Thursday, 19 November 2026
Rajasthan High Court
Service Law

Minor Penalty Within Seven Years No Automatic Bar to Promotion, Circular Cannot Exclude: Rajasthan High Court Full Bench

State of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Ajay Kant Ratudi (Sharma) 2026:RJ-JP:44847-DB Decided 18 November 2026

Published: · NyayVidhan · 4 min read

In State of Rajasthan v. Ajay Kant Ratudi (2026:RJ-JP:44847-DB), a Full Bench of the Rajasthan High Court answered a reference on minor penalties and promotion. A government servant censured, or denied one increment without cumulative effect, under Rule 14 of the 1958 Rules within seven years can be considered for promotion; a circular cannot exclude an eligible officer unless the statutory rules prescribe the bar. For seniority-cum-merit promotion the DPC may weigh the penalty as part of the record, but it is no automatic ground of unsuitability (paras 30, 38-39).

Minor Penalty Within Seven Years No Automatic Bar to Promotion, Circular Cannot Exclude: Rajasthan High Court Full Bench

Judgment Intelligence

Reference Answered
State of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Ajay Kant Ratudi (Sharma)
2026:RJ-JP:44847-DB
D.B. Civil Reference No. 3/2025
Court
Rajasthan High Court
Date of Decision
18 November 2026
Bench
Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal, Justice Sameer Jain and Justice Pramil Kumar Mathur
Relevant Acts & Sections
Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1958 — Rules 14, 15(2), 17 and 30-34; Rajasthan Police Service Rules, 1954 — Rules 15, 27, 28 and 28-A; Rajasthan High Court Rules, 1952 — Rule 134
Final Outcome

Both referred questions were answered as set out in para 39, and the reference was disposed of. The matter is to be placed before the Bench having roster to decide the writ in light of the answers (paras 39-41).

Source Rajasthan High Court, hcraj.nic.in — judgment delivered 18 November 2026, uploaded 18 November 2026

Key holdings

  1. Censure or one increment withheld without cumulative effect within seven years does not disqualify a government servant from promotion consideration (paras 30, 39).
  2. Non-promotion without consideration is in substance the penalty of withholding promotion, which only the disciplinary authority can impose (para 17).
  3. Executive instructions may supplement the statutory rules but cannot add a disqualification the rules do not contain (paras 18-20, 23).
  4. In seniority-cum-merit promotion the DPC may consider a minor penalty as part of the record when judging minimum suitability (paras 37-38).
  5. A minor penalty is no automatic ground for denying promotion merely because a circular so provides (paras 38-39).

Judgment digest by NyayVidhan: a summary of the court's judgment, not its text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.

Brief Facts

Rule 14 of the Rajasthan Civil Services (CCA) Rules, 1958 lists censure and withholding of increments or promotion as minor penalties and prescribes no period of ineligibility for promotion (paras 9-10, 14). Department of Personnel circulars of 2006 and 2008 looked at penalties in the seven years before the vacancy year (para 12). The respondent, a police Inspector who had been censured, sought consideration for promotion to the Rajasthan Police Service (Junior Scale); on 23 August 2024 a Single Judge granted it, following Pradeep Singh Charan and Raghuveer Singh (paras 4-6). The State appealed, and on 22 October 2024 issued a circular that censure will not deny promotion (paras 7, 21). Finding conflicting views, a Division Bench referred two questions on 27 August 2025 in D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 591/2025 (paras 1, 8).

Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)

  1. Can a government servant who suffered censure or withholding of one increment without cumulative effect under Rule 14 within seven years be considered for promotion? (Question I, as referred)
  2. In seniority-cum-merit promotion, can a penalty awarded within seven years be considered for denying promotion? (Question II, as referred)

Submissions

For the State. The judgment does not set out counsel's submissions; it lists the counsel who assisted (para 42). It records the State's position: the seven-year period comes from the circulars of 26 July 2006 and 4 June 2008, and the State also relied on the circular of 22 October 2024 (para 12). It appealed the Single Judge's order under Rule 134 of the High Court Rules (para 7).

For the respondent. No submissions are recorded either. The order in his favour followed Raghuveer Singh and Pradeep Singh Charan, where the 2008 circular was held unable to deprive a censured employee of consideration, and a circular could not attach the consequence of one penalty to another (paras 5-6, 26).

Court's Findings

Question I: a circular cannot create the bar

Withholding of promotion is itself a penalty under Rule 14(ii), and non-promotion escapes that label only when it follows "consideration of his case" (paras 14-17). Non-promotion without consideration is, in substance, that penalty, which only the disciplinary authority can impose under Rule 17 (para 17). The Rules allow enhancement only under Rules 30-34, with notice and at most three years, so a seven-year bar by circular raises the penalty with no notice or hearing: "What the Rules forbid directly cannot be achieved indirectly by an executive instruction" (para 18). Following Sant Ram Sharma, Guman Singh and Manoj Kumar Chak, instructions may fill gaps but cannot supplant the rules (paras 19-20, 23). The Police Service Rules contain no such disqualification, and the State's own 2024 circular says censure will not defer promotion (paras 11, 21-22). Division Bench rulings in Ashok Singhvi and Manoj Kumar Machra had refused exclusion by circular (paras 24-25).

Question II: the DPC may weigh the penalty

Seniority-cum-merit means each eligible candidate must meet a minimum standard, and those who do are promoted by seniority (para 31). Under Jankiraman the whole record, including penalties, may be considered; Mohanan treats censure as blameworthy; and Shankar Lal Parmar, though about selection grade rather than promotion, accepts censure as part of the record (paras 29, 32-33, 37). Ashok Singhvi preserved the DPC's power to find an employee unsuitable (para 35). So the penalty is relevant to suitability, but its mere existence is no automatic bar or finding of unsuitability merely because a circular says so (paras 37-38).

Legal Principle

Unless the governing statutory rules prescribe a disqualification, a circular cannot exclude an eligible government servant from promotion consideration for a minor penalty within seven years. In seniority-cum-merit promotion the DPC may weigh the penalty in judging minimum suitability, but not treat it as an automatic bar (paras 30, 38-39).

NyayVidhan's view · Practice note

Why It Matters

For departments, the answer moves a minor penalty from the eligibility stage to the suitability stage: an officer cannot be left out of the zone of consideration for censure or one increment withheld without cumulative effect, but the DPC may weigh it in judging minimum merit (paras 38-39). The State's own circular of 22 October 2024 says censure will not deny promotion, but it covers censure only and does not reopen DPCs already held (para 21). A bar can still come from the statutory rules themselves (para 30), as in the Madras High Court case where censure barred promotion under the Tamil Nadu service statute. The writ matter now goes back to the roster Bench (para 41).

Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.

Precedents Relied Upon

  1. Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan & Ors. 1967 SCC OnLine SC 16
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 19-20, 23

    Executive instructions may fill gaps where the statutory rules are silent but cannot amend or supersede them; applied to hold that a circular cannot create a promotion bar the Rules do not contain (paras 19-20, 23).

  2. Guman Singh v. State of Rajasthan & Ors. (1971) 2 SCC 452
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 20

    Instructions may guide a selection committee, but a circular, or any part of it, contrary to the statutory rules is invalid to that extent (para 20).

  3. Sarva U.P. Gramin Bank v. Manoj Kumar Chak (2013) 6 SCC 287
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 23, 35, 37

    The DPC may take misconduct and penalties into account in assessing suitability, but a circular cannot introduce a threshold disqualification absent from the service rules; debarring a censured employee would add the penalty of withholding promotion (paras 23, 35, 37).

View all precedents (12)
  1. State of Rajasthan v. Dr. Ashok Singhvi (2013) 4 WLN 251 (Rajasthan High Court, Division Bench)
    Followed Discussed at ¶ 24, 34-35

    The circular of 26.07.2006 cannot automatically bar consideration for promotion on seniority-cum-merit, while the DPC may still find the employee unsuitable if the penalty affects minimum merit (paras 24, 34-35).

  2. State of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Manoj Kumar Machra D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 662/2022, decided on 20.07.2022 (Rajasthan High Court)
    Followed Discussed at ¶ 25, 36

    Following Ashok Singhvi, rejected the State's plea that a censured employee was not entitled to be considered for promotion (paras 25, 36).

  3. State of Rajasthan v. Ucchab Lal Chhanwal (2014) 1 SCC 144
    Referred To Discussed at ¶ 27

    The later circular of 26.07.2006 could not be relied on to deny a censured officer promotion against 1996-97 vacancies under the Rules of 1954 (para 27).

  4. Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman (1991) 4 SCC 109
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 28, 32, 37

    An employee has no right to promotion but a right to be considered; the whole record, including penalties, may be taken into account, and denial of promotion on that basis is not illegal (paras 28, 32, 37).

  5. Union of India v. A.N. Mohanan (2007) 5 SCC 425
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 28, 37

    On sealed cover recommendations and retrospective promotion after a penalty; censure is a blameworthy factor but does not disqualify an employee from future consideration (paras 28, 37).

  6. State of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Shankar Lal Parmar (2011) 14 SCC 235
    Explained Discussed at ¶ 29, 33, 37

    Upheld a one-year deferral of selection grade for employees with censure; the Court explained that selection grade is a financial progression scheme, not regular promotion, while accepting that censure may form part of the record (paras 29, 33, 37).

  7. B.V. Sivaiah & Ors. v. K. Addanki Babu & Ors. (1998) 6 SCC 720
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 31

    Explains seniority-cum-merit: seniority has priority once a candidate meets the prescribed minimum merit and suitability, and seniority alone confers no right to promotion (para 31).

  8. Pradeep Singh Charan v. State of Rajasthan S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 7761/2022, decided on 04.09.2023 (Rajasthan High Court)
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 5, 26

    Followed by the Single Judge in the order under appeal; held that the circular of 04.06.2008 cannot deprive a government servant of consideration on seniority-cum-merit for censure or withholding of increments (paras 5, 26).

  9. Raghuveer Singh v. State of Rajasthan S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 20358/2018, decided on 07.05.2024 (Rajasthan High Court)
    Relied Upon Discussed at ¶ 5-6, 26

    The circular of 04.06.2008 cannot deprive a government servant of consideration on seniority-cum-merit for censure or withholding of increment, and a circular cannot attach the consequence of one penalty to another (paras 5-6, 26).

Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt