 2020-21, holding that the five-year period under Section 74 cannot be invoked by merely reciting 'suppression of facts'. The notice of 13.06.2025 came after the three-year limit had expired on 28.02.2025, even after the Covid exclusion, and stated no foundational facts. The Department may proceed afresh, but must pass its order before 28.02.2027 (paras 7, 13-15).

Night Search Without Warrant Valid If Grounds Recorded and Sent to Superior: Rajasthan High Court Denies NDPS Bail
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused bail to a man found with 180 grams of mephedrone during a 10 pm search of a house without a warrant. The SHO had recorded the information and his grounds for not getting a warrant before the search and sent them to his superior, which was prima facie compliance with Section 42 of the NDPS Act (paras 12-15). As commercial quantity was involved, the Section 37 bar applied (para 17).

Rajasthan High Court Refuses to Quash FIR Against Non-Enrolled Man Who Appeared as Advocate, Imposes ₹50,000 Costs
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused to quash an FIR against a man accused of appearing before trial courts as an advocate without enrolment, holding that no one may practise or represent himself as an advocate unless enrolled with the State Bar Council under the Advocates Act, 1961 (para 5). It refused his counsel's mid-hearing request to withdraw the petition and dismissed it with costs of Rs 50,000 (paras 2, 6).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt