Judgment Intelligence
Disposed Of- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of Decision
- 30 November 1995
- Bench
- Justices K. Ramaswamy and S.B. Majmudar
- Relevant Acts & Sections
- Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 — Sections 20, 50; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 — Section 482; Constitution of India — Article 226
Appeal disposed of. The Sessions Judge was not justified in discharging the respondent, but as more than ten years had passed and the contraband was not of a considerable magnitude, the case was not sent back for trial; that is not to be a precedent (paras 13-15).
Source Supreme Court of India, Supreme Court Reports (scr.sci.gov.in) — judgment dated 30 November 1995
Key holdings
- Section 50 is mandatory, and the searching officer must state in evidence that he told the accused of his right (para 2).
- Whether Section 50 was complied with is a question of fact to be proved at the trial (para 3).
- Discharging the accused for non-compliance with Section 50 after the charge-sheet was not justified (para 13).
- At the charge-sheet stage the court does not weigh the effect of non-compliance with mandatory provisions (para 11).
- The power to quash an FIR or charge-sheet is exceptional and to be used sparingly (paras 10-11).
Case explainer by NyayVidhan: an account of this judgment and the law it laid down, not the court's text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.
Brief Facts
Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)
- Could the Sessions Judge discharge the accused before trial because Section 50 had not been complied with?
- When may the High Court use its inherent power, or Article 226, to quash an FIR or a charge-sheet?
- Should the case be sent back for trial more than ten years later?
Submissions
For the appellant. The State appealed by special leave against the discharge, which the High Court had confirmed in revision. The order records that counsel on both sides were heard but does not set out their submissions (para 1).
For the respondents. The first respondent had been discharged by the Sessions Judge on the ground that Section 50 had not been complied with, and the High Court had upheld that order (paras 1-2); the order does not record the arguments made for them.
Court's Findings
Section 50 compliance is for the trial
Section 50 is mandatory: the officer must tell the person to be searched of his right to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate and must say so in evidence, failing which the court presumes he was not told (para 2). But whether that right was given, and whether the officer breached the requirement, is a question of fact to be proved at the trial (para 3). Following Pooran Mal, the Court said relevancy is the test of admissibility and that an illegality in investigation does not make the evidence inadmissible; its weight depends on the facts of each case (paras 3-4, 6). At the charge-sheet stage it cannot be said that there is no evidence, and the prosecution must have its chance at the trial to prove a lawful search, so the discharge was not justified (para 13).
The inherent power to quash
The power is exceptional and to be used sparingly; the guidelines in Bhajan Lal are only illustrative (paras 10-11). Once the charge-sheet is laid, the court does not weigh the pros and cons of the prosecution case or the effect of non-compliance with mandatory provisions; that is done after the trial. It only sees, prima facie, whether cognizance can be taken (para 11). Where Section 482 is available, the High Court should be loath to use Article 226, and greater care is needed in economic offences (para 12).
No remand after ten years
As more than ten years had passed and the contraband seized was not of a considerable magnitude, the case was not sent back for trial; that was not to be used as a precedent (para 14).
Legal Principle
NyayVidhan's view · Practice note
Why It Matters
Pirthi Chand is cited for two points: whether the person searched was told of his right under Section 50 is a question of fact for the trial, so it is no ground for discharge once a charge-sheet is filed (paras 3, 13); and the High Court’s power to quash a charge-sheet is exceptional (paras 10-12). Its wider observations that evidence from an illegal search stays admissible (paras 4, 13) must be read with State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh (1999), where a Constitution Bench held those broad observations, on evidence from a search in breach of Section 50, not in tune with the correct exposition of the law and did not follow them.
Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.
Precedents Relied Upon
- State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh [1994] 3 SCC 299
Relied on for the rule that Section 50 is mandatory and that the officer must tell the person to be searched of his right to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate; also for the need to consider prejudice and the weight of the evidence where the provisions are not complied with (paras 2, 7).
- Saiyad Mohd. Saiyaad Umar Saiyad & Ors. v. The State of Gujarat JT [1995] 3 SC 489
Three-Judge Bench decision relied on for the duty to inform under Section 50, the officer’s duty to say so in evidence and the presumption that arises if he does not (para 2).
- Pooran Mal v. Director of Inspection [1974] 1 SCC 345
Constitution Bench decision relied on for the view that relevancy is the test of admissibility and that evidence obtained in an illegal search and seizure is not shut out for that reason (para 3).
View all precedents (13)
- Radha Krishan v. State of U.P. AIR (1963) SC 822
Cited for the view that evidence obtained by an illegal search and seizure is not to be rejected but must be examined carefully (para 5).
- State of Maharashtra v. Natwarlal AIR (1980) SC 593
Cited for the view that an illegal search does not affect the validity of the seizure, the further investigation or the trial that followed (para 5).
- Shyam Lal v. State of M.P. AIR (1972) SC 886
Cited for the view that a search and seizure in contravention of Section 165 does not affect the later steps in the investigation (para 5).
- State of Kerala v. Alasserry Mohd. AIR 1978 SC 933
Cited for the view that a Food Inspector’s failure to comply strictly with the statutory provisions did not vitiate the trial and conviction (para 5).
- Sunder Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh AIR (1956) SC 411
Cited for the view that a search without respectable inhabitants of the locality is not invalid and that the irregularity affects only the weight of the evidence (para 7).
- State of Maharashtra v. P.K. Pathak AIR (1980) SC 1224
Cited for the view that the absence of an independent witness to the search does not affect the trial and conviction under the Customs Act (para 7).
- Matajog Dubey v. H.C. Bahri AIR (1956) SC 44
Cited for the view that non-compliance with the salutary provisions may affect the weight of the search evidence unless the prosecution explains it (para 7).
- Rakesh Kumar @ Sachdeva @ Deva v. State Delhi Administration [1994] Supp. 3 SCC 729
Cited for the view that non-examination of the investigating officer and the failure to join independent witnesses are not fatal, and that a conviction may rest on the evidence of police officers (para 8).
- State of Haryana & Ors. v. Bhajan Lal & Ors. [1992] Supp. 1 SCC 335
Relied on for the broad tests for quashing, described as only illustrative, and for the rule that the power is to be used sparingly and only in exceptional cases (para 10).
- Mrs. Rupan Deol Bajaj & Anr. v. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill & Anr. JT (1995) 7 SC 299
Cited for the view that where the complaint or charge-sheet discloses a prima facie case the court does not weigh the evidence at that stage (para 10).

