Thursday, 19 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Section 528 BNSS Petition Against Cheque Bounce Conviction Not Maintainable When Appeal Lies: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that a petition under Section 528 BNSS filed directly against a judgment convicting the petitioner under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was not maintainable, because a statutory appeal lies against that judgment (paras 2, 6). It distinguished Rekha Sharad Ushir, where a cognizance order had been set aside, since a full trial had taken place here (paras 4-5), and left all objections to the appeal (para 7).

Other Criminal Cases Alone No Ground to Deny Bail: Rajasthan High Court Grants Bail on Stringent Conditions
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that the mere existence of other criminal cases against an accused is not, by itself, a conclusive ground to deny bail; antecedents must be weighed with the other relevant factors (paras 5-7). Noting acquittals in half of 52 cases, custody of over eleven months with the prosecution evidence not yet begun, and a seven-year maximum sentence, it granted bail in an Arms Act and Explosives Act case on stringent conditions (paras 7, 10-13).

Suspension in Workplace Harassment Inquiry Cannot Be Quashed Merely for No Charge-Sheet Within Three Months: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court set aside a Tribunal order that had quashed a doctor's suspension, made in contemplation of an inquiry into a workplace sexual-harassment complaint, only because no charge-sheet was served within three months. Ajay Kumar Choudhary requires review and reasons to extend a suspension, not its automatic quashing; the challenge was premature, and such cases call for caution (paras 30-33). The suspension was revived (para 36).

Civil Remedies Don't Bar Prosecution: Supreme Court Revives FIR Over Alleged Fake Resignation Email in Arunachal Company Row
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside a Gauhati High Court order that had quashed an FIR alleging that a resignation email was fraudulently sent in the name of a majority shareholder of an Arunachal Pradesh saw-mill company. Company-law remedies do not foreclose a criminal prosecution, and a delayed charge-sheet raises no presumption of no evidence. The investigation will continue, but the two accused will not be arrested if they cooperate (paras 9, 12, 15).

Child Brought to India in Breach of US Custody Order Must Return: Supreme Court Allows Father's Habeas Plea
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court allowed a US-based father's appeal against the Karnataka High Court's refusal of habeas corpus for his US-citizen daughter, whom the mother brought to India two weeks after a California court ordered joint custody. The child's welfare stays paramount, but a foreign order deserves proper weight and a parent should not profit from disobeying it; the mother is to take the child to the US by 31.12.2026 (paras 15-19, 26-27, 32-35, 39).

Sole Eyewitness Couldn't Have Seen Through a Closed Door: Supreme Court Acquits Man in 1998 Rohtak Murder
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court acquitted a man serving life for a 1998 murder in Rohtak, holding that the sole eyewitness, who admitted the door was closed, could not be trusted, and that the forensic report never matched the blood on his clothes or the gandasa with the victim's. With nothing linking him to the death, and his wife already acquitted, he got the benefit of doubt (paras 14-22).

Inquiry Against Judge for Granting Bail Not Warranted: Supreme Court Quashes Charges, Orders Retired Judge's Dues Paid
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court quashed a departmental inquiry the Rajasthan High Court began against a Dholpur POCSO Special Judge who granted bail after the High Court had refused it, holding that counselling or an ACR entry would have sufficed. It let the High Court's adverse remarks stand, but ordered the retired officer's revised pay, pension and arrears released within three months (paras 10-14).

No Revised Return, No Fresh Claim in Section 264 Revision: Supreme Court Dismisses Orissa Rural Housing Corporation's Appeals
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held that an assessee who has not filed a revised return in time cannot raise a fresh claim before the Commissioner in revision under Section 264 of the Income Tax Act. Reiterating Om Siddhakala Associates and Goetze (India), it said revision is for a new point of law on facts already before the Assessing Officer; otherwise assessments would never end (paras 8-13).

Tramadol Capsules Case: Supreme Court Grants Bail to Medical Store Operators Linked Only by Co-Accused's Statement
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court granted bail to two men alleged to have run a medical store that supplied Tramadol-combination capsules (Proxyco SPAS) to co-accused caught with 878 capsules weighing 412.66 grams in a Rajasthan NDPS case. They were apprehended only on the co-accused's statement, whether they sold the contraband is a matter for trial, they had no criminal antecedents and the chargesheet had been filed, so continued custody was not warranted (paras 3-4).

Jharkhand DGP Rule Prima Facie Against Prakash Singh: Supreme Court Issues Notice to Serving DGP
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court said that Jharkhand's 2025 regulations, which make an officer eligible for appointment as Director General of Police even with less than six months' service left before superannuation by crediting retrospective service, prima facie run 'directly in teeth of' Prakash Singh. Since annulling the rule would also unseat the serving DGP, Tadasha Mishra, the Court directed that she be served notice (paras 1-3).

Enhanced Compensation Pending First Appeals: Supreme Court Allows 8.33% Release, Urges Allahabad High Court Decision in Six Months
Supreme Court of India

In land acquisition proceedings dating back to 1987, the Supreme Court disposed of the Meerut Development Authority's petitions against interim orders of the Allahabad High Court. The Authority must deposit the entire enhanced compensation with the High Court, of which 8.33% is to be released to the landowners and the rest invested, matching an earlier order; the High Court was asked to decide the first appeals preferably within six months (paras 3, 7-11).

Pharma Marketing Framework Not Entirely Effective: Supreme Court Directs Committee Within Two Weeks, Report in Two Months
Supreme Court of India

In a pending petition seeking binding rules against unethical marketing by drug companies, the Supreme Court found that the existing framework has not proved entirely effective. Leaving policy to the Union, it directed the Union to set up its proposed committee within two weeks, hear the petitioners, intervenors and other stakeholders, and report within two months of its first meeting; the case returns on 29.01.2027 (paras 17-25).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt