Friday, 20 November 2026

Subrata Bhattacharya v. Securities and Exchange Board of India & Ors.

2026 INSC 1247 · Supreme Court of India · 19 November 2026

Civil Appeal No. 13301 of 2015 with Civil Appeal No. 13394 of 2015 (interlocutory applications of PACL plot holders/allottees at Sectors 100 and 104, Mohali and at Bhatinda)

Source Court's copy

The text below is reproduced from the judgment for reference. The article summarises the Court's decision; refer to the original judgment for the authoritative text.

2026 INSC 1247
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 13301 OF 2015

SUBRATA BHATTACHARYA ...APPELLANT
VERSUS
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA & ORS. …RESPONDENTS

WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 13394 OF 2015

[NyayVidhan note: this is the Court's signed order of 19.11.2026 (2026 INSC 1247 printed on it) disposing of interlocutory applications by plot holders/allottees of PACL at Sectors 100 and 104, Mohali and at Bhatinda. The Court's paragraph numbers 1-36 are kept, with sub-paragraphs 29.1-29.3 as printed; section headings A-F are shown as their own lines. The three tables (para 10, para 11 and para 35) are transcribed from the printed pages as text, with cells separated by '|'; in the para 35 table the Advocate-on-Record column is left out. Footnote markers are shown as [1]-[5] and the footnotes are given at the end. Annexures A-1 to A-9 (pages 24-40, plot-number lists) are not reproduced; their headings and totals are summarised at the end. Page numbers and the digital-signature block are left out. The order's wording is kept as printed, including 'I.A No. 150831 of 2023' considered by the order dated 04.03.2020 (para 8) and 'IA No. 5/2026' allowed by the order dated 02.05.2016 (para 27).]

[Source: Supreme Court of India, www.sci.gov.in — order dated 19 November 2026.]

O R D E R

1. This order disposes of Interlocutory Applications regarding claims filed by plot holders/allottees of PACL at Sector 100 and 104 of Mohali, and at Bhatinda.

2. The present dispute arises from the regulatory action taken by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) against PACL on the ground that its business model, under which it collected money from public/investors under various investment schemes, constituted an unregistered Collective Investment Scheme (“CIS”).

3. In 1999, SEBI issued notices directing PACL to either obtain registration under the SEBI (CIS) Regulations, 1999, or to wind up its operations. Asserting that its activities were confined to real estate dealings and did not constitute CIS activity, PACL initiated writ proceedings before the High Court of Rajasthan. By its judgment dated 28.11.2003, the High Court allowed the said writ petition, holding that PACL’s activities did not satisfy the statutory requirements of a CIS, and consequently quashed the notices issued by SEBI. In the appeal filed by SEBI, by its order dated 26.02.2013, this Court disposed of the appeal by setting aside the judgment of the High Court and remanded the matter to SEBI, directing that the original 1999 notices be treated as show-cause notices and that SEBI should conduct a de novo adjudication to determine whether its business activities fell within the ambit of a CIS.

4. Pursuant to the said remand, SEBI passed final orders concluding that PACL was, indeed, running an unregistered CIS and directed its promoters and directors to refund the monies collected from investors and to wind up all existing schemes. This order was upheld by the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT). It is in this context that the present Civil Appeals against this judgment and order of SAT are ongoing.

5. By an order dated 02.02.2016, this Court constituted the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee (“the Committee”), which was entrusted with the dual mandate of liquidating the Company’s land assets and ensuring the equitable refund of investor funds. In furtherance of these duties, the Committee retrieved and scrutinized title deeds from the CBI, engaged necessary experts for valuation and auditing, and also formulated and executed modalities for the sale of immovable properties and then verified and disbursed investors’ claims.

6. The Committee’s proposal for appointment of Shri R. S. Virk, District Judge (Retd.), to examine a large number of applications, objections, grievances, and representations related to Committee’s proceedings was accepted by this Court’s order dated 15.11.2017. Subsequently, many such applications were heard and disposed by Shri R.S. Virk following due procedure. In the course of these proceedings, a large number of Interlocutory Applications (IAs) were filed by various parties before us.

7. For the purpose of disposal of the present IAs it may be stated that the Committee examined the records relating to the residential projects that PACL had at Sectors 100 and 104, Mohali, and at Bhatinda. The Committee found that Sectors 100 and 104 at Mohali, together, had 2032 units and Bhatinda had 1078 units, and that many were allotted or sold before 02.02.2016.

8. By order dated 04.03.2020, this Court, while considering I.A No. 150831 of 2023 (filed by State of Punjab) and I.A No. 105681 of 2019 (filed by Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association), directed disclosure of the names of the allottees of plots in Sectors 100 and 104 in Mohali, the dates on which the respective agreements were entered into, the mode and dates of payment, and whether the original allottees remain members of the Association or have transferred their rights. Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association filed an affidavit dated 04.10.2024, supplying the necessary details regarding allottees of Sector 100 and 104, Mohali. By order dated 17.10.2024, this Court asked the Committee to verify the claims with the assistance of an auditor.

9. Thereafter, the Committee, after duly considering the claims with the assistance of chartered accountants, filed a Final Report on 28.02.2025. After having considered the matter, this Court, by its Order dated 02.04.2025, requested the Committee to suggest a further course of action.

10. Accordingly, the Committee, in its report dated 19.04.2025 (“the Report”), analysed all the claims, categorised them into five categories and made recommendations in respect of each category. The learned Amicus Curiae, Mr. Ranjit Kumar and Mr. Shadan Farasat, learned senior counsel, assisted by Ms. Nupur Kumar, learned counsel, have collated a Note dated 08.10.2026 (“Amici Note”), which sets out the categories, further course of action and the number of allottees in each category, in the following manner –

[Table, as printed:] Categories — Category | Basis | Recommendation
I | (i) Full payment through banking channels (eg. RTGS or cheque) and possession certificate issued; (ii) full payment through banking channels (eg. RTGS or cheque payment) but neither possession certificate issued nor sale deed executed. | Should be treated as sold; sale certificate/NOC to be issued to them.
II | Part payment of more than 50% through banking channels (eg. RTGS/Cheque Payment) before or after 02.02.2016 | Treated as sold; balance under the agreement and contribution to internal development works to be deposited with the Committee within 30 days; then sale certificate or NOC may be issued to said unit owners.
III | Part payment of less than 50% through banking channels | Treated as unsold; the amount on record, as certified by the auditors, to be refunded within three months of a successful auction sale.
IV | (i) Full payment in cash; (ii) part payment in cash; (iii) transfers after 02.02.2016 through banking channels. | To be treated as unsold and sold by auction; no amount allegedly paid in cash will be refunded.
V | Allottees who sold their allotment during the pendency of these matters and who fall in one of Categories I to IV. | Dealt with in the same manner as Categories I to IV.

11. The Committee also recommended that allottees be offered the option to surrender their plots and take a refund, payable within three months of completion of the auction. The total number of allottees in each category at the various projects is as follows -

[Table, as printed:] Mohali, Sector 100 and 104 — Sr. No | Particulars | Categorization of Allottees | No. of Allottees/residents | Remarks
Sr. No 1 | Sector 100, Mohali | Category I | 92 | Full payment made through banking channels. Sale Deeds executed before 02.02.2016 (Annexure A-1 pg. 24)
— | — | Category II | 227 | More than 50% payment made through banking channels (Annexure A-2 pg. 25 to 27)
— | — | Category III | 117 | Less than 50% payment made through banking channels (Annexure A-3 pg. 28-29)
Sr. No 2 | Sector 104, Mohali | Category I | 241 | Full payment made through banking channels. Sale Deeds executed before 02.02.2016 (Annexure A-4 pg. 30-32)
— | — | Category II | 138 | More than 50% payment made through banking channels (Annexure A-5 pg. 33 to 34)
— | — | Category III | 66 | Less than 50% payment made through banking channels (Annexure A-6 pg. 35)
[Table, as printed:] Bhatinda — Sr. No | Particulars | Categorization of Allottees | No. of Allottees/residents | Remarks
Sr. No 1 | Bhatinda | Category I | 203 | Full payment made through banking channels. Sale Deeds executed before 02.02.2016 (Annexure A-7 pg. 36 to 37)
— | — | Category II | 126 | More than 50% payment made through banking channels (Annexure A-8 pg. 38 to 39)
— | — | Category III | 16 | Less than 50% payment made through banking channels (Annexure A-9 pg. 40)

12. This categorization is based on bank records examined by chartered accountants whom the Committee engaged under the order of 17.10.2024, after the State of Punjab and the Associations had accepted that exercise. Having considered the matter in detail, we are of the opinion that the categorization adopted by the Committee is appropriate and the same is accepted.

13. We will now proceed to consider the recommendations of the Committee in respect of the allottees in Categories I to V in Sectors 100 and 104, Mohali and Bhatinda.

A. Categories I – Full Payment through banking channels

14. Category I members are those who have either (i) made full payment through bank channels and have possession certificate issued, or, (ii) made full payment through banking channels but have not received a possession certificate nor was the sale deed executed. Of this category, the 92 allottees in Sector 100, Mohali are mentioned at Annexure 1, 241 allottees in Sector 104, Mohali mentioned at Annexure 4 and 203 allottees in Bhatinda mentioned at Annexure 7. The Report dated 19.04.2025 recommended that plots/allotments to allottees in Category I be treated as sold and that the necessary sale certificate/NOC be issued to them.

15. Accepting the recommendation, we issue the following directions –
i. We hereby direct that sale certificates/no objection certificates be issued by the Recovery Officer under Section 28A of the SEBI Act to each of these allottees as mentioned in Annexures 1, 4, and 7 within 8 weeks from today.
ii. We also direct the Recovery Officer to give the necessary possession certificate to those in limb (ii) of the Category I within the same time period.

B. Category II – Part-payment of more than 50% through banking channels either before or after 02.02.2016

16. Category II members are those who have made a payment of more than 50% through banking channels either before or after 02.02.2016. Of this category, the 227 allottees in Sector 100, Mohali are mentioned at Annexure 2, 138 allottees in Sector 104, Mohali mentioned at Annexure 5 and 126 allottees in Bhatinda mentioned at Annexure 8.

17. The Report dated 19.04.2025 recommended that plots/allotments to allottees in Category II be treated as sold and the outstanding amount payable under their respective agreements, together with the contribution towards Internal Development Work, shall be deposited with the Committee within 30 days and thereafter sale certificates/NOC be issued to the said unit owners.

18. Accepting the recommendation, we issue the following directions -
i. We hereby direct the Committee to give each allottee at Annexures 2, 5 and 8, except those who have made any of the payments after 02.02.2016, a statement of balance payable under the agreement and of contribution towards internal development works within eight weeks.
ii. We call upon the allottees to pay both within a period of 30 days from receipt of such statement, through banking channels, into the account that the Committee designates.
iii. Upon receipt of such outstanding balance, we direct the Recovery Officer under Section 28A of the SEBI Act to issue the sale certificates/no objection certificates to each of these allottees within 8 weeks.
iv. An allottee who does not pay in time may apply once to the Committee for a further period of up to 30 days, showing reasons. If the amounts are still not paid, the plot shall be treated as unsold, and the amounts received from the allottees, as audited by the Report, shall be refunded in the same manner as provided for Category III.

C. Category III – Part-payment of less than 50% through banking channels

19. Category III members are those who have made a payment of less than 50% through banking channels. Of this category, the 117 allottees of Sector 100, Mohali are mentioned in Annexure 3, 66 allottees of Sector 104, Mohali are mentioned in Annexure 6 and 16 allottees of Bhatinda are mentioned in Annexure 9.

20. The Committee recommended that all the units in Category III, i.e., where part payment of less than 50% was received through banking channels, be treated as unsold and that the audited amounts be refunded within 3 months after a successful auction. However, the learned Amici, in paragraph 9 of their Note, have made the following additional suggestions –
i. Affirm the view of the Report dated 19.04.2025 and treat the plots as unsold and refund the sums within 3 months of successful auction sale; or,
ii. Provide one more opportunity to interested allottees, whose claims stand audited by the Committee, to pay the remaining amounts, as per current market rate, through banking channels within a stipulated period; or,
iii. Refund amounts paid by allottees/plot holders of such properties within a stipulated period, with nominal interest from the date of payment till the date of refund.

21. The submissions of the various counsel appearing for Category III allottees can be summarized as follows -
(I) Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association (Sector 100& 104)[1] – There are 93 allottees who have paid Rs. 15.87 crore and a balance of Rs. 45.63 Crore is outstanding. In Sector 104, there are 65 allottees who have paid Rs. 9.28 crore and a balance of Rs. 30.42 crore is outstanding. These Applicants seek to abide by suggestion (ii) of the Amici Note and are amenable to the remaining balance being determined on the basis of circle rate/market rate and are willing to pay the re-determined outstanding balance.
(II) Pearl’s Township Plot Holders’ Welfare Association, Bathinda[2] - There are 16 allottees who have paid approximately Rs. 1.19 crores, with the balance being approximately Rs. 1.77 crores. These Applicants also seek the option of complying with suggestion (ii) of the Amici Note.
(III) Pinnacle Self Supporting Co-Operative Welfare House Building Society[3] – The Applicant is a society which holds 5 acres of land at Group Housing No. 3, Sector 104, Mohali, and was allotted each acre at the price of Rs. 7.5 crore with the total consideration being Rs. 37.50 crore. They submit that they paid approximately Rs. 15.10 crore with the balance being approximately Rs. 22.40 crore. They request that since Rs. 15.10 crore has already been paid, which amounts to full consideration for 2 acres, the said 2 acres be transferred at par with allottees in Category I. In addition, they seek permission to avail suggestion (ii) of the Amici Note and pay the remaining balance determined at market rate for the remaining 3 acres.
(IV) Devinder Pal Singh, Rupinder Kaur, Paramjeet Singh and Jiwan Kumar Bansal[4] - These applicants are members of Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association (Sector 100 & 104). These 4 applicants hold 8 plots and have paid Rs. 1.54 crores, with the balance being approximately Rs. 2.92 crores; they also wish to avail suggestion (ii) of the Amici Note.
(V) M/s KLV Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd.[5] - This applicant is also a member of Pearl City Mohali Residents Welfare Association (Sector 100 & 104). They submit that they were responsible for the construction of villas on 31 vacant plots. They invested Rs. 6.57 crores to construct 31 (3-storey) villas, out of which 6 were sold and 25 remained unsold. They now wish to pay the remaining balance of Rs. 12.78 crore and are willing to pay it together with reasonable interest calculated from the freezing date of 02.02.2016. Without prejudice to this submission, if the merits of the application are not considered, they also submit that they are willing to pay the circle rate for the remaining 25 plots.

22. We have duly considered the submissions made on behalf of the Category III allottees as well as the alternatives suggested by the learned Amici. The Supreme Court is exercising extraordinary jurisdiction that it has assumed in 2016. More than a decade has passed since then, and yet, this Court has been struggling to resolve this issue. Committees have been constituted, and various reports have been submitted and considered sporadically, within the limited time this Court has. These proceedings are not in the context of regular original or appellate jurisdiction that this Court exercises. It is necessary for this Court to conclude these proceedings at the earliest and at the same time, ensure that the investors are restituted in a reasonable manner. We cannot afford to convert these proceedings into suits for specific performance or public law proceedings for restitution and rehabilitation. Taking a practical and pragmatic view, it is necessary to take difficult decisions to ensure that the monies paid are returned with reasonable interest. The primary obligation in the present proceedings is to secure, to the extent possible, the return of monies to persons whose claims have been duly examined and verified by the Committee.

23. Further, this Court cannot afford to complicate the process of securing at least the repayment of the monies invested by the applicants, together with reasonable interest, by attempting to devise mechanisms for the fulfilment of their original commercial transactions. Such an exercise may, in fact, leave the respondents without even recovering the monies they paid. Having regard to the considerable passage of time, this Court cannot hazard a probable relief where plans and directions to make balance payments, resolution of existing claims and disputes over title, transfer of unencumbered property, and creation of fresh title, will all happen with certainty. The best this Court can do now is conclude the proceedings and ensure that the applicants are repaid the monies they invested, with reasonable interest.

24. In view of the above, we accept and adopt the suggestion (iii) of the Amici Note and issue the following directions -
i. The Committee is directed to refund to each allottee under this Category, as mentioned in Annexure 3, 6 and 9, the amount paid by them, as certified by the auditors and recorded in the Report, with interest at the rate of 8%.
ii. The refund, together with the interest payable, shall be made within three months from the date of successful auction of the concerned plot.
iii. Upon payment of the aforesaid amount, the claim of the concerned allottee in respect of the plot shall stand fully satisfied, and no further claim in relation to such allotment shall survive.

D. Category IV – Full or Part-payment Made in Cash (Unverified) or Payments Made Through Banking Channels after 02.02.2016

25. The Committee in its Report dated 19.04.2025 recommended that plots and allotments in Category IV, i.e., those where either full or part-payment was made through cash, and those where payments were made after 02.02.2016 through banking channels, be treated as unsold inventory and sold through public auction, with no refund being made to the applicants. The Amici Note, at para 12, supports this recommendation.

26. If the alleged payments made in cash by members of this Category are verifiable, then there is no justification whatsoever to bar them from adopting such legal remedies as may be available to them in law. This Court will certainly not prevent such allottees from exercising such remedies. With this concern, even though the Committee has suggested that no refund is to be made to the Category IV applications, we enquired of the Amici if they can file civil suits for recovery.

27. In compliance, the learned Amici have submitted a short note. It is suggested that a suit by an allottee is not necessarily barred. However, they pointed us towards Order dated 02.05.2016 wherein this Court allowed a prayer in IA No. 5/2026 filed by SEBI in the present Civil Appeal (13301/2015) in which they sought the following – “a) pass an order directing that no Civil Court or other Authority or Forum shall entertain any suit or other proceeding in respect of any claim or related matter(s) pertaining to PACL Ltd. and/or its Directors/ Promoters/ group Companies/ entities/ individuals etc., arraying therein as parties/ Defendants/ Respondents the Justice (Retd). R.M Lodha Committee (in the matter of PACL Ltd.), and/or its Chairman and/or its Members and/or the Securities and Exchange Board of India and further no injunction shall be granted by any Court or other Authority or Forum in respect of any action taken or to be taken by the Justice (Retd.) R.M Lodha Committee (in the matter of PACL Ltd.) and/or its Chairman and/or its Members and/or the Securities and Exchange Board of India, with respect to claims and/ or matter(s) relating to investments/ deposits etc. in/ with PACL Ltd. or its Directors/ Promoters/ Group Companies/ Entities/ Individuals etc;”

28. Therefore, they suggest that there is no embargo to maintain suits against PACL Ltd, and that the embargo is only against impleading designated statutory and monitoring entities such as Justice (Retd.) R. M. Lodha Committee, the Chairman of the Committee, the individual members of the Committee, and SEBI from being arrayed.

29. We have also considered the detailed submissions by the learned counsels appearing for Category IV allottees. They can be summarised as –
29.1 The Committee’s Report dated 19.04.2025 arbitrarily classifies purchasers based on the mode and timing of payment, without considering settled possession, genuineness of cash payments, or the actual circumstances of individual transactions. They seek physical verification of plots and supporting documents.
29.2 Transactions which have been acknowledged by PACL, accompanied by delivery of possession, cannot be reopened merely because sale deeds were not executed. Their claims involve disputed questions of fact, possession and title, which require adjudication by a competent forum rather than a paper-based verification exercise.
29.3 They propose that their claims be determined by a Retired Judge or Recovery Officer under Section 28A of the SEBI Act, following notice, hearing, physical survey and examination of evidence, with a reasoned order. Alternatively, they seek liberty to approach the competent Civil Court at Mohali for declaration and specific performance, notwithstanding the existing orders dated 02.02.2016 and 25.07.2016.

30. Having considered the matter in detail, we reject the IAs filed by Category IV allottees, who paid in cash, seeking allotment or refund. However, we are of the opinion that they will be entitled to approach the appropriate Civil Court by filing suits for recovery/declaration. To provide clarity and certainty on which contesting defendants to implead, the matter may be posted for hearing the learned Amici and SEBI, and for clarification of para 13 of the order dt. 02.02.2016.

31. In respect of Category IV applicants who made payments through banking channels, but after the freezing date of 02.02.2016, the Amici have suggested that the same view taken for Category III applicants be applied. We accept this recommendation and issue the following directions -
i. The Committee is directed to refund to each allottee the amount paid by such allottee towards the concerned plot, as certified by the auditors and recorded in the Report, with interest at the rate of 8%,
ii. The refund, together with the interest payable, shall be made within three months from the date of successful auction of the concerned plot.
iii. Upon payment of the aforesaid amount, the claim of the concerned allottee in respect of the plot shall stand fully satisfied, and no further claim in relation to such allotment shall survive.

32. The directions in paragraph 31 above shall also apply to those individuals in Annexures 2, 5 and 8 who have made payments through banking channels after 02.02.2016.

E. Category V Applicants

33. The Amici Note recommends that the allottees/plot holders in Category V, i.e., those who sold their allotment during the pendency of the present matter and fall in any of the aforesaid four categories, be dealt with in the same manner as the allottees/plot holders falling in Categories I to IV.

34. Having considered the matter, we direct that the claims of the Category V applicants shall be dealt with in accordance with the category to which the concerned allottee/plot holder would have belonged but for the sale of the allotment during the pendency of the present proceedings. The Committee shall accordingly extend to such applicants the benefit of the directions applicable to the corresponding category.

F. Other Interlocutory Applications

35. Beyond the five categories discussed, there are also applications filed by certain allottees who allege that they need to be included in Category I. The details of the IAs are as follows -

[Table, as printed; the AOR Name (Advocate-on-Record) column is left out by NyayVidhan:] Sr. No | I. A. No. | Directions Sought | Applicant Details
Sr. No 1 | a. 302374 of 2025; b. 302375 of 2025; c. 302376 of 2025 | Application for Intervention; Application for Directions; Application for exemption from filing OT | Mr. Navdeep Kumar
Sr. No 2 | 331974 of 2025 | Application for Intervention | Dr. Surinder Kumar Bansal

36. We direct the Committee to verify the aforementioned applications filed by allottees who claim to be in Category I and pass appropriate orders subject to approval/objection by SEBI, if any.

…J.
[PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA]

…J.
[ATUL S. CHANDURKAR]

NEW DELHI;
NOVEMBER 19, 2026.

Annexures (summary by NyayVidhan)
[Annexures A-1 to A-9 (pages 24-40 of the PDF) list, by serial number, the plot numbers of the allottees in each category. They are not reproduced here; see the PDF. Their printed headings and totals are: Annexure A-1 (Annexure-100-C1), Sector 100: Category-1: Total Allottees: 92; Annexure A-2 (Annexure-100-C2), Sector 100: Category-2: Total Allottees: 228; Annexure A-3 (Annexure-100-C3), Sector 100: Category-3: Total Allottees: 117; Annexure A-4 (Annexure-104-C1), Sector 104: Category-1: Total Allottees: 241; Annexure A-5 (Annexure-104-C2), Sector 104: Category-2: Total Allottees: 138; Annexure A-6 (Annexure-104-C3), Sector 104: Category-3: Total Allottees: 66; Annexure A-7 (Annexure-3A), Pearl’s Township Bathinda Category-1: Total Allottees: 203; Annexure A-8 (Annexure-3B), Pearl’s Township Bathinda Category-2: Total Allottees: 126; Annexure A-9 (Annexure-3C), Pearl’s Township Bathinda Category-3: Total Allottees: 16. Annexure A-2 prints "Total Allottees: 228" and lists 228 serial numbers, while paras 11 and 16 give 227 for Category II of Sector 100.]

Footnotes
[1] IA No. 105681 of 2019, IA No. 83060 of 2024 and IA No. 268105 of 2026.
[2] IA No. 24482 of 2018 and IA No. 149875 of 2024.
[3] IA No. 80721 of 2025 and IA No. 111521 of 2025.
[4] IA No. 113578 of 2025.
[5] IA No. 114869 of 2025.
Join our WhatsApp Group
✕

Try: POCSO, IBC, Electoral Bond, Article 370, NDPS Act, Bail Conditions, SC Contempt