Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Security Cheques Need a Proved, Crystallised Debt Under Section 138; Ledger Alone Not Enough: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court refused a company leave to appeal against the acquittal of its clearing and forwarding agent in a cheque-bounce case (paras 1, 17). The two Rs 15 lakh cheques were said to be security under the agency agreement, but no loss had been quantified or demanded in writing as its indemnity clause required (paras 10-12). Issuing a security cheque does not prove a legally enforceable debt, and a computer-generated ledger alone did not prove the goods supplied (paras 13-14).

Essential Commodities Act Confiscation Does Not Depend on Prosecuting Vehicle Owner: Rajasthan High Court Upholds Tanker Penalty
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court dismissed a tanker owner's revision against a Rs 23,59,375 penalty imposed by the District Collector, Ajmer under Section 6-A of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 (paras 1, 13). Confiscation under Section 6-A does not depend on prosecuting the vehicle's owner, so his being cited as a prosecution witness rather than an accused did not help him (paras 8, 10). Nor had he proved the Section 6-B(2) defence (paras 9-10).

Complainant Cannot Be Kept Out: Supreme Court Sets Aside Lucknow Development Authority Order in City Montessori School Case
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside an order of 21.10.2026 passed by the Lucknow Development Authority in Section 27 proceedings under the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973, because City Montessori School, on whose complaint of unauthorised construction the proceedings began, was not heard. A High Court direction to decide independently and impartially never meant that the complainant be kept away, the Court said. Both sides must be heard afresh on a date within one month (paras 4-6).

Lender With Board, Budget and Sales Powers Is a Related Party, Barred From the CoC: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court upheld the exclusion of ECL Finance, sole debenture holder and lender, and its debenture trustee from the Committee of Creditors of a guarantor company as related parties under Section 5(24)(m)(i) of the IBC. That clause needs only association through participation in policy making, not the proactive control required under Section 29A, and the Court found no question of law or perversity in the tribunals' findings (paras 17, 23-24, 27).

Unpaid Excise Duty on Uncleared Sugar Stock Cannot Be Disallowed Under Section 43B When Never Claimed: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court allowed Lakshmi Sugar Mills' appeal and set aside a High Court judgment upholding the addition of Rs 69,91,983 of unpaid excise duty on closing stock for Assessment Year 2005-06 under Sections 43B and 145A of the Income Tax Act. The High Court assumed the goods had been removed, but the stock lay in a bonded warehouse, and the company never claimed the duty as an expense (paras 10, 14-16).

Life Sentences for Murder and Rape Cannot Run Consecutively, Only Superimposed: Supreme Court Applies Muthuramalingam
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that two life sentences imposed in a single trial for the rape and murder of a 12-year-old, under Section 302 and Section 376 read with Section 342 IPC, cannot be directed to run consecutively. Applying the Constitution Bench ruling in Muthuramalingam, it set aside the Trial Court's consecutive-sentence direction, confirmed by the Bombay High Court, and directed that the two life sentences be superimposed, so that remission or commutation of one does not ipso facto remit the other (paras 15-18).

Section 43D(7) UAPA Bars Bail Only If Foreign Accused Entered India Illegally, Not on Later Overstay: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that the bail bar in Section 43D(7) of the UAP Act applies only when the prosecution prima facie shows that the accused is not an Indian citizen and entered India unauthorisedly or illegally. A visa overstay after a lawful entry does not qualify. Dismissing the Union's appeal, it upheld the Madras High Court's order restoring an alleged Sri Lankan national's default bail (paras 30-31, 47, 50).

Supreme Court Quashes POCSO Conviction Under Article 142 as Victim and Accused Married During Trial
Supreme Court of India

In P.T. v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr., the Supreme Court used Article 142 of the Constitution to quash the appellant's conviction and sentence under the POCSO Act and the IPC, the proceedings behind them and his pending appeal in the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The parties had married during the trial and live together as husband and wife. The Court acted on the case's peculiar facts and said the power ought to be invoked sparingly in serious crimes against children and women (paras 15-19).

Women's Bar Room Required in District and Taluka Courts Wherever Women Advocates Practise, Irrespective of Strength: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

In Sarika Tyagi & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., the Supreme Court emphasised that State Governments, Union Territories and High Courts must ensure a separate and exclusive Women's Bar Room, with basic amenities such as washrooms, wherever women members of the Bar practise in District and Taluka Courts, irrespective of their strength. It directed the States and UT Administrations to allocate funds and land, and the High Courts' Building and Infrastructure Committees to treat the issue as a priority (para 3).

High Court's Unreasoned Dismissal of Quash Plea Set Aside: Supreme Court Directs Joint Hearing With Chargesheet Challenge
Supreme Court of India

In Kamlesh Kumar Gupta v. State of U.P. & Anr., the Supreme Court set aside an Allahabad High Court order of 09.08.2023 that had summarily dismissed a Section 482 CrPC petition against a summoning order, finding the order ‘bereft of reasons’ (para 11). The petition goes back to the High Court for fresh adjudication, to be heard with the appellant's pending challenge to a chargesheet filed on an FIR over the same set of allegations; the stay of the complaint case continues (paras 12-13).

Jojari River Pollution: Supreme Court Halts New Industrial Permissions Near Rivers, Orders SIT Into Illegal Bajri Mining
Supreme Court of India

In Re: 2 Million Lives at Risk, Contamination in Jojari River, Rajasthan, the Supreme Court restrained the State of Rajasthan from permitting new industrial units along or near the river ecosystem until the High Flood Line and buffer zones are scientifically determined, with a 100-metre protective zone and no Red Category industry within 500 metres (para 24(A)). Deprecating the Mining Department's apparent attempt to legitimise illegal riverbed mining through later leases, it ordered a Special Investigation Team (paras 22, 24(B)). The matter is part-heard (para 27).

Ex Post Facto Environmental Clearance: Supreme Court Directs SEAC and SEIAA to Assess Ecological Damage as on Today
Supreme Court of India

In M/s Grenesiis Constro Pvt. Ltd. v. Vishal Arinjay Shah & Ors., the Supreme Court, hearing appeals over the National Green Tribunal's setting aside of the appellant's ex post facto environmental clearance of 09.08.2019, directed the SEAC and the SEIAA to comply, within eight weeks, with paragraph 13(5) of the Notification dated 14.03.2017. It was of the opinion that an assessment ‘ought to be made depicting the current scenario as on today’ (paras 22-24). The interim order continues; the appeals return on 08.01.2027 (paras 30-31).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt