Judgment Intelligence
Appeal Partly Allowed- Court
- Rajasthan High Court
- Date of Decision
- 17 November 2026
- Bench
- Justice Arun Monga and Justice Ashutosh Kumar
- Relevant Acts & Sections
- Constitution of India — Article 226; Certified Standing Orders — Clause 20(2)
Appeal partly allowed. The enquiry, removal and Labour Court orders stay set aside, but not the direction for reinstatement with full back wages. The Labour Court must inquire into gainful employment till superannuation; if favourable, the management decides back wages from 27 February 2009, adjusting Rs 1,56,821.20 paid (paras 49-51).
Source Rajasthan High Court, hcraj.nic.in — judgment pronounced on 17 November 2026, uploaded 18 November 2026
Key holdings
- Engaging the employer's advocate as Enquiry Officer does not by itself show bias (para 30).
- An Enquiry Officer who later defends his own report and the punishment as the employer's counsel creates a real likelihood of bias, vitiating the enquiry (paras 31-33).
- Waiver needs knowledge of the facts constituting bias, and an employee's abstention cannot cure a biased forum (paras 37, 39).
- An enquiry falling for bias leaves the charges untested, so no final finding of victimisation can follow (paras 42-43).
- Full back wages do not follow automatically; gainful employment must be examined on evidence (paras 47-48).
Judgment digest by NyayVidhan: a summary of the court's judgment, not its text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.
Brief Facts
Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)
- Was the domestic enquiry vitiated by a real likelihood of bias? (Question (a), framed by the Court)
- Did the employee's abstention, or her failure to object earlier, save the enquiry? (Question (b))
- Could the Single Judge validly record a final finding of victimisation on the merits of the charges? (Question (c))
Submissions
For the management. The employee walked out of the enquiry despite repeated opportunities and never objected to the Enquiry Officer, and a lawyer as Enquiry Officer does not by itself show bias (Saran Motors, Dalmia Dadri Cement). The Single Judge dealt with only one of eight charges; if the enquiry was defective, the management should have been allowed to prove the charges; and she never pleaded that she was unemployed (para 21).
For the employee. The Enquiry Officer was the management's regular lawyer and later defended his own report. She was denied a Defence Assistant of her choice and documents, the charges were at most minor misconduct, and the management had not shown she was gainfully employed (para 22).
Court's Findings
Question (a): the adjudicator turned advocate
Bias needs a real likelihood, judged by a reasonable person aware of the facts (V.K. Khanna, K.D. Bali, Ranjit Thakur), and merely engaging an advocate as Enquiry Officer does not show it (paras 28-30). But after his report this Enquiry Officer appeared for the management and defended his own findings, and the removal, before the Labour Court and the writ court (para 31). The fairness of his enquiry was the very question before the Labour Court, and "An adjudicator cannot later become the advocate of his own verdict" (para 32). Saran Motors and Dalmia Dadri Cement did not deal with such later conduct, and the Labour Court's failure to examine it was an error apparent on the face of the record (paras 34, 36).
Question (b): no waiver, and abstention cannot cure bias
Waiver presupposes knowledge, and his appearance for the management came only after the enquiry; she had also alleged bias in her reply to the show-cause notice (paras 37-38). Her abstention was not commendable, but bias concerns the neutrality of the forum, which her participation would not have cured; it may matter for back wages (para 39). Her other grievances were left open (para 40).
Question (c): no final finding of victimisation
Several charges did not depend on whether reviewing editions was an Artist's work, yet the Single Judge examined essentially one (paras 41-42). When an enquiry falls for bias its findings go, but the charges are not disproved and the employee is not exonerated (para 43). With her now about 60, reinstatement is no longer practical, and back wages are not automatic: gainful employment must be decided on evidence (paras 46-48).
Legal Principle
NyayVidhan's view · Practice note
Why It Matters
For employers, engaging an advocate as Enquiry Officer stays safe only while he remains neutral: briefing the same advocate later to defend his own report and the punishment invites a finding of bias (paras 30-33). For employees, the ruling is not an exoneration, since the charges remain untested and back wages turn on evidence of gainful employment (paras 43, 47-48). The judgment does not cite them, but compare the Rajasthan High Court's dairy workman case, where back wages were limited to 50%, and its Alwar recruitment enquiry ruling on an officer judging his own cause.
Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.
Precedents Relied Upon
- U.D. Lama v. State of Sikkim (1997) 1 SCC 111
Relied on by the management for waiver of a bias objection; distinguished because waiver presupposes knowledge of the facts constituting bias, and the Enquiry Officer appeared as the management's counsel only after the enquiry (paras 21, 37).
- Saran Motors Pvt. Ltd. v. Vishwanath 1964 SCC OnLine SC 9
The mere engagement of the employer's lawyer as Enquiry Officer does not show bias; distinguished because it did not deal with an Enquiry Officer who later turned counsel to defend his own enquiry and the punishment (paras 21, 30, 34).
- Dalmia Dadri Cement Ltd. v. Murari Lal Bikaneria (1970) 3 SCC 259
An advocate occasionally engaged by the employer is not necessarily biased as Enquiry Officer; distinguished on the same ground as Saran Motors (paras 21, 30, 34).
View all precedents (14)
- Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India (1987) 4 SCC 611
The test of bias is whether a reasonable person aware of the relevant facts would think bias likely, and proceedings tainted by bias are vitiated; applied to the Enquiry Officer's dual role (paras 22, 29, 33).
- State of Punjab v. V.K. Khanna (2001) 2 SCC 330
Bias means a departure from even-handed justice, and a real likelihood of bias, not a mere apprehension, is required (paras 28, 33).
- International Airports Authority of India v. K.D. Bali (1988) 2 SCC 360
The apprehension of bias must be judged from the standpoint of a reasonable and honest person, not a whimsical one (para 28).
- Reserve Bank of India v. C.L. Toora (2004) 4 SCC 657
Cited for the employee on the disproportion of removal for minor misconduct; not discussed by the Court (para 22).
- Glaxo Laboratories (I) Ltd. v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Meerut (1984) 1 SCC 1
Cited for the employee and relied on by the Single Judge for the finding that reviewing editions was outside an Artist's duties; that victimisation finding was set aside (paras 22, 26, 41-43).
- Deepali Gundu Surwase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya (D.Ed.) (2013) 10 SCC 324
Full back wages is the normal rule when a termination is set aside, but the employee must at least assert that she was not gainfully employed, and other relevant factors may be considered (paras 22, 47).
- Hindustan Tin Works Pvt. Ltd. v. Employees of Hindustan Tin Works Pvt. Ltd. (1979) 2 SCC 80
Back wages may be moulded on the facts of each case (paras 22, 47).
- Shankar Chakravarti v. Britannia Biscuit Co. Ltd. (1979) 3 SCC 371
Where a domestic enquiry is defective, the employer may prove the misconduct before the Labour Court on fresh evidence if it asks for this at the proper stage (para 44).
- Shambhu Nath Goyal v. Bank of Baroda (1983) 4 SCC 491
On the stage at which the employer must seek leave to prove misconduct before the Labour Court (para 44).
- Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation v. Lakshmidevamma (2001) 5 SCC 433
On the employer's right to prove misconduct before the Labour Court when the enquiry is defective, if sought at the proper stage (para 44).
- Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar (1993) 4 SCC 727
Where a punishment is set aside for a defect in the enquiry, a fresh enquiry may be held from the stage at which the defect crept in, and back wages abide its result (para 45).
