Judgment Intelligence
Petition Dismissed- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of Decision
- 18 September 2014
- Bench
- Chief Justice R.M. Lodha and Justices Kurian Joseph and Rohinton Fali Nariman
- Relevant Acts & Sections
- Indian Evidence Act, 1872 — Sections 3, 22A, 45A, 59, 62, 63, 65, 65A and 65B; Representation of the People Act, 1951 — Sections 100(1)(b) and 123(4); Information Technology Act, 2000
Appeal dismissed. The CDs were inadmissible without a Section 65B certificate and no reliable evidence showed the first respondent's consent to the leaflet, so no corrupt practice under Section 100(1)(b) read with Section 123(4) was proved; no order as to costs (paras 23, 37, 40-41).
Source Supreme Court of India, judgment dated 18 September 2014 · Court's copy
Key holdings
- Sections 65A and 65B are a complete code; Sections 63 and 65 do not apply to secondary evidence of electronic records (paras 19, 22).
- A computer output is admissible only if the four conditions of Section 65B(2) are satisfied (para 13).
- The Section 65B(4) certificate identifies the record and the device, describes how the record was produced, deals with the Section 65B(2) conditions and is signed by a responsible official (para 14).
- The certificate must accompany the CD, VCD, chip or printout when it is produced (paras 15, 22).
- Without Section 65B compliance, an electronic record cannot be proved by oral evidence (para 17).
- Navjot Sandhu was overruled to the extent it admitted such evidence under Sections 63 and 65 (para 22).
- An electronic record used as primary evidence under Section 62 needs no Section 65B certificate (para 24).
- A corrupt practice under Section 123(4) needs proof of consent, not connivance, to the standard of a criminal charge (paras 30, 39).
Case explainer by NyayVidhan: an account of this judgment and the law it laid down, not the court's text. The judgment itself is the authoritative version.
Brief Facts
Questions before the Court (framed by NyayVidhan)
- How must an electronic record be proved under the Evidence Act, and what must a Section 65B(4) certificate contain?
- Can secondary evidence of an electronic record be given under Sections 63 and 65 without complying with Section 65B, as Navjot Sandhu had held?
- Were the appellant's CDs admissible in evidence?
- Was the leaflet printed and distributed with the first respondent's consent, so as to make out a corrupt practice under Section 123(4)?
- What standard of proof applies to a charge of corrupt practice?
Submissions
For the appellant. On the leaflet, the appellant contended that it was printed and published with the first respondent's knowledge and consent (para 29), and that consent should be inferred from his connivance in the printing and publication (para 30). He also contended that consent had to be inferred from the circumstances of printing and distribution, relying strongly on two witnesses who said that bundles of the leaflet were taken in two jeeps and distributed throughout the constituency on the night before the poll (paras 31-32).
For the first respondent. The judgment records that both sides were heard and that the major thrust of the arguments was on the electronic records (paras 4-5), but it does not set out the first respondent's submissions.
Court's Findings
Proving an electronic record
An electronic record produced for the court's inspection is documentary evidence (para 6). Read with Sections 59 and 65A, it can be proved only by the procedure in Section 65B, which opens with a non obstante clause: a computer output is deemed a document, admissible without production of the original, only if the four conditions of Section 65B(2) are satisfied (para 13). Where a statement is to be given in evidence, Section 65B(4) requires a certificate that identifies the record, describes how it was produced, gives particulars of the device, deals with the Section 65B(2) conditions and is signed by a person holding a responsible official position in relation to the device, to the best of that person's knowledge and belief (paras 14-15). The certificate must accompany the printout, CD, VCD or pen drive when it is produced, because these safeguards secure the source and authenticity of records that are more susceptible to tampering (para 15). Genuineness, and an examiner's opinion under Section 45A, arise only after due production; without Section 65B compliance, oral evidence cannot prove the record (paras 16-17).
Sections 63 and 65 and Navjot Sandhu
Proof of electronic records is a special provision introduced by the IT Act; Section 65B is a complete code, and the general law in Sections 63 and 65 must yield (para 19). In Navjot Sandhu, a two-Judge Bench had held that printouts of call records could be led as secondary evidence under Sections 63 and 65 irrespective of compliance with Section 65B (paras 20-21). Applying the maxim that special law prevails over general law, the Court held that the earlier Bench omitted to notice Sections 59 and 65A, that Sections 63 and 65 have no application to secondary evidence by way of electronic record, and that its statement of law on the point was not correct; to that extent it was overruled (para 22).
The appellant's CDs
No Section 65B certificate was produced for the CDs, so they could not be admitted, and the case built on songs, announcements and speeches fell with them (para 23). The position would have been different had the CDs actually used for the songs or announcements been seized through the police or the Election Commission and produced as primary evidence: an electronic record used as primary evidence under Section 62 is admissible without the Section 65B conditions (para 24). The ground on announcements, resting on one such uncertified CD, failed for the same reason (para 36).
Consent for the leaflet
Under Section 100(1)(b) the corrupt practice must be committed by the returned candidate, his election agent, or another person with the consent of either, and Section 123(4) requires consent, not knowledge (paras 29-30). Connivance is different from consent (para 30). Consent may be inferred from circumstances, but they must form a chain leading to a reasonable conclusion of consent (para 31). Here the persons said to connect the first respondent with the printing were not examined, the evidence showed 1,000 copies printed against the 25,000 alleged, and the complaint lodged for the appellant on 13.04.2011 alleged only knowledge and connivance (paras 28, 31). The evidence on distribution was inconsistent, and the two jeeps were used by UDF workers, not exclusively by the first respondent (paras 33-35). There was no reliable evidence of consent (para 37).
Standard of proof
A charge of corrupt practice is substantially akin to a criminal charge and cannot be established by a mere balance of probabilities; following Razik Ram and P.C. Thomas, a doubt that remains after the evidence is weighed benefits the returned candidate (para 39).
What Changes
Legal Principle
NyayVidhan's view · Practice note
Why It Matters
Anvar P.V. made the Section 65B certificate the gateway for electronic evidence offered as a copy: a CD, VCD, chip or printout produced as secondary evidence is inadmissible without it, and oral evidence cannot fill the gap (paras 17, 22). The ruling overruled, to that extent, the contrary statement of law in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, which had allowed such records to be proved under Sections 63 and 65 (paras 20-22). In practice, a party relying on a recording should obtain the certificate when the copy is taken, signed by a person responsible for the device and covering the matters in Section 65B(4) (paras 14-15, 22). Where the electronic record itself, such as the CD actually used for an announcement, is produced as primary evidence under Section 62, the Section 65B conditions do not apply (para 24). The election half of the judgment is a reminder that consent, not knowledge or connivance, must be proved, and to the standard of a criminal charge (paras 29-30, 39).
Editorial comment by the NyayVidhan Editorial Desk. It is not part of the Court's judgment and is not legal advice.
Precedents Relied Upon
- State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu alias Afsan Guru (2005) 11 SCC 600
A two-Judge Bench had held that printouts of call records could be led as secondary evidence under Sections 63 and 65 irrespective of compliance with Section 65B; that statement of law on secondary evidence of electronic records was held not to lay down the correct legal position and was overruled (paras 20-22).
- Charan Lal Sahu v. Giani Zail Singh and another (1984) 1 SCC 390
Quoted: connivance does not invariably amount to consent, consent implying that the parties are ad idem; applied to reject the plea that consent to the leaflet should be inferred from connivance (para 30).
- Sheopat Singh v. Harish Chandra and another AIR 1960 SC 1217
Consent to a corrupt practice may be inferred from the circumstances; the Court added that the circumstances must form a chain leading to a reasonable conclusion of consent (para 31).
View all precedents (6)
- Ram Sharan Yadav v. Thakur Muneshwar Nath Singh and others (1984) 4 SCC 649
Quoted for the considerations that guide the appreciation of evidence in corrupt-practice cases, including the totality of the evidence; on that footing it was unsafe to connect the returned candidate with the distribution (para 35).
- Razik Ram v. Jaswant Singh Chouhan and others (1975) 4 SCC 769
A charge of corrupt practice is substantially akin to a criminal charge and cannot be established by a mere balance of probabilities (para 39).
- P.C. Thomas v. P.M. Ismail and others (2009) 10 SCC 239
Quoted as following Razik Ram: proof of a corrupt practice is as in a criminal charge, and a remaining doubt benefits the returned candidate, without stretching the standard so far as to make proof impossible (para 39).



