Judgment Intelligence
Disposed Of- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of Decision
- 16 November 1992
- Bench
- Chief Justice M.H. Kania and Justices M.N. Venkatachaliah, S. Ratnavel Pandian, T.K. Thommen, A.M. Ahmadi, Kuldip Singh, P.B. Sawant, R.M. Sahai and B.P. Jeevan Reddy (Justices Thommen, Kuldip Singh and Sahai dissenting)
- Relevant Acts & Sections
- Constitution of India — Articles 14, 15(4), 16(1), 16(4), 46, 335 and 340
Writ petitions and transferred cases disposed of (para 124): the Office Memorandum of 13 August 1990 held valid subject to exclusion of the creamy layer; clause (i) of the Memorandum of 25 September 1991 valid as read down; clause (ii), the 10% reservation on economic criteria, invalid; directions issued (para 123).
Source Supreme Court of India, Supreme Court Reports (scr.sci.gov.in) — judgment dated 16 November 1992
Key holdings
- The 27% reservation of the 1990 Memorandum was upheld, subject to excluding the creamy layer (para 124).
- A caste can be, and quite often is, a social class (para 121).
- The creamy layer must be excluded from the Other Backward Classes (paras 86, 123).
- Reservations under Article 16(4) should not exceed 50%, save in extraordinary situations (para 94A).
- Devadasan was overruled (para 98).
- Article 16(4) does not permit reservation in promotions, with prospective effect (para 121).
- Reservation on economic criteria alone is invalid; the 10% economic quota fell (paras 115, 122).
Case explainer by NyayVidhan: an account of this judgment and the law it laid down, not the court's text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.
Brief Facts
Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)
- Must a provision under Article 16(4) be made by legislation, or can an executive order make it?
- Is Article 16(4) an exception to Article 16(1), and can reservations be made under Article 16(1)?
- Can caste identify a backward class, and must the creamy layer be excluded?
- Can a backward class be identified, or a reservation made, on economic criteria alone?
- Is there a 50% limit on reservations, and was Devadasan correctly decided?
- Does Article 16(4) permit reservation in promotions?
- Are the two Office Memoranda valid?
Submissions
For the petitioners. A provision under Article 16(4) affects other citizens' fundamental rights and can be made only by the legislature (para 55). Caste can never be the basis of identification; a survey must go from individual to individual (para 62). Some members of the designated classes are as advanced as any forward class and take the benefits meant for the truly backward, so the creamy layer must go (para 86). The Mandal Commission's caste-based approach divided the nation into forward and backward sections (para 118A).
For the Union of India and the States. The Union objected that reservation in promotion did not arise, as the Memoranda confined reservation to direct recruitment (para 101). Bihar, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and other respondents opposed any creamy-layer test as a ruse to deprive the backward classes of reservation (para 86). Where the backward classes exceed half the population, their reservation may also be 50% (para 94). Errors in the Commission's work are no ground for rejecting its report (para 118A).
Court's Findings
Legislation or executive order
A provision under Article 16(4) need not be made by Parliament or a Legislature: the executive, and local bodies, statutory corporations and other instrumentalities of the State, can make it, and an executive order is enforceable the moment it is made and issued (paras 55-56, 121).
Article 16(4) and Article 16(1)
Agreeing with the majority in Thomas, the Court held that clause (4) is not an exception to clause (1) but an instance of the classification implicit in it (para 57). Clause (4) is exhaustive of reservation for backward classes, but reservations for other classes can be made under clause (1), within the level prescribed for backward classes (paras 58, 60, 121).
Caste and the creamy layer
A caste can be, and quite often is, a social class; among non-Hindus, occupational groups, sects and denominations can be backward social collectives. Identification may begin with castes so long as the survey covers the entire populace (para 121). The accent is on social backwardness; the class under Article 16(4) is wider than that of Article 15(4) and need not resemble the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (para 121). Members far too advanced socially snap the connecting thread with their class; excluding them, such as the children of a member of an All India Service, leaves a truly backward class. The Government of India was directed to specify the basis of exclusion, a discussion confined to the Other Backward Classes (para 86).
Economic criteria
A backward class cannot be identified only and exclusively by economic criteria, though occupation-cum-income without reference to caste is permissible (para 121). Even under Article 16(1), reservations cannot be made on economic criteria alone (para 122). The 10% reservation for economically backward sections of the open category failed: barring a citizen solely on income or property-holding is inconsistent with Article 16(1) (para 115). Backward classes may, however, be categorised as backward and more backward (para 92A).
The 50% rule and Devadasan
Clause (4) speaks of adequate, not proportionate, representation, and a majority of seats was never envisaged: reservations under it should not exceed 50%, save in extraordinary situations such as far-flung and remote areas, with extreme caution (para 94A). The rule governs reservations proper, not horizontal reservations or concessions (para 95), and a year is the unit (para 96). Devadasan, which struck down a carry-forward rule, was overruled; such a rule must not breach the 50% rule (paras 98-99).
Promotions
Disagreeing with Rangachari, the Court held that Article 16(4) does not permit reservation in promotions (para 107). The ruling operates only prospectively: existing reservations in promotion may continue for five years, and concessions and relaxations remain open if efficiency is not compromised (para 121). Justice Ahmadi expressed no opinion, upholding the Union's preliminary objection (para 122).
The two Memoranda
The 1990 Memorandum is valid subject to excluding the socially advanced; clause (i) of the 1991 Memorandum stands only if read as distinguishing backward and more backward classes by degrees of social backwardness; clause (ii) is invalid (para 124). The Court directed permanent bodies for complaints of over-inclusion and under-inclusion, creamy-layer criteria within four months, and all challenges only in the Supreme Court (para 123).
Separate Opinions
What Changes
Legal Principle
NyayVidhan's view · Practice note
Why It Matters
Indra Sawhney remains the starting point for disputes on reservation in public employment. Its core holdings are that a caste can be a backward class, that the creamy layer must be excluded from the Other Backward Classes (para 86), that reservations under Article 16(4) should not exceed 50% save in extraordinary situations (para 94A), and that economic criteria alone cannot identify a backward class (para 121). Read it with care: Justice Ahmadi expressed no opinion on promotions (para 122), the creamy-layer discussion is confined to the Other Backward Classes (para 86), and the 50% rule applies to reservations proper, not to horizontal reservations or concessions (para 95). Later Supreme Court rulings on this site return to these questions, among them Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India on reservation for economically weaker sections, Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta on reservation in promotion and The State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh on sub-classification.
Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.
Precedents Relied Upon
- M.R. Balaji & Ors. v. State of Mysore [1963] Suppl. 1 S.C.R. 439
A Constitution Bench rejected the argument that, absent a limit in Article 15(4), the court could prescribe none, and held that reservation must be reasonable and generally below 50%. Followed: reservations under Article 16(4) should not exceed 50%, save in extraordinary situations.
- T. Devadasan v. Union of India [1964] 4 S.C.R. 680
The majority struck down a carry-forward rule because, with carried-forward vacancies, reservation in a year could exceed 50%. Overruled: the Court agreed with Krishna Iyer J. in Karamchari Sangh, took a year as the unit and held only that a carry-forward rule must not breach the 50% rule.
- General Manager, Southern Railway v. Rangachari [1962] 2 S.C.R. 586
Held, by majority, that reservation under Article 16(4) extends to promotion to selection posts. Not followed: the Court held that Article 16(4) does not permit reservation in promotions, with prospective effect.
View all precedents (14)
- State of Kerala & Ors. v. N.M. Thomas [1976] 1 S.C.R. 906
The majority held that Article 16(4) is not an exception to Article 16(1) but an emphatic statement of a principle implicit in it. Held to be the correct view.
- State of Madras v. Champakam Dorairajan [1951] S.C.R. 525
A Special Bench of seven Judges held a communal order allotting college seats by caste violative of Articles 15(1) and 29(2); Article 15(4) was then inserted. Recounted as the start of the case law.
- State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. U.S.V. Balram [1972] 3 S.C.R. 247
Justified the division of the backward classes of Andhra Pradesh into groups sharing the reserved vacancies. Relied on to hold that backward classes may be categorised as backward and more backward.
- Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan [1968] 1 S.C.R. 111
Government may issue executive instructions on matters on which the statutory service rules are silent. Relied on to hold the impugned Memoranda enforceable when issued.
- Comptroller and Auditor General v. Mohanlal Mehrotra [1990] 2 S.C.C. 1
Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes can be directed by executive order where the rules are silent. Relied on likewise.
- K.S.Jayasree & Anr. v. State of Kerala & Anr. [1977] 1 S.C.R.194
A means test imposed by the Kerala Government. Noted in tracing the creamy-layer argument, which the Court accepted for the Other Backward Classes.
- K.C.Vasant Kumar & Anr. v. State of Karnataka [1985] Suppl. 1 S.C.R. 352
Five separate opinions on identifying backward classes, the means test and the 50% rule. Discussed at length; Chandrachud CJ.’s suggestion of periodic revision of the lists was adopted.
- Comptroller and Auditor General v. K.S. Jagannathan [1986] 2 S.C.R. 17
Stated that reservation under Article 16(4) extends to promotions. Noted among the decisions following Rangachari.
- State of M.P. v. Nivedita Jain [1982] 1 S.C.R. 759
Upheld the removal of minimum qualifying marks for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates in medical admissions under Article 15. Distinguished: under Article 16, Article 335 does not permit doing away with a minimum standard.
- Janaki Prasad Parimoo v. State of Jammu & Kashmir [1973] 3 S.C.R. 236
Poverty alone cannot be the basis for identifying social and educational backwardness. Noted in tracing the case law.
- State of Uttar Pardesh v. Pradip Tandon [1975] 2 S.C.R. 761
Poverty alone cannot be the basis for identifying social and educational backwardness. Noted likewise.

