Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Judgment Highlights

Landmark rulings, constitutional decisions and tribunal orders shaping Indian law.

Lifelong Care Means 100% Functional Disability: Supreme Court Doubles Compensation for Two Accident Victims
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court raised compensation for two men hurt in a 2016 scooter accident in Kerala, holding that functional disability, not the medical board's percentage, decides loss of earning capacity. The pillion rider, certified at 75.5% but needing lifelong care, was treated as 100% disabled and gets Rs.77.84 lakh; the 22-year-old rider, certified at 62%, was treated as 80% disabled and gets Rs.69.61 lakh (paras 5.1.3, 5.5, 6.2.1, 6.7).

High Court Was Misled on Criminal History: Supreme Court Sets Aside Gangsters Act Bail, Orders Surrender
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside an Allahabad High Court order granting bail to an accused under the UP Gangsters Act, finding that the High Court was not told of his criminal history - nine cases listed in the State's counter affidavit - and was misled that he had none. The bail plea goes back to the High Court for fresh consideration, and the accused must surrender by 30.10.2026 (paras 3-4, 7-12).

Over Two Years in Jail, Only 7 of 147 Witnesses Examined: Supreme Court Grants Sandip Ghosh Bail
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court granted bail to Sandip Ghosh, charge-sheeted by the CBI's Anti-Corruption Branch, Kolkata, over alleged financial irregularities in the college where he was Principal and the alleged accommodation of undeserving candidates through manipulated merit scores. He has been in custody for more than two years and only 7 of 147 witnesses have been examined. The High Court's refusal of bail was set aside (paras 4-7).

Supreme Court Asks High Courts to Set Up District Execution Cells; Rajasthan HC Yet to Respond
Supreme Court of India

In its follow-up on delays in executing civil decrees, the Supreme Court noted that 17 High Courts support District Execution Cells, four oppose them, three are still considering, and the Rajasthan High Court has not responded. It asked the supporting High Courts to set up the cells, directed the Union Law Ministry to file an affidavit on funding, and required executing courts to call for judgment-debtors' asset affidavits (paras 2-8).

Homebuyer Refund Limited to Own Payments, Not Bank-Disbursed Loan: Supreme Court Invokes Unjust Enrichment
Supreme Court of India

Where a builder failed to deliver a flat bought with a home loan disbursed under a tripartite agreement, the Supreme Court held the buyer entitled only to the Rs.1.27 crore he paid himself, with 12% interest, not the Rs.2.19 crore refund ordered by the NCDRC, which included the lender's money. Paying him unrepaid loan money would be unjust enrichment; he gets Rs.15 lakh compensation but no rent on top of interest (paras 28, 31, 37, 41).

Yes Bank's AT-1 Bond Write-Down Illegal: Supreme Court Upholds Bombay High Court, Says Administrator Lacked Power
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed appeals by Yes Bank, the RBI and the Union of India against the Bombay High Court's 2023 judgment setting aside the Administrator's write-down of Yes Bank's Rs. 3,000 crore and Rs. 5,415 crore AT-1 bonds on 14.03.2020. The final Reconstruction Scheme had dropped the write-down clause, any write-down had to precede the reconstruction, and at the point of non-viability only the RBI could write the bonds down (paras 40, 63, 70, 80).

Record of Default From Information Utility Is Sufficient Proof for Section 7 Admission: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court upheld the admission into insolvency of the companies owning the JW Marriott Hotel, Bangalore and the Crowne Plaza Hotel, Pune, on Omkara ARC's Section 7 petitions. Default need only be shown on a summary, prima facie standard; an authenticated Information Utility record of default is by itself sufficient and displaceable only by clear, cogent material; and a positive EBITDA does not disprove default (paras 47, 55, 58, 65).

No-Interest Clause Ending With 'Or Otherwise' Bars Pre-Award Interest in Arbitration: Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court upheld the Delhi High Court's ruling that a sub-contract clause refusing interest claims on held-up payments, deposits and delayed payments "or otherwise" barred the arbitrator from awarding pre-reference and pendente lite interest under Section 31(7)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The residuary words are not read down by ejusdem generis; the contractor keeps its substantive claims and post-award interest (paras 14, 16-18).

Conversion to Islam Does Not Confer Backward Class Muslim Status: Supreme Court Upholds Quashing of Tamil Nadu G.O.
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed Tamil Nadu's challenge to a Madras High Court judgment striking down G.O.(Ms.) No. 314 of 09.03.2024, which let converts to Islam from Backward Class, Most Backward Class, Denotified and Scheduled Caste communities to be certified as members of seven notified Backward Class Muslim communities. Conversion establishes religious affiliation, not membership of a birth-based community, and backwardness suffered in the Hindu social order does not travel into the new religion (paras 39, 45, 62-63).

Contradictions 'Act as a Mirror' to Defence: Supreme Court Suspends Life Sentence in 1997 Bhadrak Murder
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court suspended the life sentence of a man convicted of a 1997 sword attack and murder at Chandabali Bazar in Bhadrak, Odisha, and granted him bail pending his appeal. He has served more than twelve years, and, prima facie, contradictions in the evidence, including a witness's failure to identify him, 'act as a mirror' to his contentions (paras 6-11).

Supreme Court Sets Aside Rajasthan High Court Interim Order as Uncalled For With Civil Suit Pending
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court set aside an interim order of 18.08.2025 passed by the Rajasthan High Court at Jaipur in two criminal miscellaneous petitions, finding it completely uncalled for while civil suit no. 71/2022 for specific performance, declaration with respect to sale deeds and permanent injunction is pending. Without going into the merits, it requested the High Court to decide the main matters within about four months and kept all questions of law open, including reliance on a forensic signature comparison (paras 3-9).

Supreme Court Refuses to Disturb Acquittal of 17 Accused in 1992 Fatal Assault Over School Land
Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court dismissed a de facto complainant's appeal and left undisturbed the acquittal of 17 accused charged over the death of his brother, assaulted in 1992 during a dispute over school land. Finding grave discrepancies among the eyewitnesses and the medical jurist, and the accused rising from 10 in the FIR to 17 at trial, the Court saw no perversity in the concurrent findings and gave primacy to the view favouring the accused (paras 7-8, 17-19).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt