Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Non-Signatory Partners Whose Rights Turn on Disputed Retirement Deed Are Veritable Parties to Arbitration: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court held, prima facie, that two later partners of a Mumbai firm who never signed the 1985 partnership deed containing the arbitration clause are veritable parties to the arbitration over the firm's commercial property, because their rights depend on whether the appellants' disputed 1995 retirement deed is valid (paras 15-17). Their limitation and estoppel objections were left to the Arbitral Tribunal (paras 16, 18).

Disability Pension Ruling Does Not Allow Arrears in Every Case, Each Claim on Its Merits: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court clarified that its common judgment of 12.02.2026 in Union of India v. Sgt Girish Kumar, which held ex-servicemen entitled to disability pension with broad banding and interest, cannot be read to mean that disability pension with arrears can be claimed in every case; each claim must be decided on its own merits (paras 2, 8). The Union had said courts and tribunals were extending it to settled cases (para 4).

Where Arbitration Clause Names Two Places, Exclusive-Jurisdiction Clause Decides the Seat: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside the Delhi High Court's appointment of an arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, holding that where the arbitration clause names both Delhi and Goa, the named venue does not automatically become the seat, and the clause giving Goa courts exclusive jurisdiction shows that Goa is the juridical seat (paras 21-22, 24).

Amendment After Trial Begins Allowed Where Compromise Decree Was Discovered Later: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court allowed a plaintiff's amendment, sought after the trial had begun, to challenge a compromise decree affecting part of the suit land that he said he learned of only later, holding that due diligence under the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC was shown and the nature of the suit was unchanged (paras 13.2, 14). Arguable limitation and Order XXIII Rule 3A objections were left to the trial court (paras 16.2, 17).

JEN 2020 Paper Leak: Rajasthan High Court Grants Bail to Two Accused, Says Seriousness Alone Cannot Bar Bail
Rajasthan High Court

In Ganpatlal Malwada v. State of Rajasthan (2026:RJ-JP:41788), the Rajasthan High Court granted bail to two men accused by the SOG in the Junior Engineer Examination, 2020 paper-leak case. The seriousness of the accusation, it held, cannot by itself be the sole ground for refusing bail. It relied on the filed charge-sheet, the offences being triable by a Magistrate, co-accused already on bail and a long trial ahead, without commenting on the merits (paras 12-13).

Representation Cannot Wait for the Advisory Board: Gauhati High Court Quashes PIT-NDPS Detention
Gauhati High Court

The Gauhati High Court at Kohima has quashed a PIT-NDPS detention order of 09.04.2026, and its confirmation of 09.07.2026, against a man already in judicial custody in an NDPS case (paras 3-4, 24). The Union Government received his representation on 29.04.2026, after the reference to the Advisory Board but before its opinion, yet waited for that opinion and rejected it only on 15.06.2026, contrary to Ankit Ashok Jalan (paras 22-23).

No Proof of Lack of Knowledge: Chhattisgarh High Court Upholds Confiscation of Motorcycle in NDPS Case, Cuts Sentences
Chhattisgarh High Court

The Chhattisgarh High Court upheld the confiscation of a motorcycle on which three men were travelling when 50.560 g of brown sugar was seized from one of them, because its owner, the grandfather of one convict, gave no evidence that it was used without his knowledge (paras 33, 37-39). In the connected appeals it maintained two convictions under Section 21(b) of the NDPS Act but cut the 10-year sentences to the period already undergone and the fines to Rs.10,000 (paras 30-32).

Hydroponic Ganja's Higher THC and Value Count Against Bail: Karnataka High Court Refuses Bail to Airport Accused
Karnataka High Court

The Karnataka High Court has refused regular bail to a man accused of bringing hydroponic ganja into Bengaluru from Bangkok, with 16.360 kg of a 26.230 kg seizure from three passengers attributed to him (paras 3, 6). Applying its order of 17.08.2026 in Crl.P No. 9787/2026, the Court held that the higher THC content, value and social harm of hydroponic ganja must weigh with courts, and that an intermediate quantity is not by itself a ground for bail (paras 6-7).

Findings Without Legal Evidence Perverse Despite Fair Inquiry: High Court Upholds Dairy Workman's Reinstatement, Awards 50% Back Wages
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court upheld a Labour Court award reinstating a dairy workman removed in 1991 over the alleged theft of 25 tins of ghee. Although the domestic inquiry had been held fair, the inquiry officer's findings rested on no legal evidence and were perverse, so the Labour Court rightly interfered (paras 24-25). The employer's writ petition was dismissed and the workman's allowed to the extent of 50% of the back wages (paras 30-32).

FIR on Same Facts After Complaint Dismissed Under Section 203 CrPC Not Permissible: Rajasthan High Court
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court quashed an FIR for forgery and cheating against a Sarpanch, registered on the complainant's second complaint after his first complaint on the same allegations had been dismissed under Section 203 CrPC (paras 6-7, 9-10). Relying on the Supreme Court's decisions on second FIRs, it held that registration of a second FIR by the same complainant on the same facts is not permissible (paras 8-9).

Manager With Control Over Vendors Not an "Employee" Under Rajasthan Shops Act: High Court Quashes Reinstatement Order
Rajasthan High Court

The Rajasthan High Court held that a Manager (Operations) whose duties were managerial, including control over vendor selection and the business affairs of his area, was not an 'employee' under Section 2(5) of the Rajasthan Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1958 (para 16). The authority under Section 28A therefore had no jurisdiction to set aside his dismissal and order reinstatement; its order was quashed, leaving him free to pursue other remedies (paras 17-18).

Supreme Court Keeps Ban on Unauthorised Posting of Court Live-Stream Recordings, Asks Centre for Proposal
Supreme Court of India

A Bench led by the Chief Justice kept in force its interim directions of 24.07.2026 barring the extraction, monetisation, posting or hosting of recordings of court proceedings on social media without permission, and gave the Solicitor General two weeks to file a comprehensive proposal on preventing commercial exploitation and misleading use of court live streams (paras 1-5).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt