Judgment Intelligence
Acquittal Set Aside- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of Decision
- 27 September 2019
- Bench
- Justices Uday Umesh Lalit and Vineet Saran
- Relevant Acts & Sections
- Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 — Sections 8, 15
Appeal allowed; acquittal set aside and conviction restored with 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment, fine and default sentence unchanged. The respondent was to surrender before the concerned Police Station within seven days, failing which he would immediately be taken in custody; a copy was to be sent to the concerned CJM and the Police Station for intimation and compliance (paras 18-20).
Source Supreme Court of India, judgment dated 27 September 2019 · Court's copy
Key holdings
- None of the Court’s earlier decisions found non-production, by itself, sufficient for acquittal (para 15).
- Jitendra, Ashok, Vijay Jain and Vijay Pandey each also rested on other gaps (para 15).
- If the seizure is otherwise proved and not disputed, the entire contraband need not be produced (para 17).
- The prosecution must then prove intact samples, intact seals when sent for forensic examination and a report on the contraband’s potency, nature and quality (para 17).
- Unchallenged evidence of sampling and sealing, with a seizure memo signed by the accused, proved the seizure (para 16).
Case explainer by NyayVidhan: an account of this judgment and the law it laid down, not the court's text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.
Brief Facts
Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)
- Do the decisions relied on by the High Court hold that the prosecution case must be discarded if the contraband is not produced?
- Was the seizure of 223 kg proved, though only two sample packets and a 2.5 kg bag were produced?
- If the seizure is proved, must the whole contraband be produced, and what must be proved instead?
Submissions
For the State. The State appealed against the High Court’s acquittal of 7 April 2016 (paras 2, 8). It was heard, but the judgment does not set out its submissions (para 9).
For the respondent. In the High Court he urged a single ground: the Muddamal, the contraband itself, was not produced before the court, and the evidence did not support the seizure and recovery of 223 kg. The High Court accepted it, relying on Noor Aga, Jitendra, Ashok and Vijay Jain (para 8). No submissions of his in this Court are recorded (para 9).
Court's Findings
What the earlier decisions held
The Court first asked whether the decisions relied on by the High Court state in unequivocal terms that the prosecution case must be discarded if the contraband is not produced (para 10). Non-production was pressed in each, but never alone decided the case: in Jitendra other facets weighed; in Ashok there was no explanation where the seized substance was kept and nothing connected the forensic report with it; in Vijay Jain the evidence did not establish that the material was seized from the appellants; in Vijay Pandey nothing connected the forensic report with the substance seized (paras 11-15). Non-production had never singularly been found sufficient for acquittal (para 15).
Proof of the seizure
The police witness’s evidence showed that about 500 grams were taken from each of the 7 bags; two samples of 500 grams and the remaining 2500 grams were sealed separately and marked A, B and C. The bags were sealed and taken into custody, and the seizure memo recording this was signed by the accused. No suggestion was put in cross-examination that the signatures were taken by fraud, coercion or misrepresentation, or were not the accused’s. The seizure of 223 kg stood conclusively proven (para 16).
Producing the bulk
If the seizure is otherwise proved and not doubted or disputed, the entire contraband need not be produced; bulk such as 223 kg may not be feasible to produce. What must be proved is that the samples were kept intact, that the seals were intact when they were sent for forensic examination, that the experts’ report shows the potency, nature and quality of the contraband, and that the ingredients of the offence are made out (para 17). The High Court’s conclusion was completely unsustainable (para 18).
Legal Principle
NyayVidhan's view · Practice note
Why It Matters
The ruling separates two questions: whether the seizure is proved, and whether the bulk must be produced. Once the seizure is proved, as here by unchallenged evidence of sampling and sealing and a seizure memo signed by the accused, bulky contraband need not be brought to court; the prosecution must still prove intact samples, intact seals when they went for forensic examination and an experts’ report showing the nature of the substance (paras 16-17). The Court read Jitendra v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Ashok v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Vijay Jain v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Vijay Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh as acquittals resting on further gaps, not on non-production alone (para 15).
Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.
Precedents Relied Upon
- Noor Aga v. State of Punjab & Another (2008) 16 SCC 417
Named among the decisions on which the High Court relied in holding that failure to exhibit the contraband was fatal (para 8); the Court quoted Vijay Jain’s reading of the Noor Aga passage, which requires the samples to be produced even where the bulk is destroyed but says nothing about the consequence of not producing the contraband (para 13).
- Jitendra & Another v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2004) 10 SCC 562
Relied on by the High Court (para 8). The Court quoted the submission and the reasoning recorded in it (para 11), noted that Ashok relied on it (para 12), and read it as a case where, apart from non-production, other facets of the matter also weighed with the Court (para 15).
- Ashok alias Dangra Jaiswal v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2011) 5 SCC 123
Relied on by the High Court (para 8). The Court quoted its reasoning (para 12) and noted that the absence of any explanation where the seized substance was kept, and of evidence connecting the forensic report with the substance seized, were also relied on in giving the benefit of doubt (para 15).
View all precedents (5)
- Vijay Jain v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2013) 14 SCC 527
Relied on by the High Court (para 8). The Court quoted its reasoning (para 13), noted that Vijay Pandey relied on it (para 14), and read it as a case where the evidence did not establish that the material was seized from the appellants, one of the relevant circumstances (para 15).
- Vijay Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh Criminal Appeal No.1143 of 2019 @ SLP(Crl) No.1273 of 2019 decided on 30.07.2019
A recent decision, quoted in part, which extended the benefit because the seized sample was not co-related with the one tested (para 14); the Court noted that there, too, the lack of evidence connecting the forensic report with the substance seized was relied on (para 15).



